December 19, 2005
From MediaGuardian.co.uk:
The new guidance has been sent out internally and tells journalists: "The guidelines do not ban the use of the word. However, we do ask that careful thought is given to its use by a BBC voice. There are ways of conveying the full horror and human consequences of acts of terror without using the word 'terrorist' to describe the perpetrators."So, apparently it's okay to describe the terrorism as long as the word 'terrorism' isn't used. Also, whoever is responsible for bad stuff that happens shouldn't be described as 'terrorists.' Therefore, instead of stating, "A terrorist bombed the crowded school bus," it's more appropriate to state, "A man created full horror and human consequence on a crowded school bus." And, the guidance continues.
"Careful use of the word 'terrorist' is essential if the BBC is to maintain its reputation for standards of accuracy and especially impartiality ... that does not mean we should emasculate our reporting or otherwise avoid conveying the reality and horror of what has occurred; but we should consider the impact our use of language may have on our reputation for objective journalism amongst our many audiences ... we must be careful not to give the impression that we have come to some kind of implicit - and unwarranted - value judgement."Blah ... blah ... blah. That last paragraph reads like gibberish. However, that's not all there is.
The edict reminds BBC staff of the existing BBC editorial policy, which states: "The word 'terrorist' itself can be a barrier rather than aid to understanding. We should try to avoid the term without attribution. We should let other people characterise while we report the facts as we know them."Boiled down, the substance of the new policy is to avoid using the term 'terrorist' and practice hedging the wording of all reports. My interpretation? "Forget accuracy, be political.""We should not adopt other people's language as our own. It is also usually inappropriate to use words like 'liberate', 'court martial' or 'execute' in the absence of a clear judicial process. We should convey to our audience the full consequences of the act by describing what happened. We should use words which specifically describe the perpetrator such as 'bomber', 'attacking', 'gunman', 'kidnapper' 'insurgent' and 'militant'."
The new guidance suggested using words such as "bomb attack" instead, or "bomber" or "assassin". [sic all]
Of course, this announced new guidance begs the question of what exactly is different from the way the BBC currently reports the news?
Companion post at Interested-Participant.
Posted by: Mike Pechar at
11:57 AM
| Comments (47)
| Add Comment
Post contains 470 words, total size 3 kb.
And this, folks, it's what it's all about to the Libs-- "understanding" the terrorists. After all, homicidal maniacs have their own reasons too, right?
If only these Libs spent so much time and energy trying to "understand" us conservatives. That'll be the day.
Posted by: Jesusland Carlos at December 19, 2005 12:03 PM (8e/V4)
This from a media group that was banned from British warships in 2003 for biased war reporting. As far as the BBC is concerned, Britain has already fallen and is now under new management. Disgraceful.
Posted by: Graeme at December 19, 2005 12:18 PM (Wtu+d)
Oh, the irony!
Posted by: heroyalwhyness at December 19, 2005 12:36 PM (XU9K/)
OK, I'm fed up with this. JC, what's this "us conservatives" crap? You think sitting around listening to Ann Coulter with your pants around your ankles and bitching about "Libs" makes you a conservative? A conservative has a true set of principals and values: small government, fiscal responsibility, and basically staying the hell out of people's lives. This administation -- and I'm a guy that voted Republican UNTIL the boob in office now -- does nothing, repeat nothing for the true conservative cause. They're rich, they're powerful, all they want to do is hold onto their power and they don't give a SHIT about guys like you -- unless its time for you to vote that is.
If all the knee-jerk, Limbaugh-loving supporters of this administration knew they're being about as conservative as Ted Kennedy, I'm certain they'd change their tunes.
Posted by: hooligan at December 19, 2005 01:25 PM (oxMjD)
I see. You Libs can "understand" terrorists, but you won't even try to "understand" me.
Case closed.
Posted by: Jesusland Carlos at December 19, 2005 01:29 PM (8e/V4)
Posted by: holligan at December 19, 2005 01:32 PM (oxMjD)
that's great, I have my beef with Bush too. But far more beef with the Left. Don't you? And we're talking about the Left right now.
Posted by: Jesusland Carlos at December 19, 2005 01:38 PM (8e/V4)
Posted by: Improbulus Maximus at December 19, 2005 01:40 PM (0yYS2)
Posted by: hooligan at December 19, 2005 01:44 PM (oxMjD)
Posted by: jesusland joe at December 19, 2005 01:56 PM (rUyw4)
Let's start voting for people becasue of who they are, not because of who they are not!!!
Posted by: Hooligan at December 19, 2005 02:07 PM (oxMjD)
I think conservatives are doing a good job at making themselves heard by Bush on the issues we disagree with (much of his domestic agenda), but we also support him on those issues where he's doing the right thing. I happen to agree with this administration's foreign policy, as do most conservatives. Sorry if you don't, but that doesn't make you more pure than me.
Posted by: Jesusland Carlos at December 19, 2005 02:08 PM (8e/V4)
Posted by: Hooligan at December 19, 2005 02:18 PM (oxMjD)
I used to think they was making it up as they went along too to some extent, and then I read a book by George Friedman of Stratfor called "America's Secret War." They know what they're doing:
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0385512457/qid=1135023961/sr=2-1/ref=pd_bbs_b_2_1/002-8711954-4228011?s=books&v=glance&n=283155
Posted by: Jesusland Carlos at December 19, 2005 02:28 PM (8e/V4)
Yes, the BBC is disgraceful to say the least, but I think traitorous is a better word to describe their behavior. They seem to be more concerned about how the jihadists will react to their terminology rather than whether it is correct or not.
I wonder. Isn't the BBC an organ of the British government? The fact that it continues this disgraceful behavior under the auspices of the government of the UK says a lot about Britain and who is in charge. Can nothing be done with the BBC? Are they responsible to no one or thing? Does anyone know?
Posted by: jesusland joe at December 19, 2005 02:37 PM (rUyw4)
I understand yours and everyone elses frustration with the BBC - but it's an internal British thing so I'm not going to sweat it.
The same cultural and ideological battles between left & right (check that - left and common sense) that's being fought here is also going on there. It's more subdued and the right/common sense side is dis-organised and a lot less effective.
It's their thing - let them play it out. I find anger over it ineffective (and the left likes anger (theirs and ours)). I find mocking laughter to be a better tool - the left hates to be laughed at and held up for comic ridicule.)
Posted by: hondo at December 19, 2005 03:16 PM (3aakz)
Posted by: D. Carter at December 19, 2005 03:41 PM (Suv/B)
JJ, the BBC isn't government run, it's just heavily subsidised by the government using that insane tv license. If the government really wanted to, they could do something about it, but Nu Labour is a strange breed. Yes Blair is going along with the GWOT, but he and his party are pushing a politically correct / nanny state agenda almost the same (in some respects far worse) than the US Dems, so I suppose there's no incentive.
Posted by: Graeme at December 19, 2005 04:03 PM (Wtu+d)
The BBC itself is paid for by the British public through 'licence fees' but the World Service is paid for by the UK government since it has a propaganda and prestige aspect. Obviously the two need to be ruthlessly separated to avoid continuing contamination of the domestic services.
It also doesn't help that the BBC elites recruit all their staff thru the job pages of the like-minded Guardian!
Posted by: John O'Connor at December 19, 2005 04:10 PM (HFpoN)
They do have a couple of stand-ins - ethnic middle-eastern & sub-continent - who definitely derserve a lot more air time!
I try to look at things from all angles.
Posted by: hondo at December 19, 2005 04:30 PM (3aakz)
Posted by: hondo at December 19, 2005 04:45 PM (3aakz)
Seriously, when your speech is constrained by what it could possibly be interpreted as, you're already a dhimmy.
Posted by: Cheapshot911 at December 19, 2005 04:55 PM (PDG3N)
Posted by: Agent Smith at December 20, 2005 05:56 AM (7pPFo)
Posted by: sandpiper at December 20, 2005 09:03 AM (jAP6C)
Posted by: Improbulus Maximus at December 20, 2005 09:26 AM (0yYS2)
Posted by: Riff at December 20, 2005 09:44 AM (UHKaK)
Posted by: hondo at December 20, 2005 11:21 AM (3aakz)
Posted by: Improbulus Maximus at December 20, 2005 11:34 AM (0yYS2)
Pissed-off little weiners that huddle in their rooms like diseased monkeys and plot their "revolutions" on blog sites are about the saddest fuckers around. Guess that's the price of being a "genius," eh? HA! If anybody is offed "when the times comes" I hoping its Nazis like you.
Posted by: Riff at December 20, 2005 12:25 PM (UHKaK)
If he hates islam (as I do) it does not make him a racist a nazi or an idiot. I hate cancer...Does that make me dumb?
Liberalism is a mental disorder.
Which political wing's agenda are trying to spark a revolution?
Posted by: Alexander at December 20, 2005 01:21 PM (JnnHL)
You really irked that lil' troll, especially with the MENSA hook!
Note - his ENTIRE second paragraph is a mirror image of himself! I could have written that paragraph myself (maybe I did in the past) as a typical left troll discription! We need a decent archives! I think I've been plagarized!
Posted by: hondo at December 20, 2005 01:39 PM (3aakz)
Sitting in your one-room apartments, plunking away at your keyboards, screeching about the scary liberals, talking ONLY to those of a like-mind gives you no special insights, no grand understanding of "the way it is", no legitimacy and nothing special to say.
If it helps you vent, go for it — better than beating your wives or plucking wings off flies. But please, don't have the unmitigated balls to think you speak for any kind of majority. There is no way, NO way any significant number of Americans share the fucked-up viewpoints of human waste like Improbulus Maximus. I don't know any; but then again, I don't belong to the Aryan Brotherhood. If most right-wing blog sites are like this one, filled with no more than a half-dozen or so morons with delusions of importance, I think the world will be OK.
So go ahead, post your responses to this, rave about the fucked-up "dhimmis", agree with each other and, finally, call for revolution. I'm signing off and will never see it. You douche-bags are way too annoying.
Posted by: Riff at December 20, 2005 01:51 PM (UHKaK)
If it looks like a duck...
Posted by: DaveP. at December 20, 2005 01:52 PM (6iy97)
I thought conservatives were only Rich and educated.
Keep contradicting your own argument.
Posted by: Alex at December 20, 2005 02:05 PM (JnnHL)
Who are the annoying fucktards walking around ranting like fucking mongoloids that lost a crayon on the street corner holding picket signs on how eating steak is murderous? its not us "douche-bags" its your liberal open minded posse. The most annoying groups of HUMANS on this planet. MEAT IS MURDER 1234 we dont need your stinking war... Shut up it died in the 60's and people hated them too. Common sense rules!
Go find the missing crayon, and find out which chromsones your missing and stfu.
Posted by: Alexander at December 20, 2005 02:14 PM (JnnHL)
Posted by: Darth Evader at December 20, 2005 02:19 PM (UHKaK)
The tired wornout discriptive cliches are extremely important to him (and totally useless no less). Typically the left places itself on a pedestal and defines itself by camparative analysis to its perceived foes. Its all self-delusional of course, which renders it totally ineffective.
But they can't (and refuse) to see that - which is fine by me.
Simple example - Riff is big because others (he distains) are small. The only basis (or measurement)for this exists solely in his mind.
Posted by: hondo at December 20, 2005 02:34 PM (3aakz)
Posted by: Alexander at December 20, 2005 02:41 PM (JnnHL)
Posted by: Improbulus Maximus at December 20, 2005 03:43 PM (0yYS2)
Posted by: jesusland joe at December 20, 2005 04:01 PM (rUyw4)
A journalist's job is to report the facts, not what he thinks about the facts. This isn't a new idea. Ancient Greek philosopher Epictetus put it roughly thus:
"If a man drinks much wine, don't say he has a drinking problem. Say rather, 'He drinks much wine.'
If a man bathes rarely, don't say he has a hygene problem. Say rather, 'He bathes rarely.'"
It takes self-discipline and humility, but it keeps you from confusing what you know with your opinions about what you know. A professional news article has facts in it. Reporters who have opinions about the facts get to fight over the editorial page. Of course, neither you nor I have any reason to care what some flunky infotainer thinks about a car bomb, so let's forget about Op-Ed and stick to facts.
BBC is right by saying that using "terrorist" carelessly could get you in trouble with the facts. For instance, suppose a bomb goes off on a school bus in Baghdad. What else could it be? "A terrorist attack on a school bus in Baghdad today left 11 children dead..." you'd say if you were the reporter. But what are you going to say next week when the investigation discovers that actually one of the kids found a landmine and tried to bring it to school to show his friends? You look like a fool.
Posted by: ShannonKW at December 20, 2005 07:43 PM (dT1MB)
Now just what the hell has the facts got to do with the BBC. They quit reporting the facts a long time ago, soon after Epictetus made the allusion you refer to. Or it seems so, anyway.
That's just funny you putting the BBC and facts in the same sentence. And looking like a fool is what the BBC does on an hourly basis these days.
Shannon, you sound like a recent j-school graduate.
Posted by: jesusland joe at December 20, 2005 09:14 PM (rUyw4)
That's deep!
With a hypothetical like that who is the fool here?
Posted by: hondo at December 20, 2005 10:42 PM (3aakz)
BBC does suck, yes, but in this narrow case I believe they are adhering to good form. It's not like they are demanding that amputees be called "differently-limbed" or some other PC dodge. They don't want their people to assume terrorism every time a truck backfires on on the Baghdad freeway. They're not trying to be sensitive to the feelings of terrorists.
BBC has some facts, usually. Their method of bias is the same as every other big Western news house's--facts dealing with pet causes go to the head of the line. They have a real hard-on (so to speak) for women's rights. If coital queefing is decriminalized in Kyrgyzstan they'll make space to trumpet it as a victory, nevermind if a civil war just broke out in that country.
They give you facts, just not all the facts. If you know of a world news outlet that does post all the facts, please post a link.
Posted by: ShannonKW at December 20, 2005 11:00 PM (dT1MB)
Remember the bombing of the Oklahoma City federal building? Remember how, right after that, every newsman and his dog was going off about how "terrorism has finally reached our shores," and speculating about what type of Muslim fanatic did the deed? Remember the embarassment when the FBI nabbed some pink, clean-cut, Christian terrorists? I sure do. It was funny to watch. If I recall correctly, my local news anchor said...
"Er... Uhm... Wuh-wuh-wuh-well, we just *assumed*..."
Everybody knows how "ASS-U-ME" breaks down. Getting your facts straight isn't the same thing as being liberal.
Posted by: ShannonKW at December 20, 2005 11:22 PM (dT1MB)
J Gagnon-Golden CO-USA and proud of it!
Posted by: June Gagnon at December 21, 2005 12:57 AM (2FzlO)
Relax. My only comment was with the hypothetical you presented - let's be honest - it was terrible!
I did understand your point - your followup was dead on the money.
Actually, I do agree with you. I do in fact use the BBC and one of my primary sources of information.
"Assumptions" drawn from minimal information is a human trait and failing - and natural. Constructive analysis does not come easy - especially when emotions enter the equation.
We are in related fields - objective analysis goes with the job - but we had to learn it.
Posted by: hondo at December 21, 2005 01:26 AM (3aakz)
34 queries taking 0.027 seconds, 202 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.









