August 19, 2005
Its disgusting that you legitimize this fraudulent meme of the Left, Rusty.
The meme SPQR is talking about is the often-repeated phrase "chickenhawk" tossed at war supporters who haven't served in the military, or (since G.W. Bush is a veteran, and therefore passes the test) haven't served in combat. Yes, it is a meme, but Rusty isn't legitimizing it. In fact, quite the opposite. I'm certainly willing to stipulate that anyone who has been in combat has more "moral authority" than I to comment on the war, and I imagine Rusty is as well. But that's only one kind of authority, and it doesn't beatify any single veteran, which is apparently what the Left believes. Though Max Cleland has more moral authority than I, I have more intellectual authority. And to the extent that my intellect is consistent with what is right, and what has the greatest chance of saving the most lives and preserving civilization, I also have more moral clarity than Max does. That ought to count for something. Heck, it ought to count for quite a lot.
But the "chickenhawk" concept is fraudulent because it presumes:
1. That everyone who hasn't been in combat is assumed to be a coward; and
2. That, therefore, only those who have been in combat can legitimately support the war.
Which, of course, doesn't mean that assumed cowards can't oppose the war. According to the meme this is entirely consistent and morally non-problematic. What they can't do is support it; because, well... that'd be hypocritical. By such logic it's hypocritical to support criminal convictions and sentencing if you're not willing to apprehend the criminals yourself. And only those who are demonstrably willing to serve as policemen can cast a jury vote with any validity, or far that matter deserve protection from crime. So the options for an "assumed coward" (anyone who hasn't been in combat) are either to oppose the war, or shut the heck up.
And it isn't lost on these folks that combat veterans are vastly outnumbered by assumed cowards in our society, which guarantees the result they seek.
BUT if moral authority is a valid concept, and I think it is, even though I'm not willing to stipulate that it's everything, then only the votes of combat veterans carry significant weight one way or the other in that personal moral dimension. Robert Heinlein's SciFi classic Starship Troopers exemplifies this concept, by differentiating between "civilians," who haven't volunteered to serve in combat, and "citizens" who have.
So, the bottom line is that Rusty's project has merit, because intuitively its premise is that veterans have more moral weight in the debate, reflecting greater moral authority. And if that's the criterion, then our side almost certainly wins.
The thing that's fraudulent about the "chickenhawk" concept, is that it disenfranchises only the opposition, based not on some uniform criterion, but on their prospective vote.
Which, of course, is not only dumb but immoral.
(Cross-posted by Demosophist to Demosophia)
Posted by: Demosophist at
02:22 AM
| Comments (12)
| Add Comment
Post contains 512 words, total size 3 kb.
THAT TOO is why Rusty's project has merit. Idiots like that guy.
Posted by: Oyster at August 19, 2005 06:52 AM (YudAC)
Posted by: Howie at August 19, 2005 09:02 AM (D3+20)
But the main problem I have is one of the premises in the Chickenhawk discourse, that military/combat experience gives one moral authority. Morality is concerned with what is right, what is good, and what is virtuous, and, according to the American Heritage Dictionary, is "based on strong likelihood or firm conviction, rather than on the actual evidence: a moral certainty.
I believe people, deceptively or otherwise, are substituting the use of "moral" for "empirical," meaning "Relying on or derived from observation or experiment: empirical results that supported the hypothesis;" or "Verifiable or provable by means of observation or experiment: empirical laws" or "Guided by practical experience and not theory, especially in medicine." The problem with this is that one person's empirical observations prove useful only in terms of what they themselves can replicate, such as how to behave in combat, but not in terms of applying this to a larger, unrelated sphere, such as strategy. Even a greater sampling of soldiers will only yield information on how to soldier, not how to strategize a war.
So whatever the anti-chickenhawks call themselves, they have no more authority on the war in Iraq to claim, moral or otherwise, than any other informed observer, unless you change the argument entirely. I therefore find Rusty's correlation between service, bias and opinion to be very interesting.
Posted by: tee bee at August 19, 2005 09:55 AM (q1JHF)
{Jerome} Armstrong: Markos started reading MyDD in 2001, and was one of the first people to write comments on my postings. He emailed me to tell me he was starting his own blog, Fishy Shark in 2002, which I linked to. Later, he started DailyKos.
We started e-mailing back and forth, and he {Kos}told me near the end of that year (2002) that he was going to stop blogging because he was about to start working for the State department.
I was already talking to the Dean folks and Trippi was asking me to build a blog and other stuff. I knew Markos had a strong computer background, and so I invited him up to Portland where I was living, and so we gelled in a day or two.
cite
This sort of parallels the story of Fidel Castro, then aspiring baseball pitcher, not getting called up by the Yankees back in the 50s. Had Markos gone to work at the State Department, had DailyKos not gone through its growth and had the influence that it did -- who knows what would have happened?
My guess: President Kerry.
~ and ~
not to mention now the State Department has lost out on that clear-headed pragmatic world view that Markos "You know the Quote" Moulitsas brings to the table.
Thanks, Kos!!
Posted by: BumperStickerist at August 19, 2005 10:02 AM (EgPEq)
Posted by: Downing Street Memo at August 19, 2005 10:04 AM (90EsJ)
Posted by: tee bee at August 19, 2005 10:11 AM (q1JHF)
Now there's something that has to make DSM happy.
Posted by: jesusland joe at August 19, 2005 10:27 AM (DDXXI)
But the main problem I have is one of the premises in the Chickenhawk discourse, that military/combat experience gives one moral authority. Morality is concerned with what is right, what is good, and what is virtuous, and, according to the American Heritage Dictionary, is "based on strong likelihood or firm conviction, rather than on the actual evidence: a moral certainty.
Actually, I think the term "moral authority" is misleading, because it simply means that the person who has it also has a low probability of being hypocritical in terms of physical courage. I have no problem with that, but it's different from "moral clarity," which has a great deal more to do with morality, justice, and even validity. There's also experiencial and expert authority.
I agree that everyone ought to be paying some price for this war, and it's ironic that one reason it has become unpopular is precisely because the costs are borne so narrowly. We aren't yet invested in it, as a nation.
Posted by: Demosophist at August 19, 2005 10:49 AM (0sVKo)
* donate blood - You've had 12 opportunities to donate blood since the war started, how many times have you actually donated blood?
* donate time/money - Have you donated time or money to a charitable cause for either the troops or the families of the troops.
There doesn't have to be a specific level reached for either dollars or blood, but people who just bang away on a keyboard on either side might consider doing either of the above.
Posted by: BumperStickerist at August 19, 2005 11:54 AM (EgPEq)
Posted by: A Finn at August 19, 2005 11:59 AM (lGolT)
Dem, I wonder if the whole notion of "authority" isn't another linguistic red herring. When words have their meanings twisted and facts such as pre-war intelligence are regularly discounted by one side, it's difficult to have much faith in managing a reasonable discussion. Such chicanery is typical of people who will use any means to get what they want.
You mentioned on my post that there was a use of the term, moral authority. Is this among historians? I'm liberal arts, so I have some history along with the social sciences and lit. In my academic and personal reading, I've never come across it. Thanks.
Posted by: tee bee at August 19, 2005 05:54 PM (q1JHF)
I have tried to donate every chance I can,
but unfortunately for me, I was in Germany in
1982 for more than 6 months. (Mad cow disease.)
I go in everytime, and I am denied. But I am told
to come back next time because they "might"
have a test to tell if I have MCD. MOOOOOOOOOO.
I have also donated several tins of cookies,
and crayons.
Posted by: Butch at August 22, 2005 03:49 PM (Gqhi9)
34 queries taking 0.0844 seconds, 167 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.









