September 16, 2006

School for Scoundrels

Cross-posted from The Dread Pundit Bluto

NYT Teaches Reporters How to Flout Law

The Fitzpatrick Plame investigation has spurred the New York Times into examining how their reporters conduct themselves. Apparently, the Gray Lady wants her staff to act more like terrorists and drug dealers. Reporters are being told to delete emails, destroy notes, and use disposable cell phones in order to stymie future investigations.

From the New York Observer:

Mr. Barstow [NYT investigative reporter] said he suggests disposing of story drafts and cutting back on telephone and e-mail contact with sources—or using disposable cell phones for important calls. Reporters should be wary of meeting sources at their offices, Mr. Barstow said, so as to avoid sign-in sheets and security cameras.

In another point of conflict between bureaucracy and confidentiality, Mr. Barstow said he has recommended altering Times expense-sheet forms so that a reporter does not have to list the names of sources who have been taken out for lunch or dinner.

And what about the original paper trail that reporters create for themselves? The very first discussion question on Mr. Keller’s memo promoting the seminar was “Should a reporter keep his notes?”
This shouldn't surprise anyone. The New York Times has put profit ahead of ethics for quite a while.

From The Conservative Voice via Ace of Spades.

Posted by: Bluto at 04:06 PM | Comments (32) | Add Comment
Post contains 217 words, total size 2 kb.

1 The NYT doesn't put profit ahead of ethics, because their ethics allow any sort of activity that may be necessary to aid in the destruction of the communist masters' enemy - America. They are a bunch of seditious traitors and should all be shot.

Posted by: Improbulus Maximus at September 16, 2006 05:59 PM (v3I+x)

2 I am hearing rumblings of the type that may indicate there will be some sort of legal backlash against the Plame-Wilsons and Amrmatige.

Posted by: SeeMonk at September 16, 2006 08:01 PM (n4VvM)

3 SeeMonk, I must be misunderstanding... do you mean against Valerie Plame and her husband? Against Armitage I understand...

Posted by: Rich at September 16, 2006 10:04 PM (89Rw1)

4 This is sounding like a no-win scenario for the media. They want to use the tactics of a foreign intelligence agency, but they don't want the penalties spies face. So their solution is to start destroying their paper trails.

With all of the falsified stories, faked sources and faked documents in the news lately that may not be the best idea. No one can tell what's true if there is no evidence. It would be the reporters word that all the information contained was true. "Trust me I'm a journalist" doesn't work anymore post-Rathergate.

Posted by: nin10do at September 16, 2006 10:37 PM (JePW9)

5 The crazy cracker list keeps on growin. First a gay rooster, then a leathernut and now an impatient mofo who wants to shoot a newspaper. Youre a bunch of scared pussys

Posted by: Tyrone Washington at September 17, 2006 04:06 AM (DnP0U)

6 This isn't to protect the reporters. It's to protect their sources who break the law by leaking classified information. Reporters are already, supposedly, protected byt law on revealing sources. Judy Miller found out otherwise, but was released after three months anyway.

Amazing how Armitage was a blabber mouth when passing on supposed classified information about Plame yet, took the high ground ("But I was told not to say anything!") and clammed up when his own neck was on the line. Not a peep out of him during the entire investigation.

They're self-serving when they think they can get someone in trouble, but when it backfires, they're suddenly bastions of propriety - reporters and their leakers alike.

In order to be guilty of disclosing the name of an agent two things have to happen:
1) The agent has to be fully considered as covert status and
2) The leaker has to know that and willingly disclose their name. There has to be evidence that it was deliberate.

If Novak is telling the truth about the manner in which Armitage disclosed information on Plame, then by the standards stated in the law Armitage should be "frog-marched" off to jail.

Now - the reason Armitage isn't in jail tells us that A) Plame was not covert (as many will attest to) or B) Novak is lying about the way Armitage revealed her.

Or C) They're willingly overlooking the circumstances because it was far more important that Rove or Cheney be jailed and since neither could be, the mindset is, well, nevermind.

Posted by: Oyster at September 17, 2006 07:32 AM (YudAC)

7 Reporters and whistle-blowers should be protected. Under previous administrations (both Republican and Democrat) this was respected even though there is not federal press shield law. Under this administration it's not, that's why there's these questionable measure being taken.

As for Oyster's point about the plame crap, he's basically right, it appears no law was broken. Personally I think Armitage, Rove, Cheney and Libby should all have the pleasure of sharing a cell but, based on what is essentially a technicality ("I didn't know her status") they're in the clear (except Libby of course on a different charge altogether).

heh... flame on...

Posted by: Rich at September 17, 2006 09:58 AM (89Rw1)

8 Dammit. I had a nice, long rant in the making, and my comp took a shit, so I had to reboot. Oh well, I'll just summarize: All muslims are the enemies of civilization, and all lefturds are their allies in their war against us, and all members of both groups should be publicly burned alive. Discuss amonst yourselves.
How's that for flames Rich, you lefturd piece of shit?

Posted by: Improbulus Maximus at September 17, 2006 10:19 AM (v3I+x)

9 IM, I'm not actually on the left so I find your little rant mildly amusing if a bit misguided.

Painting people as allied with the enemy simply because they have the audacity disagree with you is an old tactic. It's most common use in modern times is by those groups you claim to most vehemently oppose. For example, Saddam's regime practiced the same tactics.

Those on both sides, especially the right, need to start realizing that we're all making our arguments out of patriotic thinking. It's the people that just plain don't care that need to be questioned.

Posted by: Rich at September 17, 2006 10:51 AM (89Rw1)

10 Rich, you poor, pathetic moron, you haven't disagreed with anything anyone has said; you've simply attempted to muddy the waters with equivocation by using the "both sides" argument, which only works on simpletons such as yourself. My position is simple: Anyone who threatens or conducts violence against me or my country is an enemy and must be destroyed, utterly and without mercy. Anyone who takes the side of such an enemy against me or my country is also an enemy, and must also be destroyed, utterly and without mercy. You are clearly a lefturd, despite your pitiful attempt to disguise yourself as something else, at which you fail completely, and identify yourself as such by clearly stating that your enemy is our President and his administration.
I don't hate you for the fact that you dislike the President, which is your right, and frankly, I don't care much for him myself, but he is the President, duly and legally elected, twice, to that office, despite what you contemptible, execrable, idiotic, conspiracy-theory-expounding lefturds say. And oh yeah, we're at war; a war which we didn't start, and which cannot be blamed on us in any way, because it started over 1400 years ago, once against despite what oxygen thieves like you say, but all idiots like you talk about is Bush this and Bush that. You're so fucking stupid you don't deserve to live, and about the only part of this whole sad state of affairs is that I know without a doubt that your beloved jihadis would give you a far more gruesome death than I would. So fuck off, grow some balls, and go join the jihad if you hate America so bad, and while you're at it, hope we never meet you slimy piece of shit lefturd.

Posted by: Improbulus Maximus at September 17, 2006 01:18 PM (v3I+x)

11 Tyrone, if you have something to say, please say it, but if you just want to be a "nigga" troll, go somewhere else.

Posted by: jesusland joe at September 17, 2006 02:54 PM (rUyw4)

12 Anonymity is quite important these days: look at the HP scandal. Several reporters had their phones compromised. If the laws won't protect us, we have to protect ourselves.

Posted by: actus at September 17, 2006 06:55 PM (NV0dI)

13 "Personally I think Armitage, Rove, Cheney and Libby should all have the pleasure of sharing a cell but, based on what is essentially a technicality ("I didn't know her status") they're in the clear (except Libby of course on a different charge altogether)."

You base that on the assumption that Plame was indeed covert. There are many who attest to that not being the case. So now we have two technicalities which, negates my point 1 AND point 2. There is no point three. There's nothing left. That makes it a non-issue.

Posted by: Oyster at September 17, 2006 06:56 PM (YudAC)

14 IM: re: your rant with Rich - sounded like a TKO. well-done.

Posted by: Heroic Dreamer at September 17, 2006 07:14 PM (fIUHw)

15 actus, do you claim to be a reporter?

Posted by: jesusland joe at September 17, 2006 07:17 PM (rUyw4)

16 Rectus isn't a reporter - just a traitor. It's even in his handle; actus is from actus reus, a Latin legal term that means "the guilty act", which constitutes the actual act of the crime, and coupled with mens rea, the "guilty mind", i.e. criminal intent, is sufficient to convict. He is basically telling us with his handle he is not on our side, as if his posts weren't enough.

Posted by: Improbulus Maximus at September 17, 2006 08:55 PM (v3I+x)

17 IM, again I find your ignorant and misguided rant amusing, kinda in the way people are amazed by idiot savants. I'm shocked that one person can, in some ways, expound their point so eloquently and in other ways demonstrate amazing levels of ignorance, stupidity and intolerance. I've actually made my point of view abundantly clear on this site, granted, you may have missed large amounts of that.

"Anyone who threatens or conducts violence against me or my country is an enemy and must be destroyed, utterly and without mercy. Anyone who takes the side of such an enemy against me or my country is also an enemy, and must also be destroyed, utterly and without mercy."

This I actually agree completely with and without caveat. Where we disagree is on my position for example. You seem, quite ignorantly, convinced that by not agreeing with you, I agree with the enemy. This couldn't be further from the truth. In fact, in other discussions on this very site I've said how I think enemies of the US should be dealt with quickly and effectively, and, preferably, violently.

"You are clearly a lefturd, despite your pitiful attempt to disguise yourself as something else, at which you fail completely, and identify yourself as such by clearly stating that your enemy is our President and his administration."

Again, unabashed stupidity and ignorance. Not once did I say "my enemy" is our president and his administration. I've said I think he's bad for this country, as do many on the right. Even you just said "I don't care much for him myself," if I were one to use your "tactics" I may wonder aloud if you're a terrorist sympathizer. Obviously, I know you aren't though, so, saying something like that would be irresponsible at the very best.

"but he is the President, duly and legally elected, twice, to that office, despite what you contemptible, execrable, idiotic, conspiracy-theory-expounding lefturds say."

Wow, this is amazing, one assumption pulled out of your ass after another. I agree, he was legally elected. I have no argument with that.

"And oh yeah, we're at war; a war which we didn't start, and which cannot be blamed on us in any way, because it started over 1400 years ago, once against despite what oxygen thieves like you say, but all idiots like you talk about is Bush this and Bush that."

lol... this is getting a little ridiculous. Not once did I say we started this war. The GWOT was certainly not our choice but, if I had things my way we'd win it quickly, effectively and unquestionably. Also, if you look back through many comments I've made, I've spent relatively little time discussing Bush, so it's hardly "Bush this and Bush that" with me. In fact, in this thread YOU were the first person to bring up Bush, oddly enough, to attack me for attacking Bush.

"You're so fucking stupid you don't deserve to live, and about the only part of this whole sad state of affairs is that I know without a doubt that your beloved jihadis would give you a far more gruesome death than I would. So fuck off, grow some balls, and go join the jihad if you hate America so bad, and while you're at it, hope we never meet you slimy piece of shit lefturd."

And again, this is a perfect demonstration of what's destroying my great country. Do I think you're functionally (just barely) retarded? Yes, I think you've shown that quite well. You are however entitled to your opinion and I certainly wouldn't wish death on you because of it. And, as if I had to say this, I wish nothing but death on the animals (jihadis) that attacked us and continue to try to attack us.

To continually try to frame the argument as "anyone who disagrees loves the terrorists" is just plain brain dead. I think it's people with your point of view that is doing more to help the terrorists and hurt my beloved country than I ever have. After all, you sound far, far more like one of those fanatics than I do. I don't however think you actually side with them, nor would I ever. Leveling that accusation at an American based solely on a disagreement is, in my opinion, vile and inhuman. It's a terrible thing to be called (even on the medium of some random net discussion) and isn't something that should be just tossed around the way you do. You obviously believe your approach to be best for the US and I disagree. Does something as simple as disagreeing with you make me a terrorist sympathizer?

Posted by: Rich at September 17, 2006 08:56 PM (89Rw1)

18 Oyster, you are of course absolutely right, and I should have been more clear. It was not common knowledge, in the general population, that she ever was CIA covert or not. Exposing that fact for a *political* reason is wrong (in my opinion) and that is why they should be in jail.

I'm aware obviously that my opinion doesn't, and shouldn't, put someone in jail though. So, that would be why I said it's "right" that they've been convicted of nothing.

Posted by: Rich at September 17, 2006 09:00 PM (89Rw1)

19 Rich, tell me: Precisely where do you draw the line between whistle-blowing and treason? The latter being anything from leaking classified information to leaking or publishing information that falsely implicates administration members.

I agree that our laws protect whistle-blowers for a good reason. They do not, however, protect reporters, nor should they, and reporters who knowingly engage in this kind of activity or other treasonous acts (like blowing open the SWIFT program or the NSA wiretapping) should most certainly not be protected, they should be prosecuted to the full extent of the law.

"Protecting whistleblowers" is simply the cover story for what these journalists are really doing, which is attempting to protect themselves from prosecution after they break the law. These people don't give a hoot about their sources, only themselves!

Posted by: Aaron G at September 17, 2006 09:23 PM (N71Wr)

20 Rich, it sounds to me like you fell for the Joe Wilson/NYT's crock of bull. Even the liberal, anti-Bush Washington Post has come out and repudiated Plamegate. The only person who should be in jail for this sordid affair is Joe Wilson.

Posted by: jesusland joe at September 17, 2006 09:27 PM (rUyw4)

21 Jesusland Joe, I'm saying this in all seriousness. I hadn't heard anything even remotely similar to what you said. A cursory search turned up nothing. I have no problem admitting when I'm wrong, care to provide a link to an article or something?

Posted by: Rich at September 17, 2006 09:31 PM (89Rw1)

22 Aaron G, I'll readily admit that's a tough line to define and it wouldn't surprise me if that's precisely why it's not defined yet. Personally, I think if an issue has broad civil liberties implications then "whistle-blowing" is appropriate. It's of course not quite as simple as that and wide open for debate.

I don't agree that reporters shouldn't be protected (in the instances of whistle-blowing). Who else will the government workers report the activity to? Their superiors? That's a joke.

Also just so you know where I stand, I thought it was good the wiretapping program was exposed but the SWIFT disclosure should be investigated.

Anyway, lets just say some program was exposed that you found personally offensive, what would you think of a press shield law then? Obviously the press does have a role in the betterment of our society, although, whether they're fulfilling that role now is certainly questionable.

Posted by: Rich at September 17, 2006 09:40 PM (89Rw1)

23 "actus, do you claim to be a reporter?"

No.

"He is basically telling us with his handle he is not on our side, as if his posts weren't enough."

What does your handle tell us IM? That you're all talk and no go?

Posted by: actus at September 17, 2006 10:01 PM (NV0dI)

24 Rich, go to LittleGreenFootballs, 09-01-06, 10:24am; Not with a bang, but a whimper: and read the post. It links to the story in the Washington Post. Or you can read Charles' take on it.

Posted by: jesusland joe at September 17, 2006 10:08 PM (rUyw4)

25 Jesusland Joe, thanks.

Posted by: Rich at September 17, 2006 10:14 PM (89Rw1)

26 You can just call me jj, Rich. All my friends do, haha!  I believe I have been called most of the worst things in English and French, and I am unsure of some of the Arabic insults, but I have been threatened with death by Islamists two times. I consider those to be my high points, and I am very proud of them.

Posted by: jesusland joe at September 17, 2006 10:24 PM (rUyw4)

27 Jesusland Joe, now that I've read that (The Post article and what was on LGF) I can say it doesn't really put everything to rest. It's simply a new angle on the old issue. The new angle is, admittedly, one I hadn't thought of and is thought provoking, certainly not something I could dismiss.

I will say though, it's not as clear a condemnation of the whole event as you make it out to be either. It even says "That's not to say that Mr. Libby and other White House officials are blameless."

I do agree with the point about Wilson too though. Since his wife put him on that mission and he came back making explosive charges, it's only logical that some reporter would get curious and find out who sent him.

I dunno, maybe we should just toss the whole lot of them in jail... Novak, Plame, Wilson, Libby, Cheney... hell, toss in Fitzgerald too. Seems like they all deserve each other.

Posted by: Rich at September 17, 2006 10:30 PM (89Rw1)

28 JJ, thanks, will do.

heh... most of the things I've been called most recently you can see in this very thread. I don't get much french insults, I've gotten Arabic and being from south florida, Spanish.

As for your death threats, hell yeah, they're a badge of honor.

Posted by: Rich at September 17, 2006 10:35 PM (89Rw1)

29 Nice try Rich, but we've seen enough of your kind around here to know you with our eyes shut. Take greg for example; he claims to be a loyal citizen, and espouses war on our enemies too, just like you claim to, but takes every opportunity to spread the enemy's propaganda. Things are not going to go well for your kind when the jihad comes in earnest, and according to experts, that shouldn't be long.

And Rectus; you should know by now that trying to turn the focus away from yourself doesn't work. Nobody here has any doubt about my position or loyalty, and I don't think very many have much doubt about yours either. You lefturds are all alike; you tell yourselves that you're intellectuals and like to think that your're smart, but you swallow, digest, and regurgitate the party lines of our enemies with gusto. Oh well, it won't be long before the likes of you, Rich, and gregturd get to see first-hand the results of your work, in the form of a jihadi as he cuts your throat.

Posted by: Improbulus Maximus at September 18, 2006 07:01 AM (v3I+x)

30 "You lefturds are all alike; you tell yourselves that you're intellectuals and like to think that your're smart, but you swallow, digest, and regurgitate the party lines of our enemies with gusto."

Party lines of the enemy? All I said is the law won't protect us so we have to protect ourselves. Get over yourself. Go tell the police you want all liberals dead.

"Oh well, it won't be long before the likes of you, Rich, and gregturd get to see first-hand the results of your work, in the form of a jihadi as he cuts your throat."

You mean they're going to beat you to it?

Posted by: actus at September 18, 2006 07:26 AM (NV0dI)

31 Rich, I still don't understand why you think any of them should be thrown in jail. "Exposing that fact for a *political* reason is wrong (in my opinion) and that is why they should be in jail." There is still no evidence other than a what few vivid imaginations have come up with, that her name was exposed for political reasons. Her name came up due to a political issue which Joe Wilson created himself. Later you state clearly that you understand why her name would come up due to a reporter's curiosity. That makes more sense than anything. It was simply a chain of events that culminated in over-reaction and accusations. I've said this all along.

Posted by: Oyster at September 18, 2006 09:00 AM (4wby6)

32 Rich, here is my take on it. The CIA, yes the CIA, or agents in the CIA, tried to take down a sitting President. Do you understand the significance of that? A coup, if you will. Does this not scare you? There was a conspirary in the CIA to hire the husband of a CIA agent to go to Niger, and do what? Was this man qualified? Why would not the CIA have sent one of their own, for instance? Or was there not an American embassy in Niger with agents in place who could have determined this? No, Rich, the real story has not come out yet. Who in the CIA ordered this trip? Who attempted a coup? You should be worried about this Rich, because it could happen again if they get away with it this time. That is my concern. What about the future? Yes, indeed, someone should go to jail, and for a hell of a long time.

Posted by: jesusland joe at September 18, 2006 09:19 AM (rUyw4)

Hide Comments | Add Comment

Comments are disabled. Post is locked.
54kb generated in CPU 0.0305, elapsed 0.0446 seconds.
34 queries taking 0.0326 seconds, 187 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.