February 06, 2007

More on Rudy and Guns

I think this commenter may have it about right:

He needs to change his thought patterns if he wants to win. . . . He needs a 2nd Amendment advisor or he is going to end up losing the election.
A lot of smart people have been saying this for a long time. Gun control is a landmine for Rudy Giuliani. When it comes to guns, Rudy's got a terrible track record to deal with. So far, his message sucks. Based on Rudy's messaging on guns, I'll guarantee you most gun owners are still actively shopping around. If Rudy doesn't get some solid advice on guns and start listening to it, gun control could be the issue that sinks his candidacy.

Why is gun control such an issue? Because it's an issue on which Rudy's closer to the Democrats, and everybody knows it. The Dems will very likely retain control of the House and Senate in 2008. If the Dems control the House and Senate after 2008, there's a very likely scenario in which the only thing standing between us and new federal gun control laws is a presidential veto.

Would Rudy Giuliani be willing to veto a re-enactment of the Brady Bill waiting period or the Scary-looking Weapons Ban of 1994? Based on his track record, and his massaging so far in this campaign, I wouldn't bet on it--and that's going to be a real issue for Rudy as this campaign heats up.

Posted by: Ragnar at 10:01 AM | Comments (16) | Add Comment
Post contains 247 words, total size 2 kb.

1 Rudy's selection for the #2 spot on the ticket could be the answer. If he were to pick someone like Duncan Hunter, he could temper the criticism of being too liberal on social issues as Hunter is more conservative being pro life and enjoying a five star rating by the NRA. In addittion he would be strong on the war on terror as he demonstrated by  calling the dems out on their whining about pulling the troops out. I am pro gun. I have reservations about Giuliani for that reason. But many in Congress today are pro gun also as 'conservative' democrats were added to the ranks in the last election.
 
The most challenging problem we face today is terrorism. If we can't win the war on terror, nothing else will matter. Guiliani has the fire in his belly to stand firm in that fight. I remember him standing up to Arafat in New York years ago. The attack on the trade center was taken personally by Rudy as it should be by us all.
 
Despite my reservations, I think Rudy is a strong leader and would make a fine president. I only hope he picks someone like Duncan Hunter to round out the ticket.

Posted by: Billy at February 06, 2007 11:26 AM (1SzWp)

2 Guiliani would be a tough, ant-jihadist warrior if elected President.  The gun thing doesn't bother me much either.  After all, if guns were a reliable check against terrorism, then Baghdad would be as safe as Mission Viejo, CA.  What would bother me more is his stance on abortion since I'm a social conservative, but I'd be willing to put even that aside in exchange for a strong national security policy. 

If Rudy gets the nomination, then I'll vote Republican in 2008 without hesitation.

Posted by: NorthernCross at February 06, 2007 02:38 PM (Jwdal)

3 If Guiliani actually holds to his promise to appoint "strict constructionists" (a phrase even Scalia says implies a judge too far to the right), then Guiliani's abortion stance is irrelevant.  Strict constructionists will find no federal right to abortion, and Roe v. Wade will be overturned, returning the abortion question to the states.  This is a very simple concept for the public to understand even in the face of media spin, and I don't think the abortion issue will stop Guiliani.

The gun issue remains a little trickier.  Assuming we get the promised court justices, we don't need to worry about the likes of the Brady bill, even if Guiliani would let it slide without a veto.  However, the Second Amendment has not been held to fully bind the states.  States like California (where I live) can continue to screw with us through oppressive regulation.  It sounds like Rudy is a big fan of the state regulation authority, so that's bad news to us in Cali or NY, but it won't matter to most states (which protect your rights).  But that's the status quo, and NOBODY on the right, even Duncan Hunter, can control the state gun regulations from the presidency.  It's a moot point. But this is a much more convoluted area of law, as the SCOTUS has not really delineated just how much regulation is permissible on the federal level. 

Posted by: wooga at February 06, 2007 03:45 PM (t9sT5)

4 If Guiliani ever promised to appoint "strict constructionists" to the Supremes, then I suspect that his definition of "strict construction" is a bit more malleable than most social conservatives would have thought.  I can see him appointing Justices who would expand the foundation of "construction" to include decades-old case law in order to philosophically embrace abortion as a constitutional right.  "Of course I'm a stict constructionist.  We should absolutely follow Roe to the letter!"

Posted by: Northern Cross at February 06, 2007 04:25 PM (Jwdal)

5 Ahhh, it's so nice to see Republicans lay aside their differences and to build a consensus on the issues they really care about.  Abortion? No big deal.  Gun control?  No problem.  Gay marriage?  Pleanty of room for compromise.  Serial adultery over the course of his three marriages?  Oh well, nobody's perfect.
 
Yup, the Republican base will support Rudy because he's got an abudance of the single attribute they care about more than any other, and that will lead them to forgive any shortcoming in a candidate; he's a racist thug who that knows how to keep blacks and Mexicans in their place.

Posted by: legaleagle at February 06, 2007 04:49 PM (fMQ6j)

6 Dems,....... Infidelity? I never had sex with that woman,er, those women. Lie to a Grand Jury? I never had sex with that woman. Hide documents? Gee, how did THOSE get in my bedroom! Hide documents? Who put MY fingerprints on those documents in my bedroom. I'll bet Vince did it, where's Vince? Can anybody find Vince? Hide documents? Hey, let me just stuff these in my pants or socks until I can hide them under the trailer.  Racism? I know alot of clean blacks. Religious intolerance? Hey, I've got two tickets to Hymie town this weekend. Slander, Libel, Sedition? The president of the United States is guilty of genocide by hurricane. Protect the homeland? Ah heck, just pop a couple of missiles off, I have a date tonight. Protect the homeland? For chrissake, don't shoot any more missiles, we wouldn't want to be accused of wagging the dog here, it was just a big boat anyway, we can fix it.Besides, it'll just piss em off. Stand behind our troops? Nah, they're just a bunch of uneducated dummies anyway. You saw how those idiots slept too close to the windows in Kohbar, didn't you. Swear on the Bible? You won't mind if I use my Koran, will you. Sing the National Anthem? Damn, where did that teleprompter go. Rescue swimming? Heck, that would make me miss the rest of the party, besides, I wasn't driving, really I wasn't. I don't even have a drivers license. Let's work together in a spirit of nonpartisanship.? Hey, how did you get in here, who's watching the damn door. Didn't you support the war? Well, my wife had breast cancer at the time so I wasn't thinking.

Posted by: Billy at February 06, 2007 06:11 PM (1SzWp)

7 He's also the same or close to the Dems on a massive amnesty for IllegalAliens.

Posted by: Rudy Rudy Rudy at February 06, 2007 06:41 PM (3xSIU)

8 A president can't make a law.  I do not believe for a moment that Rudy would or even could if he wanted to, take away our legally owned guns if he were president.  Just because someone holds an opinion, it doesn't always follow that they want to impose their opinion on other people.


The major issue for me is national security and sane leadership.  I trust Rudy more than I trust any other candidate, his personal opinions on issues notwithstanding.  As long as I don't see any indication of Rudy being activist in his gun control position, he is fine with me.

One important thing is that Rudy takes away the social agenda from the Democrats.  This will hold the national security issue in stark contrast. Oh, and a Rudy/Lieberman ticket would probably blow the Dems right out of the water.

The important thing to remember is that the base means nothing in the national elections.  The base is important during primary season but once you get to the national election, the independents decide the winner.  Whichever candidate takes the mose independents will win.  That is why I say that the candidate who wins Texas will win the election.  Texas independents outnumber both Democrats and Republicans.  The candidate who takes Texas will likely take the entire country.

Posted by: crosspatch at February 06, 2007 07:14 PM (zECyY)

9 He has to fix his position on guns to get to second place in my preferences. If he can fix his stance on abortion, he could be tied for first. I still like Romney, and I do trust McCain's patriotism.
                             USA, all the way!

Posted by: Michael Weaver at February 06, 2007 07:17 PM (2OHpj)

10 Yup, the Republican base will support Rudy because he's got an abudance
of the single attribute they care about more than any other, and that
will lead them to forgive any shortcoming in a candidate; he's a racist thug who that knows how to keep blacks and Mexicans in their place.
So.... by favoring amnesty Rudy is keeping Mexicans in their place? And just how is Rudy keeping the black man down?

Face it - only one party rallies behind a klansman. Only one party thinks blacks are too stupid to succeed without a handout. Only one party refuses to allow school vouchers, even though some 90% of blacks want them.  After all, the Democrats have to keep their core constituency poor and uneducated. Right, 'legaleagle'?

Posted by: wooga at February 06, 2007 08:19 PM (t9sT5)

11

Legaleagle: Shit another commie wannabe left out. No we will not accept gay marriage. I know that one breaks your heart.


 


 


All of you are nuts. It's going to be Newt and Rudy. Or Rudy and Newt. Then everything will be as it should. Even if we have to go to the streets with axe handles.


Posted by: greyrooster at February 06, 2007 09:33 PM (Lf9lR)

12 Newt and Rudy v. Gore and Obama.  I'd love to see it happen.

Posted by: NorthernCross at February 07, 2007 12:11 AM (7vz05)

13 Face it - only one party rallies behind a klansman. Only one party thinks blacks are too stupid to succeed without a handout. Only one party refuses to allow school vouchers, even though some 90% of blacks want them.
 
Ahh, yes, of course; it's the Democratic Party that is the real bastion of racism in the United States.  Too bad those silly, stubborn blacks just won't face reality.  Kind of how the Jews refuse to accept the notorious anti-semitism of the Democratic Party.  The message must be getting through, though, because the level of Jewish support for the Democrats is all the way down to eighty-seven percent!! 
 
He has to fix his position on guns to get to second place in my preferences. If he can fix his stance on abortion, he could be tied for first.
 
Oh, now that is a profoundly compelling statement of principle if I've ever heard one!  So much for the ususal Republican accusations of flip-flopping.  After all, nothing wrong with a little pandering, as long as you're heart's is the right place, right?

Posted by: legaleagle at February 07, 2007 01:25 PM (fMQ6j)

14 Ahh, yes, of course; it's the Democratic Party that is the real bastion of racism in the United States.
Well it is. The Republican party happens to be the bastion of "economic classism."  That's why wealthy blacks vote Republican, and poor blacks vote Democrat.  The economics take priority over race.

More important to party affiliation, however, is the belief in social mobility.  The Democratic agenda is premised on the notion that social mobility is an unattainable capitalist dream, and so the gov't has to step in and works its own social engineering magic through the tax code and affirmative action.

As far as the Jewish vote, that's a known FDR holdover, coupled with jewish guilt dovetailing nicely with standard white liberal guilt.

Posted by: wooga at February 07, 2007 03:27 PM (t9sT5)

15

Legaleagle:


Fixing his stance would be not just talking the talk, but walking the walk. Some politicians never have a stance, and that is true across party lines. Some politicians have an honest change of heart as new information becomes available. We should expect that. The biggest problem we have is when someone lies about their change of stance. That is how I define flip flopping.  The second biggest problem comes from those who change their stance based on flawed information, and that can happen to honest politicians, as well as the crooks.



I don't think Rudy has the right information, or I believe he would take a better position. You see, I like him, and think he is basically a good guy. I don't think he would cheat on his wife and lie about it to the whole country if he was President.



It is easier to find someone who is already walking the walk, and so Rudy is not a front runner as far as I'm concerned.



Anyway, I'm suppossed to be asleep right now, so I'm outahere. catch y'all later.



US, all the way!


Posted by: Michael Weaver at February 08, 2007 06:44 AM (2OHpj)

16 Legalloophole:


Is an entitlement program enshrined in U.S. law which claims Blacks are inferior racist or not? How about slavery and Jim Crow?


Do dem Jooos benefit from affirmative action? No? Your blind racism is showing.

Posted by: Jeff Bargholz at February 08, 2007 10:09 AM (Dt3sl)

Hide Comments | Add Comment

Comments are disabled. Post is locked.
44kb generated in CPU 0.0126, elapsed 0.0524 seconds.
34 queries taking 0.0443 seconds, 171 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.