August 08, 2006

Best Counter-Battery Fire Ever

Cross-posted from The Dread Pundit Bluto

Katyushas out:

getty.jpg

Caption:
Tyre, LEBANON: Katyusha rockets are fired from the outskirts of the southern Lebanese port city of Tyre into Israel, 06 August 2006. Israel's army will carry on fighting Hezbollah in southern Lebanon until two soldiers, whose capture sparked the conflict last month, are returned, its ambassador to Washington said today. EDS NOTE: CORRECTING DIRECTION OF SHELLING. AFP PHOTO/SAMUEL ARANDA (Photo credit should read SAMUEL ARANDA/AFP/Getty Images)

"Israeli rockets" in:

getty.jpg

Caption:
Tyre, LEBANON: Rockets fired from Israel are seen falling in the outskirts of the southern Lebanese port city of Tyre, 06 August 2006. Israel's army will carry on fighting Hezbollah in southern Lebanon until two soldiers, whose capture sparked the conflict last month, are returned, its ambassador to Washington said today. AFP PHOTO/SAMUEL ARANDA (Photo credit should read SAMUEL ARANDA/AFP/Getty Images)

Okay. These are the same photo, obviously showing Hizballah launching Katyusha rockets into Israel, not Israeli rockets landing in Lebanon. It's just another example of the mainstream media's eleventy-seven layers of editors doing their jobs.

Via LC Scott, commenting at The Anti-Idiotarian Rottweiler.

Fred Fry International has more strange observations on missile launch photos.

UPDATE by RS: Here's a little taste of what long time friend of the Jawa Fred Fry finds.

Posted by: Bluto at 09:40 AM | Comments (18) | Add Comment
Post contains 216 words, total size 2 kb.

1 Wow. The Yahoo photo captains were at least the same for the two variations of the picture.

There is no end to how sloppy, deceitful these people are!

The only thing missing in the missile photos is the Hezbollah guide who brought these guys to the spot.

Posted by: Fred Fry at August 08, 2006 10:02 AM (JXdhy)

2 Maybe they were Boomerockets ... ever think of that, smart guy?

Posted by: Batshitcrazy at August 08, 2006 10:41 AM (UHKaK)

3 Wait, wait, wait! This was an example of the editors doing their job: they caught and corrected the mistake. Admittedly, it happened after initial publication to the web, but that's a result of bad process (publish to the web, edit, re-release to the web and release to print), rather than an editorial problem. This isn't like the mis-identified artillery shell in Pakistan that the editors didn't catch, and it's nothing like the Reuters doctored photos or the staging of photos at Qana.

My suggestion: if you want to be taken seriously by the media on such issues, hold your fire for the times when there's a real problem that needs to be resolved.

Posted by: Jeff Medcalf at August 08, 2006 11:25 AM (BGVHF)

4 [sigh] Jeff, if you follow the links you'll see that the same image is still for sale using different image ID numbers, with the different captions.

My suggestion: if you want to be taken seriously by other bloggers, get your ducks in a row and stop being so snotty.

Posted by: The Dread Pundit Bluto at August 08, 2006 11:39 AM (vBK4C)

5 Just a question:

Is the explosion on the ground still from the launch of the rocket, or is it, in fact, an explosion from a rocket hitting the ground in that area?

The explosion on the ground would seem to me that it is a rocket hitting, not being launched.

It is entirely possible that I'm mistaken, so if anyone knows better, I'd be glad to know why it looks like an explosion on the ground.

Posted by: "Pink Eyed" Jim Cortina at August 08, 2006 11:43 AM (QBzHJ)

6 Jeff,

What about the fact that the photogrpher, who should have been there, somehow couldn't 'figure out' which way the missiles were going as well as who was launching them.

Why didn't the editers take this guy to task for a blatenetly false caption for his photo. Because they didn't care.

You are assuming that the original caption was made in error. Wrong.

Posted by: Fred Fry at August 08, 2006 11:46 AM (JXdhy)

7 Jim: the Katyushas are fired in rapid sequence. What looks like an explosion on the ground is probably the ignition of the next rocket.

Posted by: The Dread Pundit Bluto at August 08, 2006 12:01 PM (vBK4C)

8 Last item first: It's a launch signature.

Second: We should use the lefturds' own tactics against them, i.e., hammer them mercilessly at every opportunity, but unlike them, use real facts instead of invented ones. We don't need "fake but accurate", because we've got "real and accurate".

Third: A good lefturd or 'slamoturd is one at room temperature.

Posted by: Improbulus Maximus at August 08, 2006 12:09 PM (v3I+x)

9 DPB -- Are you offering this example of incorrect captioning as the dreaded slant of the MSM or the poor photo-management practices of a stock photo house? Hope it's not the former, as you know perfectly well Getty is not a news agency. Are you aware of instances in which these photos were run?

Posted by: grinnel at August 08, 2006 12:44 PM (UHKaK)

10 Liberals used to criticize the media, now they defend it. How times have changed.

Posted by: Jesusland Carlos at August 08, 2006 01:03 PM (8e/V4)

11 JC--Strange, I've always associated media criticism with conservatives, Nixon supporters being the most notable example in my lifetime.

Posted by: grinnel at August 08, 2006 01:10 PM (UHKaK)

12 grinnel: this is another likely example of a local stringer/photographer duping the MSM. The photographers write the captions. Do you really think the photog couldn't tell that these were outgoing, not incoming?

The juxtaposition of the two captions makes it amusing. Unfortunately, with so many editors (and news consumers, such as yourself) being unwitting or willing tools of jihadi propaganda, the amusement palls quickly.

Btw, Agence France Presse, the copyright holder, is a news agency.

Posted by: The Dread Pundit Bluto at August 08, 2006 01:13 PM (vBK4C)

13 Yep, it seems possible the photog "double-dipped" and got paid twice for the same photo, probably forwarding it to different regional Getty offices.

Actually, in the case of this photo, it really didn't make much difference if it was outgoing or incoming as both instances have actually taken place hundreds of times. A meaningless photo in the grand scheme. Little convincing "propagandizing" could have happened as a result, though this is an admittedly mild example. No defense of innacurate photos intended.

Posted by: grinnel at August 08, 2006 01:22 PM (UHKaK)

14 grinnel,

when I think of media criticism, I think of Leftwing organizations like Media Watch and Media Matters. Curiously, the Lefties at Media Matters are now furious at any suggestion that the Qana bombing may have been staged. How times have changed.

Posted by: Jesusland Carlos at August 08, 2006 01:46 PM (iDabT)

15 It's probably more correct to say media criticism's always been there; being a defender or a critic I think depends a lot on whether or not you like what "your" media is saying.

Posted by: grinnel at August 08, 2006 01:54 PM (UHKaK)

16 For a larger, unadulterated (ie no imposed logo) image go here. It's definately outgoing, not incoming.

Posted by: Oyster at August 08, 2006 02:04 PM (iari8)

17 Click on the actual image down to the left.

Posted by: Oyster at August 08, 2006 02:14 PM (iari8)

18

I linked from Old War Dogs >> I guess I was tired

Tomorrow when the world finds out Hajj and Green Helmet Dude have been sleeping together for years, remember you heard it from me first so I can be on Drudge Radio and CNN.


Posted by: Bill Faith at August 08, 2006 08:30 PM (n7SaI)

Hide Comments | Add Comment

Comments are disabled. Post is locked.
38kb generated in CPU 0.0194, elapsed 0.0469 seconds.
34 queries taking 0.0351 seconds, 173 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.