August 28, 2006

If You Can't Win, Throw Out The System

The Electoral College system - an American tradition and governmental safeguard in place in the US for over 200 years - has suddenly become catastrophically unacceptable to some residents of California.

Sure - it was positively dandy when the Clintons were in power. There was no need to change anything, because all was right with America. Now that the letters have changed decisively from D to R, however, something has to be done. This wasn't supposed to happen.

According to Opinion Journal, legislatures in California are trying to usurp these constitutionally mandated safeguards to favor large, uneducated liberal urban populations of inner cities. The proposal would mandate that any candidate that got the popular vote would automatically get the state's electors - regardless of the number of communities that participate in the electoral process. In other words, if voters in LA, San Fran and San Diego outnumber the rest of the state, then these three cities determine who gets California's electoral votes.

I won't go into the number of constitutional and logistical problems this would create for all candidates and voters - the Opinion Journal article does that quite effectively - but the American public at large should be aware this is going on. It is being pushed by one party - the Democrats.

Yes. The Democrats want the dense inner-city populations and their infinitely successful approaches to problems like education, crime and corruption to run the national government without regard to what anybody else outside of the large population centers might think.

Times have changed so much under the long dark night of Bushiburton fascism that the very democracy that was perfectly acceptable a decade ago has collapsed entirely and needs to be replaced with procedures favorable to urban liberal constituencies.

Didn't y'all country boys and gals get the memo? Your votes are no longer needed or relevant, thankyouverymuch.

Stein hoist: Daily Pundit.

Update: I worded a particular passage above badly. Jim corrected me in the comments: " It would be more correct to say that if Candidate 'R' wins the majority in California (not the most likely outcome) but Candidate 'D' wins the majority of the popular vote nation wide, then instead of California's electoral votes going to 'R' as they are currently required to do they would go to 'D' anyhow."

Apologies for the oversight.

Posted by: Good Lt. at 07:15 AM | Comments (40) | Add Comment
Post contains 396 words, total size 3 kb.

1 This is just a symptom of the problem that faces our nation - one that Benjamin Franklin foresaw when he was asked what kind of government the convention had created and he replied; "A republic, if you can keep it." Well, we've done a piss-poor job of keeping it, because we've been slowly democratizing to the point that most people actually do think we're a democracy, and don't even know the difference due to general ingorance. It didn't help when the Constitution was amended to allow direct election of senators; a minor point, but a crucial one, since that one move essentially removed from the states any say in the Federal government, thus eliminating one of the checks and balances which was so crucial to keeping equilibrium in the system. Now we have a tyrannical, imperial Federal hegemony in which two corrupt parties manipulate the system and violate the spirit and letter of the Constitution on a regular basis for the sake of power, and the idiots who vote for the parties are perfectly willing to accept the degredation of our rights and liberties in exchange for a better place at the trough. Democracy allows a people to give themselves the kind of government they deserve, good and hard. Well, we're getting it, and there's more to come.

Posted by: Improbulus Maximus at August 28, 2006 08:46 AM (v3I+x)

2 You are exactly right IM. Back when Bush Sr. lost his re-election bid to Bill Clinton, Bush won the popular vote. No one seems to remember that one. Our system wasn't flawed back then. Now all of a sudden the republicans gain control and its a problem. Give me a break.

Posted by: Venezuelanexile at August 28, 2006 09:08 AM (a/kZr)

3 Howie, you got the outcome correct, but you didn't word this analogy correctly:In other words, if voters in LA, San Fran and San Diego outnumber the rest of the state, then these three cities determine who gets California's electoral votes.

What would be more correct is to say that if Candidate 'R' wins the majority in California (not the most likely outcome) but Candidate 'D' wins the majority of the popular vote nation wide, then instead of California's electoral votes going to 'R' as they are currently required to do they would go to 'D' anyhow.

Posted by: Jim at August 28, 2006 09:11 AM (YkmII)

4 "I won't go into the number of constitutional and logistical problems this would create for all candidates and voters - the Opinion Journal article does that quite effectively - but the American public at large should be aware this is going on."

The constitutional system issue isn't that hard. Legislatures can allocate their electoral college vote any way they wish, subject of course to other constitutional mandates, like equal protection and due process.

Or did you think you had some constitutional right to vote for president all on its own?

"In other words, if voters in LA, San Fran and San Diego outnumber the rest of the state, then these three cities determine who gets California's electoral votes."

Uh, whoever gets the most votes in CA gets CA's electoral votes already. Did you not know this?

Posted by: actus at August 28, 2006 09:12 AM (nnhSu)

5 That was a very thoughtful and reasoned response, Maxie, and one likely to draw criticism from the ones who refuse to see that this abomination we call the Federal Government was born of the conflict named the Civil War. Changes made subsequent to that conflict have given rise to what we now have, an all-powerful central government with little concern for the sharing of power foreseen by the founders. I have little doubt that the masses, including the illegal aliens, will vote, and vote often in the upcoming elections. When you have a system that allows voting without any proof of citizenship or identification, which would prevent you from even renting a movie at Blockbuster, you get what you deserve.

Posted by: jesusland joe at August 28, 2006 09:12 AM (rUyw4)

6 Sorry Good Lt., not Howie.

Posted by: Jim at August 28, 2006 09:12 AM (YkmII)

7 California could also explore succession - I'd be cool with that. That way - everybody can get what they want! Big problem though will be counties in north and those outside the major cities. They may want to stick around.

Posted by: hondo at August 28, 2006 09:31 AM (XrexX)

8 Hmm....I seem to remember something in my history about a great war being fought to preserve the Union, hondo. I have a better idea, hondo, the state of California stays in the Union, and anyone living there not satisfied with the Union, move on to a place more to their liking, say Mexico, or Europe, or perhaps the Middle East, as they seem to be enamored with that place.

Posted by: jesusland joe at August 28, 2006 09:43 AM (rUyw4)

9 "The constitutional system issue isn't that hard."
 
Duh. How can a system be "hard?"
 
 "Legislatures can allocate their electoral college vote any way they wish, subject of course to other constitutional mandates, like equal protection and due process. "
 
When the Cali Democrats throw out the traditional electoral college process to tweek the system for the favor of the national Democrats, that's apparently just fine by actus. Equal protection and due process much? Apparently, those constitutional mandates only apply when Democrats are chaning the system that they were fine with a decade ago.
 
"Or did you think you had some constitutional right to vote for president all on its own? "
 
That sentence makes no sense. Try again.
 
Maybe that's why you don't show your face at protein wisdom anymore. Not that we're complaining.

Posted by: Good Lt at August 28, 2006 09:45 AM (yT+NK)

10 Californians can do anything they want with their electoral votes - except take them away from Californians.

Posted by: hondo at August 28, 2006 09:48 AM (XrexX)

11 Well, I see reports this morning that a Mexican flag has been hoisted atop a post office in California, so I suppose this thing may come to a head before long. It's apparent to me that illegal aliens can do whatever they want with California's electoral votes, as they are likely to vote, and vote often. The illegal alien will decide the fate of California.

Posted by: jesusland joe at August 28, 2006 09:59 AM (rUyw4)

12 "Duh. How can a system be "hard?"

It can be hard to understand. I dont think thats the case here though.

"Equal protection and due process much? Apparently, those constitutional mandates only apply when Democrats are chaning the system that they were fine with a decade ago."

But those mandates would still apply.

"That sentence makes no sense. "

Nowhere in the constitution does it guarantee that the majority vote in a state is what determines that states electoral college allocation. A state is free to do it anyway it pleases, so long as it follows other constitutional rules, like equal protection, due process, the voting rights of women or 18 year olds, etc...

But plain old having a direct right to vote for president? that you don't have.

Posted by: actus at August 28, 2006 10:05 AM (nnhSu)

13 Exactly, actus, and that is exactly what the founders intended not to have happen. A better question would be why. Why would the founders have created such a system, a system that disallows a direct vote for a president?

Posted by: jesusland joe at August 28, 2006 10:16 AM (rUyw4)

14 "But those mandates would still apply."

Yup. The entire system in which they functioned, however, would be altered because Democrats can't nationalize elections effectively and dammit they're not going to take it anymore.

"Nowhere in the constitution does it guarantee that the majority vote in a state is what determines that states electoral college allocation. A state is free to do it anyway it pleases, so long as it follows other constitutional rules, like equal protection, due process, the voting rights of women or 18 year olds, etc..."

Nobody was denying them these rights. They have nothing to do with the central argument.

Like I said - Democrats tossing out the 200+ year old system is just fine by actus. How very Stalinist of you.

Read the argument, and argue with it (instead of yourself):

"First, the direct election of presidents would lead to geographically narrower campaigns, for election efforts would be largely urban. In 2000 Al Gore won 677 counties and George Bush 2,434, but Mr. Gore received more total votes. Circumvent the Electoral College and move to a direct national vote, and those 677 largely urban counties would become the focus of presidential campaigns.
Rural states like Maine, with its 740,000 votes in 2004, wouldn't matter much compared with New York's 7.4 million or California's 12.4 million votes. Rural states' issues wouldn't matter much either; big-city populations and urban issues would become the focus of presidential campaigns. America would be holding urban elections, and that would change the character of campaigns and presidents.

Second, in any direct national election there would be significant election-fraud concerns. In the 2000 Bush-Gore race, Mr. Gore's 540,000-vote margin amounted to 3.4 votes in each of the country's 175,000 precincts. "Finding" three votes per precinct in urban areas is not a difficult thing, or as former presidential scholar and Kennedy advisor Theodore White testified before the Congress in 1970, "There is an almost unprecedented chaos that comes in the system where the change of one or two votes per precinct can switch the national election of the United States."

Washington state's 2004 governor's race was decided by just 129 votes. A judge found 1,678 illegal votes were cast, and it turned out that 1,200 more votes were counted in Seattle's King County than the number of people recorded as voting. This affected just Washington state, but in a direct national election where everything hangs on a small number of urban districts, such manipulations could easily decide presidencies.

Third, direct election would lead to a multicandidate, multiparty system instead of the two-party system we have. Many candidates would run on narrow issues: anti-immigration, pro-gun, environment, national security, antiwar, socialist or labor candidates, for they would have a microphone for their issues. Then there would be political power seekers--Al Sharpton or Michael Moore--and Hollywood pols like Barbra Streisand or Warren Beatty. Even Paris Hilton could advance her career through a presidential campaign.

For such candidates to run under the present system is very difficult, for they have to win state by state electoral votes. But if all you need is national fame and fortune to win popular votes, many candidates would run and presidential campaigns would become unfocused, confused, and about political advocacy instead of presidential substance.

Finally, direct election would also lead to weaker presidents. There are no run-offs in the Interstate Compact--that would require either a constitutional amendment or the agreement of all 50 states and the District of Columbia--so the highest percentage winner, no matter how small (perhaps 25% or 30% in a six- or eight-candidate field) would become president. Such a winner would not have an Electoral College majority and therefore not be seen as a legitimate president.

So rather that trying to eviscerate the Electoral College, we should be embracing it. It was put in the Constitution to allow states to choose presidents, for we are a republic based on the separation of powers, not a direct democracy. And the Electoral College--just like the Senate--was intended to protect the residents of small states. As James Madison said, the Electoral College included the will of the nation--every congressional district gets an electoral vote--and "the will of the states in their distinct and independent capacities" since every state gets two additional electors."
- - -

If it were the Republicans bucking 200+ years of electoral procedure and tradition, however, then we all know it would be an "unprecedented threat to the democratic process," rife with "disenfranchisement."

Thanks for playing, actus. You have no point, as usual.

Posted by: Good Lt at August 28, 2006 10:27 AM (yT+NK)

15 A few weeks ago, I finished a good book on the history and modern implementation of the Electoral College:

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0977072207/sr=8-1/qid=1156778664/ref=pd_bbs_1/002-5047387-0806429?ie=UTF8

The book argues (correctly) that a shift to a popular vote for President would render states largely irrelevant to a Presidential contest. The President would be selected according to the votes within a dozen or so large cities, mostly on the East and West coasts. No more Presidential visits to small rural states.

Given the left-wing machine politics in place in most major American cities, this would, of course, be a liberal Democrat's wet dream.

Posted by: The All-Seeing Pirate Ragnar at August 28, 2006 10:32 AM (c/4ax)

16 Jawa Report:

Actus, who regularly defecates at Patterico's Pontifications and Jeff Goldstein's Protein Wisdom, has apparently now seen fit to leave his "pearls" of "wisdom" here.

What folks at those other sites have long ago learned is not to respond to actus, b/c his whole point is simply to disrupt and argue. Forget about moving goalposts, actus specializes in motorized goalposts!

Our suggestion: IGNORE ACTUS

Posted by: Lurking Observer at August 28, 2006 10:33 AM (/ZD7V)

17 I say "don't try to fix something if it ain't broke." And the system isn't broken. At least until someone like Howard Dean gets elected.

Posted by: Venezuelanexile at August 28, 2006 10:42 AM (a/kZr)

18 Ah. The "ignore the retarded telephone pole" treatment. I gotcha.

actus is treading on my home turf here, so it was too tempting not to smack him/her/it around at least once or twice.

But you're absolutely right, LO. I am aware of his antics at PW and Patterico, and I haven't seen him at PW a lot lately. Probably all that "law school" he/she/it assures everyone he/she/it is attending.

Posted by: Good Lt at August 28, 2006 10:47 AM (yT+NK)

19 Observer, we know actus well, as he has defecated on numerous occasions here on this blog.

Posted by: jesusland joe at August 28, 2006 10:50 AM (rUyw4)

20 "Why would the founders have created such a system, a system that disallows a direct vote for a president?"

The founders created a system where each state allocats votes on their own. Thats all thats happening here. You just disagree with how they're allocating it.

"Like I said - Democrats tossing out the 200+ year old system is just fine by actus. "

Constiutionally, yes. But as policy i think it would be quite an amazing change. I'm not so sure its a good idea, but I must say that what the WSJ thinks are bad parts of it make think its actually worhtwhile. We ignore our cities way too much.

I really don't know how to address their Paris Hilton arguments. I'm not comfortable with content-based arguments for election systems.

"No more Presidential visits to small rural states."

You're trying to argue against this system?

Posted by: actus at August 28, 2006 10:53 AM (nnhSu)

21 The electoral system is in place to give equal or semi-equal voice to all states. It also allows for a last chance vote, should there be a voice within the state's populace who disagree with the outcome. The college electorate casts the final vote. It is just assumed they will vote for the winning candidate. This change will not happen simply because there are more smaller states without big metropolis' than with.

Posted by: SeeMonk at August 28, 2006 11:36 AM (n4VvM)

22 I don't get the fuss. If a majority of Californians vote for candidate A, California can give all electoral votes to A, or proportion them by percentage between A & B ... now technically the electors are obligated to vote IAW the voters who elected them - but they can switch - some have (solely as personal statements) - if it was done on a larger scale to effect an election there probably would be one hell of a firestorm.

Now if California decided to give its votes to candidate B based on the fact B won the national popular majority - but Californian voters chose A ... whoa! So much for Californian democracy - doubt under these circumstances it would even be legal.

Whoa - more - until the election is complete and certified, California would have no real impact till after the fact! And then - if its actions changed the outcome - straight into court and/or the streets.

All this is simply an exercise in arrogrant stupidity. So 2 elections in our history have turned on the electoral college - out of how many?

This is pure (softspoken) BDS by the California Democratic Party - they lost a national election in 2000 - and now are looking for a precedural change in the process to prevent it from happening again.

But this is pure stupidity - even the procedural change gaurantees absolutely nothing - and it doesn't turn back the clock to 2000!

This is nothing more than red meat - sorry red soy - for their base to eat up.

Posted by: hondo at August 28, 2006 11:38 AM (XrexX)

23 "Now if California decided to give its votes to candidate B based on the fact B won the national popular majority - but Californian voters chose A ... whoa! So much for Californian democracy - doubt under these circumstances it would even be legal."

For that we turn to the wonderful system created by teh founders. Who gave this right to pick electors not to the people, as a democracy, but to the state legislatures. woah is right.

Posted by: actus at August 28, 2006 11:43 AM (nnhSu)

24 Missed your point actus. State legislatures are democratically elected at the local/decentralized level - They are highly representative of the people in their districts and far more responsible to them.

It is an excellent system for chosing electors
as well as dare say - write legislation. Your not suggesting creating a dependancy on public referendums and propositions for more and more affairs, are you?

Posted by: hondo at August 28, 2006 11:59 AM (XrexX)

25 "Missed your point actus. State legislatures are democratically elected at the local/decentralized level - They are highly representative of the people in their districts and far more responsible to them."

So a legislature's way of allocating electors is 'highly representative of the people in their districts and far more responsible to them.' Ok. Because thats whats going on here: state legislatures deciding to allocate electors, as the founders intended.

Posted by: actus at August 28, 2006 12:11 PM (nnhSu)

26 actus doesn't have a point, hondo. Ever.

Posted by: Good Lt at August 28, 2006 12:31 PM (jWYAe)

27 "actus doesn't have a point, hondo. Ever."

The point here is rather simple, people are whining about, among other things, constitutional problems with this scheme. My point is that there really aren't any as far as the elecoral college is concerned.

But there is, I believe, a prohibition on treaties or compacts between states. So the system would have to be set up to not be a compact.

Posted by: actus at August 28, 2006 12:43 PM (nnhSu)

28 "My point is that there really aren't any as far as the elecoral college is concerned."

That's why bucking the 200+ year national electoral process for the presidency isn't news to you - since it is being done by Democrats for Democrats. No problem. Nothing to see here. Radical systemic alterations of fundamental constitutional American democratic electoral institutions, traditions and processes being implemented by a leftist political party. Move along, folks.

Sorry, actpole, but if it isn't that big of a deal, then it wouldn't be in the WSJ. Don't you ever get tired of being pointless?

Posted by: Good Lt at August 28, 2006 01:05 PM (jWYAe)

29 "That's why bucking the 200+ year national electoral process for the presidency isn't news to you - since it is being done by Democrats for Democrats."

I also made the point that it would be an "amazing change." It's certainly news.

"Sorry, actpole, but if it isn't that big of a deal, then it wouldn't be in the WSJ."

Well, don't be (mis)guided by their op-ed page. Their news reporting, on the other hand, is phenomenal.

Posted by: actus at August 28, 2006 01:10 PM (nnhSu)

30 And from parts of KALIFORNIA where they have the infamous 9th curcut court maybe its time to boot a few liberals out of the nation and to dump HANOI ON THE BAY into the pacific ocean

Posted by: sandpiper at August 28, 2006 02:51 PM (oCdmx)

31 Actually, it is not a big deal - in fact it is a meaningless BS stunt designed to achieve nothing while stroking their lib/left constituency.

Would this bill have changed the outcome in 2000. Let's see - Gore won California and popular vote - and got all California's electoral votes. (er no change).

Now if Bush won the popular vote and lost California - would California give Bush all its electoral votes?

Had friends who were involved in the hydrogen dioxide hoax some years back - some enlightened progressive California city came within one day of a City Council vote/ruling for banning the substance. Am I supposed to take these people serious?

Posted by: hondo at August 28, 2006 04:52 PM (XrexX)

32 The Electoral college is a safety that prevents elections from being fixed. The electors are representitive of their communities. They are the last stand against a fixed election. That among anything else must really piss of the Dems. Makes it almost impossible to fix a Presidential election.

Posted by: SeeMonk at August 28, 2006 09:21 PM (n4VvM)

33 Maybe we should give rectus a break. Anyone that irritates the pink panty prick goodie Lt can't be all bad.

Posted by: greyrooster at August 29, 2006 06:10 AM (fnweh)

34 Aww - that hurts my feewings, roostie.



Its a good thing you decided to grace us with your presence - I was
beginning to think you were doing something productive out there.

Posted by: Good Lt at August 29, 2006 07:33 AM (yT+NK)

35 I did. I bought 3 rounds of drinks at the Southside Cafe in Slidell, La today. Trying to get the boys to put up an Iragi style road block between here and New Orleans.

Posted by: greyrooster at August 29, 2006 05:55 PM (BInc2)

36 If you see that numbskull Nagin, punch him twice in the chops for all of us.

Posted by: Good Lt at August 29, 2006 06:17 PM (jWYAe)

37 You can't say that. Nagin is black. Oh no, call the delete police. Nazi on board, KKK, bigot, racist. delete, delete.

Posted by: greyrooster at August 30, 2006 08:54 AM (WmiLs)

38 Awww. How cute. You're still holding a grudge like a jilted lover.

So much for my attempt to be concilliatory. Just what I'd expect from a petty little Stallinist child who refers to himself in third person.

Swish.

Posted by: Good Lt at August 30, 2006 10:43 AM (jWYAe)

39 Asshole: You started the shit. You attacked me because of my beliefs. You started the name calling. So fuck you. The same dog never bites me twice.

Posted by: greyrooster at August 31, 2006 05:31 PM (wDEFg)

40 Nobody attacked you. You're a hypersensitive loon.

Posted by: Good Lt at August 31, 2006 07:01 PM (jWYAe)

Hide Comments | Add Comment

Comments are disabled. Post is locked.
60kb generated in CPU 0.0718, elapsed 0.1141 seconds.
34 queries taking 0.0941 seconds, 195 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.