March 05, 2005
Suspicion continues to mount that Giuliana Sgrena, the journalist for the Italian Communist paper Il Manifesto, either faked her own abduction or became an accomplice after the fact with her jihadi captors.
Today Giuliana Sgrena told her version of the dramatic story contradicting US military claims that her car was fired upon when it failed to slow down at a Coalition check point. Bloomberg:
``It wasn't a checkpoint, but a patrol that started shooting after pointing some lights in our direction,'' the Ansa news agency cited Sgrena as telling the prosecutors. ``We hadn't previously encountered any checkpoint and we didn't understand where the shots came from.''As if on cue, Sgrena then goes on to say what we at The Jawa Report had been predicting she would say all along:
``I was never treated badly,'' Sgrena told her colleagues at Manifesto upon her arrival in Rome, according to Ansa.The Italian left-wing, as predicted, has siezed upon Sgrena's ordeal today. The headline at Sgrena's own Communist paper shouts the headline that the Italian secret-service agent who had negotiated her release had been "Assassinated" by America.
UPDATE: NPR now reports that an anti-war rally is planned to celebrate Sgrena's release.
The Jawa Report has been predicting from day one that Sgrena would be released unharmed, and that on her release she would blame the US for her ordeal. The fact that her driver did not stop at a US checkpoint on a road scattered with checkpoints is more than a little odd--it is canny.
How does a driver in Iraq not know that the rules of engagement for Coalition forces are to fire upon any car which does not stop when ordered to?
While the Italian people wish to know why the US fired upon Sgrena, we in the US want to know why it was the Sgrena's car did not stop when ordered to do so?
Sgrena, continues her anti-Amricanism (Reuters):
"We thought the danger was over after my release to the Italians but all of a sudden there was this shoot-out, we were hit by a barrage of bullets," she told RAI TV by telephone.Doesn't this whole incident seem more than a little odd?Nicola Calipari, the senior secret service agent who had worked for her release, was telling her about what had been going on in Italy since her capture when the shooting started.
"He leaned over me, probably to protect me, and then he slumped down, and I saw he was dead," said Sgrena.
Sgena was kidnapped by her admitted friends in Iraq.
She was kidnapped while on the phone with another journalist.
A tape was released of her begging Italy to cave to the terrorists demands of pulling Italian troops out of Iraq the day before the Italian Senate was to vote on that very issue.
On the tape Sgrena appears to tell the 'terrorist' holding the camera to stop. He follows her order as if she is directing.
The tape came exactly two-weeks after she was captured.
One month to the day after her abduction she is released.
On the day of her release her car speeds toward a US checkpoint, fails to stop when ordered, fails to heed warning shots, and the car is ultimately fired upon.
In the end, who looks like the bad guys? The terrorists? The jihadis? The 'insurgents'? No, the US.
And what possible motivation, as I am frequently asked, might Sgrena have in being complicit in this whole thing?
"I don't believe a word of the American version," said Oliviero Diliberto, head of the Italian Communist party, part of the main left-wing block led byformer premier Romano Prodi.If one actually believes in the Left-wing version of the world than aiding Michael Moore's 'Minuteman' is not only the right thing to do, but a moral imperetive. Sgrena holds the world-view, as evidenced in her body of journalistic work, that America is the cause of all the problems in the world. She believes the US is exactly as Ward Churchill describes it. America is just like Nazi Germany."The Americans deliberately fired on Italians. This is huge. All of the center-left must vote in parliament for the withdrawal of our troops."
And Iraq? Iraq is an imperialistic move motivated by greed, the desire for hegemeny, and to bolster the Zionist-imperialists in Palestine. Iraq has been a blood-bath with tens of thousands of children dying so that the US could gain control over Mideast oil.
Normally we don't go in for conspiracy theories. We hate them. We despise them. But the speculation that Sgrena collaborated with the 'minutemen' of Iraq in demanding that Italy withdraw from that country does not involve layer upon layer of cover-up. It requires a few people, none of them working in an official government capacity.
Remember Benjamin Vanderford or John Adam?
And if you really believed all that the Left says about the US in Iraq, wouldn't it be your duty to fight the occupation? And if it is morally acceptable to kill in that resistance then surely the lesser crime of lying is also acceptable.
Guliana Sgrena, you are a liar and a propagandist. Why should we trust you now?
UPDATE: I oringinally wrote this from my 28k connection at home and have corrected some of it.
This is speculation and I could be wrong. Speculation, though, is the foundation for any hypothesis testing. I hope Italian and US investigators do not simply take this enemy propagandists word for it. In my book, she is every bit a suspect as she is a victim.
Jeff Goldstein adds his two-cents here.
Let me also remind readers that Sgrena's car was shot at night. The DU is now filled with posters claiming Sgrena was shot because "she was brown, like the Iraqis" or that "the US will shoot any brown person".
The soldiers could not have known who was in the car. They had no idea a hostile journalist was in the car (sorry Eason Jordan, your hypothesis doesn't wash) and they could have had no idea there was a 'brown person' in the car (sorry DU and Ward Churchill)
UPDATE: Let me clarify a few points responding to comments.
1) Nobody is accusing the Italian secret-service to have been in on this. No one is saying that a giant conspiracy exists. What we are saying is that Sgrena was amongst friends if her hostage takers were terrorists. That a ransom was paid makes Italy a victim, not a co-conspirator.
2) When the word of a propagandist is pitted against the word of a US soldier, I am inclined to believe that of the soldier.
3) If the speculation that the whole thing was a hoax is wrong, so be it. However, ample evidence exists that Sgrena was really in no danger if it was jihadis responsible for her kidnapping. If however the kidnappers were simple criminals, then all this is wrong.
UPDATE March 07: After taking Sunday to think about this, let me do a couple of "take-backs."
I implied in this and an earlier post that the troops firing on Sgrena's vehicle was somehow part of Sgrena's bigger plan. The accusation that this is wingnuttery are actually right-on. Now that would require some sort of conspiracy between Sgrena and the men who had negotiated for her freedom (at a price-tag of over $1 million from what we are now hearing.
I feel stupid for having implied that such a conspiracy existed.
The most likely explanation is that Sgrena's driver simply did not follow orders to halt.
Now, why did Sgrena's driver not follow these orders?
Two hypothoses come to mind:
a) It was dark and the driver was confused about the identity of the soldiers mistaking them for insurgents
b) The driver believed the anti-American rhetoric of Sgrena and her likes. If the US is as Sgrena describes then why would you stop? Remember, for a large number of people in the world who watch al Jazeera or read left-wing newspaper's US soldiers are terrorists.
If the latter is true than the shooting incident becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy.
Don't stop at an American chekcpoint because they shoot reporters. The reporters get shot because they don't stop at a US checkpoint.
However, for Sgrena to have been complicit in her own kidnapping requires no such grand conspiracy. It takes one reporter cooperating with the mujahadin council. That's it. more...
Posted by: Rusty at
12:28 PM
| Comments (265)
| Add Comment
Post contains 2284 words, total size 15 kb.
Try again.
Posted by: Louis Robert Fowles at March 05, 2005 01:25 PM (lEdku)
Posted by: bpb901 at March 05, 2005 01:28 PM (b2Y3g)
Posted by: Jeff G at March 05, 2005 01:30 PM (jd1P8)
Posted by: Thom at March 05, 2005 01:30 PM (ckj8m)
I'm not arguing that one of these conspiracies is true while the other isn't. And I've got no issue with you presenting evidence of Srgena's possible duplicity. I'm just mystified as to why wing-nuts are so utterly credulous when it comes to their own government, which has, of late, shown little interest in transparency and accountability. What the hell happened to the classic conservative skepticism of government? That used to gospel to you guys. Further, Bush has given anyone paying an ounce of attention ample reason to question what prompts him to take any action. Look at budget numbers, the Medicare bill, Social Security - yes, even WMD and the accompanying hype - the guy stretches the truth like taffy. And yet, for half the country, this is a man who "says what he means." You're kidding, right?
Feel free to question Sgrena's actions and words. But, on the way, don't discard the obvious: yes, she's an anti-war journalist; yes, she's hostile to the U.S. - no question. Until there's greater evidence than guilt by sympathy, you're just reaching. I read this morning in the NY Times (also part of the Michael Moore conspiracy, no doubt) that, for all her anti-war material, Sgrena also criticized the limitations of jihadist political philosophy: why not mention that? Right. Doesn't fit the conspiracy - it's all part of her cagey attempt to disguise her true motives.
If you accept the obvious interpretation of this event: the jihadis kidnapped Sgrena precisely to impact the vote; the predictability of the reaction, not only from Sgrena but from the Italian left generally; the reactions of U.S. troops at seeing a speeding car (even if it was a patrol, I'm guessing they'd treat it the same) - the whole thing adds up to a simple, embarrassing tragedy. Remember Occam's razor.
Posted by: TBF at March 05, 2005 01:31 PM (64/E/)
Posted by: Adnrew at March 05, 2005 01:32 PM (sK6OP)
We are not that lucky in America. In my opinion, it seems the communists in America hide, making it difficult to expose them for what they are. Fred
Posted by: Fred Kolovrat at March 05, 2005 01:33 PM (+7VNs)
The fact that Sgrena was against the war and against the occupation may have helped with her release after a month in captivity, but that does not even come close to suggesting she was complicit in a faked abduction. And you might want to check your facts about who Sgrena was waiting to interview - refugees from Fallujah who had fled the US assault on their city. Again, you might need to look a little further than the English language media if you want to find this out. Try Italian Google News, then use the translation function in Google preferences.
Of course, your theory may prove correct and as you say it will be interesting to see what emerges over the next few weeks. But it would be a good idea to start reading what the Italians are saying before leaping to conclusions.
Posted by: cat at March 05, 2005 01:34 PM (pq+mH)
Posted by: terrorist at March 05, 2005 01:38 PM (js0j9)
Posted by: Paul at March 05, 2005 01:38 PM (QxbN2)
Oh, and speaking from personal experience, Il Manifesto and most other leftist organizations in Italy need absolutely NO help from anybody to disagree with the war/the United States and the rightist government in Italy. I assure you that the style of rhetoric coming from those publications would be the same if Sgrena was never captured. BUT, the idea that this was all staged seems very far-fetched to me. You really think that a left-wing newspaper in Italy would've PLANNED to not only have one of their correspondents kidnapped, but then PLANNED to have them fired upon by American troops in order to wound and kill some of them? I mean come on, that kind of staging seems a little TOO much! I mean, this isn't Private Lynch and the U.S. Government here! This is a communist newspaper in Italy! Italy has had its share of tragedy since the beginning and "ending" of this war, the 4 private security guards who were kidnapped and one killed, the bombing at Nasiriyah, two other journalists were captured a few months ago. The idea that Il Manifesto somehow masterminded this whole thing is pretty ridiculous if you ask me. It seems to me that its NOT very hard to get yourself kidnapped or shot at in Iraq nowadays eh?
Posted by: Scott Stuart at March 05, 2005 01:46 PM (24Am3)
now THATS a conspiracy theory
Posted by: Scott Stuart at March 05, 2005 01:50 PM (24Am3)
"While the Italian people wish to know why the US fired upon Sgrena, we in the US want to know why it was the Sgrena's car did not stop when ordered to do so? "
Posted by: war in iraq = failure at March 05, 2005 01:58 PM (1eVE8)
Posted by: Scott Stuart at March 05, 2005 02:03 PM (24Am3)
Posted by: roy at March 05, 2005 02:05 PM (XbwU9)
Posted by: Chuck Benz at March 05, 2005 02:09 PM (+7Nwj)
Posted by: A.Scott at March 05, 2005 02:16 PM (VJWzz)
ALSO...if you haven't spoken to Italians who fought in World War II...and I have, my grand-father in law did, fighting for BOTH Italian and American forces, he tells me that he and everyone else he knows from that time feel nothing but deep respect and gratitude for what the US did in WWII. He tells me "I can never thank the US enough for that....but I think that America is doing the wrong thing here in Iraq, and that is clear to see from all over the world." I think you are grossly misinformed if you think that Italians are not grateful for America's involvement in WWII. But I think that the America 60 years ago is not the America today...and so should not be judged the same way, no? No one in their right mind could possibly compare the ethical justifications for fighting in World War II with the complete absence of ethical, pragmatic, humanitarian justifications in Iraq
Posted by: Scott Stuart at March 05, 2005 02:18 PM (24Am3)
Posted by: Elrod at March 05, 2005 02:18 PM (t5fT9)
Posted by: Scott Stuart at March 05, 2005 02:20 PM (24Am3)
By the way, I mentioned that Sgrena's story has been confirmed by one of the wounded SISMI (not SCIRI) agents. Maybe he is also a communist feminist Arabic-speaking anti-US liberal working for Il Manifesto. But that's not the impression I've usually got from people in the security services. Perhaps they're a bit different in Italy.
Posted by: cat at March 05, 2005 02:23 PM (dxJYZ)
(and btw, in italian "assassinato" does mean "deliberately murdered". The generic term for "killed" is "ucciso")
As for the kidnapping, there seem to be two types of kidnappers, which I'll call type A and type B.
Type A are the usual psychos that kidnap foreigners and murder them unless their requests are accepted, or even just to make a point. The killers of Enzo Baldoni and Fabrizio Quattroccchi (and all the other hostages killed in Iraq) were type A.
Type B are somewhat different though. They:
- only kidnap leftwing activists that "have been in Iraq since before the war" (ie as valued guests of Saddam Hussein's regime).
- don't seem in a great hurry to formulate requests, and couldn't care less when their requests are rejected.
- go to great lenghts to interfere with Italian domestic politics, asking for mass demonstrations against the government, timing their messages to coincide with parliament votes and so on.
- don't use the usual channels such as Al Jazeera or the islamic web sites to deliver their videos, for some reason they prefer to use western press agencies instead.
- never kill their hostages, which in return make a point of mentioning how well they have been treated as soon they get off the plane. Pretty weird for someone that went on tape whimpering and pleading for help.
The two aid workers "kidnapped" last year and Giuliana Sgrena are clearly "victims" of type B kidnappers. Or else they enjoy a extraordinary and selective luck.
Posted by: Armando B. at March 05, 2005 02:28 PM (EfJ7H)
Posted by: ravingliberal at March 05, 2005 02:29 PM (SMUjt)
Posted by: ATM at March 05, 2005 02:36 PM (quHw1)
I guess this is all symantics and not all that important
Posted by: Scott Stuart at March 05, 2005 02:37 PM (24Am3)
and isn't "International Left" a pretty broad spectrum? It seems to me that the definition of the "Right" is that THEY are the ones so famously good at bilking?
Posted by: Scott Stuart at March 05, 2005 02:40 PM (24Am3)
Posted by: Armando B. at March 05, 2005 02:48 PM (EfJ7H)
I'm happy she has not be killed by those stupid terrorists and stupid american soldiers.
Maria Coza
Posted by: maborg at March 05, 2005 02:49 PM (uFPpT)
Nothing complex or conspiracle about this. Just a good strategy for the left who want to see Iraq re-repressed, as there is nothing worth fighting or dying for.
Posted by: quark2 at March 05, 2005 02:51 PM (U98ZF)
Posted by: quark2 at March 05, 2005 02:55 PM (U98ZF)
Posted by: Clyde at March 05, 2005 02:56 PM (jn16O)
One another exemple of US stupidity : insult your own ally instead of assuming your own blunder.
Go on like this and you soon be left alone in Irak.
Please use the brain you were born with.
It's highly improbable that the Us army didn't know about the release of the journalist since the Italian, unlike the french, are members of the coalition.
The car was shot at at 7OOm from the airport. To be that close, they already had to pass numerous check ups. So the army must have known their passage.
The members of Italy's elite secret service securing the release were very experienced people. Not the kind of fools who would speed up if they are warned by " flashing lights and shots in the air".
What about if they were not warned but just shot at by trigger happy conscripts ? or scared young boys far away from home ?
The content of this article is just filthy. Some americans can go really low, remember Abu Ghraib.
Posted by: Michel Meyer at March 05, 2005 03:06 PM (xTwDq)
Posted by: rman at March 05, 2005 03:17 PM (g3874)
The pulp of your nation has origins wide spread, so think in being part of the world insted of the world being part of you.
From Portugal.
With respect for Man.
Posted by: Tiago at March 05, 2005 03:17 PM (S9ApA)
People or nations who live in glass houses should not throw boulders. Might do you some good to look down at your feet, see all that glass you're standing in?
So much for so-called alliances, that run at the first sign of an error or problem. But then again nothing is really worth fighting for is it.
Posted by: quark2 at March 05, 2005 03:20 PM (U98ZF)
Posted by: gail at March 05, 2005 03:21 PM (47cun)
Posted by: rman at March 05, 2005 03:23 PM (g3874)
You need to speak to the French about the Congo. That is still their territory. Unless as an antiwar afficiando you think the United States should declare war on France in order to do something to help the Congo.
But then again, there really is nothing worth fighting for is there.
Posted by: quark2 at March 05, 2005 03:34 PM (U98ZF)
US Soldiers should have been forwarned by US intelligence that this vehicle was coming their way. Were they? Well then the US soldiers fired on a known journalist.
Were the US Soldiers NOT warned? Well then, US intelligence set the journalist up to be slaughtered by nervous, trigger happy US Soldiers.
Either way you slice it, this Italian Journalist was set up to be murdered. Lucky for her, the Italian intelligence officer protected her from the hail of gunfire, so she lived. The officer died a hero by sacrificing his own life to protect a fellow human being. The family of that Italian officer should be proud of his bravery and service to his country.
The US? Hang our heads in shame. We fucked up once again. Especially when we promote a smear campaign against the very people we murdered. Shameful.
To sit here and listen to you people justify the shooting because she is a "communist" exposes your warped perceptions. Italy has 3,085 troops in Iraq. Snap back to reality.
Posted by: Sally at March 05, 2005 03:39 PM (4oTpc)
Posted by: mompjb at March 05, 2005 03:41 PM (jNmJ7)
"Either way you slice it, this Italian Journalist was set up to be murdered"
And you have the verifiable documented proof to
prove this statement?
But then again nothing is really worth fighting for then is it.
Posted by: quark2 at March 05, 2005 03:46 PM (U98ZF)
But from Sgrena's own report:
``It wasn't a checkpoint, but a patrol that started shooting after pointing some lights in our direction,'' the Ansa news agency cited Sgrena as telling the prosecutors. ``We hadn't previously encountered any checkpoint and we didn't understand where the shots came from.''
IF you are going to argue her side of the story, you can't dismiss her claim that she had not been through a checkpoint. But if you are willing to believe that she IS lying, then maybe they did go through checkpoints; but if that is the case then we can't believe her when she says this WASN'T a checkpoint, or anything else her group says (her "rescuer" is unlikely to tell a different story than that told be the "hero" hostage).
And if they did go through several checkpoints,they should have know the protocol for approaching and stopping at a checkpoint.
Since I wasn't there, I will refrain from making my own conclusions about the event; the facts will sort themselves out in a few days. I'm merely saying that arguments must at least be internally consistant, which this one wasn't.
Charles
Posted by: Charles Wayne CT at March 05, 2005 03:46 PM (FVv2u)
Posted by: gail at March 05, 2005 03:48 PM (47cun)
Posted by: Stan at March 05, 2005 03:49 PM (KF1fi)
As for whether the left does bilking, you have to look no further than Cuba and NoKo for left wing governments that rob the resources of their own countries to enhance the power and comfort of the rulers. Castro is one of the wealthiest men in the world, yet Cuba is dirt poor.
Posted by: ATM at March 05, 2005 03:50 PM (quHw1)
Posted by: Scott Stuart at March 05, 2005 03:52 PM (24Am3)
Anyone can see that since the invasion of iraq...women have it even worse than they did in Saddam Hussein's time....the acts of violence and repression against women have skyrocketed as religious hardliners are aggressively pressuring women to don headscarves etc etc....
the point being this, no one is going to argue with you saying that Saddam Hussein was a great guy and his country was in great shape, neither would I argue that Cuba is in great shape....BUT....the literacy rate in Cuba is great....and during Hussein's time....women were treated better than most ANY other Middle Eastern country....
BESIDES. All of the original rationale for going to war has proven to be FALSE. Would anyone like to argue with me on that? I welcome it.
Posted by: Scott Stuart at March 05, 2005 03:58 PM (24Am3)
now THATS some bilkage.
Posted by: Scott Stuart at March 05, 2005 04:05 PM (24Am3)
Posted by: Gringo at March 05, 2005 04:12 PM (/nsOy)
This need to believe anything horrific about the motives of the tropps, no matter how contrived, is really astounding to behold.
Posted by: Nukevet at March 05, 2005 04:12 PM (Wm4GU)
And everybody that pays income taxes got a cut in rates.
Posted by: Gringo at March 05, 2005 04:14 PM (/nsOy)
Since I am posting from the United States, I do have freedom of speech, just as you. One mans truth can be anothers propaganda. Still doesn't give you the right to tell someone else to stop speaking.
And when you applied the word BUT to your last statement, you canceled everything posted before.
By the way Hitler made sure the trains ran on time too.
But then again to some, nothing is worth fighting for. Not even you.
Posted by: quark2 at March 05, 2005 04:15 PM (U98ZF)
I agree that we should do something about the Congo, especially about the UN's European and Arab "peacekeepers" who are raping children and using them for pornography there.
The Europeans sure can't be trusted to do anything at all, just as they did nothing about Rwanda or Bosnia or Saddam Hussein. Doing nothing about Saddam made sense, though, since the EUnuchs were reaping huge profits by participating in Saddam's circumvention of the Oil for Food fiasco (which led to the deliberate starvation and deaths of Iraqi children when Saddam withheld food and medicine).
You hypocritical, cowardly Europeans make me want to vomit. The US is cleaning up your mess for you once again, while you sit back, save your Euros and criticize. But the huge (and exploding) populations of unassimilatable Muslims in Europe is something the US isn't going to be able to fix for you - Europe is finished as a civilization, a corpse that doesn't know it's dead yet. Kiss it goodbye and say hello to Eurabia.
Bronxite
Posted by: Bronxite at March 05, 2005 04:15 PM (5KmWh)
By the way, I think that both conspiracies that Sgrena planned her kidnapping AND that the US wanted her killed are ridiculous. I don't think there are many of us "lefties" who think that. In terms of if the Italians think that....I think that they are justifiably outraged right now...and want to know what the HELL just happened. As I know I would too
Posted by: Scott Stuart at March 05, 2005 04:17 PM (24Am3)
Yes, this conspiracy theory, like many, is interesting, but it stretches the imagination.
As was posted earlier, what REALLY happened is likely exactly what appears to have happened.
The reporter got kidnapped, and then was a victim of a friendly-fire (after a fashion) incident.
So far 2 of my friends have died in Iraq, both to friendly fire (one before the invasion).
Posted by: Gringo at March 05, 2005 04:19 PM (/nsOy)
your critical thinking skills go lacking.
Posted by: rumcrook at March 05, 2005 04:25 PM (Q9W6F)
Posted by: See you at March 05, 2005 04:25 PM (uFPpT)
I've read the Ansa report and did'n't see the phrase "We hadn't previously encountered any checkpoint ".
She did say that 'it was not a check point but a patrol" who fired.
Her boy friend Pier Scolari also says some interesting things about the fact that the US army was warned in advance and talks about an "embuscade".
You can try to find every excuse (as absurd as they maybe) for the mistakes of your troops but not insult italians - or other europeans - because they have a different opinion. To start such a smear campaign just hours after one person has been killed is just sickening.
To Quark2
Ignorance, stupidity and arrogance are worth fighting against.
Posted by: Michel Meyer at March 05, 2005 04:27 PM (xTwDq)
so YES...the original rationale to going to war have been proven false.
NO WMD'S
NO SUBSTANTIVE CONNECTIONS TO AL-QAEDA
ABSOLUTELY NO THREAT TO THE UNITED STATES
don't forget rumcrook, all the 9/11 guys were from Saudi Arabia, right?
Posted by: Scott Stuart at March 05, 2005 04:32 PM (24Am3)
"Ignorance, stupidity and arrogance are worth fighting against."
That is an oxymoron.
Just what weapons would be used in fighting against ignorance, stupidity and arrogance?
Why isn't terrorism, honour killings, clitiorectomies, mass starvations, amputations and
child rapes not worth fighting against?
Posted by: quark2 at March 05, 2005 04:33 PM (U98ZF)
Posted by: William Teach at March 05, 2005 04:36 PM (cuTsc)
This war is not about us being the good guys, believing that is a LACK of critical thinking
Posted by: Scott Stuart at March 05, 2005 04:36 PM (24Am3)
a tragedy? Yes.. absolutely., no contest there.
But an accident? Nope.... Those soldiers fired their weapons on purpose, in accordance with thier training and their orders.
A mistake? Sorry... The soldiers hit what they were shooting at- a vehicle that refused orders to stop, again, in accordance with thier orders and their training.
In another blog, I came across criticism of the soldiers for thier "failure to properly identify the vehicle" with out any explaination (of course) of HOW they were supposed to identify it as containing non-hostiles, as if it is a given that insurgent cannot wield a paintbrush as they please.
No, I think the soldiers did a fine job of identifing the vehicle- as one that would not freaking stop when ordered and very possibly about to blow them into damnation. Put yourself in the position of those soldiers. you have witnessed corades killed and maimed by car bombs and roadside charges.
Consider...
A vehicle is approaching.... it is signaled to stop.... it does not stop... your gut tightens under your kevlar armor.. another attempt is made to stop to stop the vehicle... discipline holds, even thought the oncoming vehicle, which for all you know contains a couple of hundred pounds of high explosives with your name on it.... does not stop..
warning shots are fired.... with no result!
What are you going to do?
And from the point of view of the occupants of the oncoming vehicle...
you are driving down a road.. up ahead you see American soldiers waving at you to stop and flashing lights at you to the same object. They are pointing automatic weapons at you. Then, warning shots are fired. Do you stop or not?
Those boys have orders to stop any vehicle that comes their way, in full awarenness that thier lives may easily depend on their doing so,
Bottom Line: If they tell you to stop, you will stop. Dead or alive, you WILL stop. Any Questions?
If it is of any help, try looking at this as an intelligence test.. and it's strictly PASS/FAIL, M'kay?
Posted by: Lucius Severus Pertinax at March 05, 2005 04:38 PM (r95xu)
frightening a man that is pointing an automatic weapon at you is A REAL BAD IDEA, okay?
Posted by: Lucius Severus Pertinax at March 05, 2005 04:41 PM (r95xu)
Posted by: quark2 at March 05, 2005 04:44 PM (U98ZF)
Posted by: Scott Stuart at March 05, 2005 04:45 PM (24Am3)
If the US wanted this chick dead she would be dead. Why was she not killed by her captors? I don't think that is an unreasonable question.
Esp considering that she was sympathetic to the "insurgents"
And yes lots of "lefties" hate the US military. They are over a DU having a party right now.
Posted by: susanita at March 05, 2005 04:52 PM (DGrPq)
The history books will tell you are right. You can't say either. And I hope that if you turn out to be wrong (which it looks increasingly like Bush started a good the in the ME) than I hope that you can admit it.
But you won't. Just like with Reagan. He was critized until it was clear he was right and now everyone loves him and claims to have been on his side all along.
Posted by: susanita at March 05, 2005 04:55 PM (DGrPq)
I don"t really see the link with the Sgrena story but the Congo was not a french colony but a belgium one.
It is a good thing to liberate all oppressed nations throughout the world.
What about Liberia or Sierra Leone, two countries that have close historical ties with the US and are both plagged by civil war ?
Not worth fighting for ?
Posted by: Michel Meyer at March 05, 2005 04:57 PM (xTwDq)
Your claims that women are worse off in Iraq now,shows that your very selective Left Wing memory suffers from critical lapses.
Seems you have forgotten about the rape rooms, the govt. paid rapeist, the mass graves & the fun games that those sweet little Saddam Jr's liked to play.
You guys all seem to have a firewall that will only allow things in to your mind that strictly conform to your alternate reality.
Posted by: Yankee Diver at March 05, 2005 05:08 PM (6krEN)
Maybe we should slam shut our borders, turn our back s on the world. Mind our business.
Then the left can line all of 'the masses'in long lines and do our thinking for us as big brother. The great nanny state of from the cradle to the grave.
Emulate the systems of such great left leaning systems as North Korea and the also ran USSR.
Oh yes, we are not the great guys. We the great white walking dead preying on the world.
We should fall to our knees and offer our necks in appeasement and shame to those who are so much greater and better than us........those of the 12th century third world.
pshaw!
Posted by: quark2 at March 05, 2005 05:10 PM (U98ZF)
and you show your true colors, deny you hate america in one breath then call us the bad guys in the next.
Posted by: rumcrook at March 05, 2005 05:12 PM (Q9W6F)
You are correct, it is a Belgium colony. But then again the belgians are about the same as the french.
Same attitudes, same type of culture, same type of governance and same language.
And maybe it's time that everyone start fighting their own battles.
And everyone start minding their own business.
Posted by: quark2 at March 05, 2005 05:19 PM (U98ZF)
You seem to know as much about the different cultures and countries of the world as your president G.W.Bush.
Hey wake up it is not like in hollywodd movies ?
Do you know that for instance that in France no one understood the thing about the "french fries" changed into more patriotic "freedom fies". Because here no one would call the "pommes frites" french since we believe the best fries come from Belgium (like the Congo)!
Posted by: Michel Meyer at March 05, 2005 05:39 PM (xTwDq)
Posted by: TS at March 05, 2005 05:50 PM (B7VX/)
Posted by: Dumbo_the_Elephant at March 05, 2005 05:57 PM (fjxg3)
Posted by: Arrmatey at March 05, 2005 05:58 PM (DZDzu)
Posted by: Scott at March 05, 2005 05:58 PM (PiM5Z)
Posted by: slickdpdx at March 05, 2005 05:59 PM (hzSsW)
Take your condescension somewhere else. Whoever's colony the Congo is it was a poster here who said the US should get involved. And quark2 was trying to respond.
I have lived in Europe and have heard plenty of ridiculous & derogatory things that misunderstand Mexico, South America, and the US. So you can have your Belgian pommes frites and I'll eat my freedom fries and we'll both feel superior- when in fact, Europe's average citizen is pretty ill informed about the world outside the continent.
Europe is not like in the movies either.
Give me a break.
Posted by: susanita at March 05, 2005 06:01 PM (DGrPq)
Posted by: madne0 at March 05, 2005 06:02 PM (S9ApA)
No fan of bollywood here.
And what do you know of Mr.Bushs knowledge? Are you in an intimate situation that you would know this?
You are not an american that is obivious. Freedom fries, because french products are being boycotted in the United States. Which is why the french winemakers are whinging and looking for aid from the government.
Posted by: quark2 at March 05, 2005 06:11 PM (U98ZF)
Similar here - what were these people doing when told to halt? Trying to race through US troops. What a foolish thing to do with entirely predictable results.
Posted by: LR at March 05, 2005 06:15 PM (mOion)
Posted by: fm at March 05, 2005 06:46 PM (q8c7P)
I fact calling this entire thing a "Hoax" make me want to HOWL!
Posted by: Red Wolf at March 05, 2005 06:49 PM (RqaMW)
AROOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!
Posted by: Red Wolf at March 05, 2005 06:54 PM (RqaMW)
I'm not condescending but outraged by this article and some of the comments.
To inform us, ignorant europeans, journalists like Scregna or Aubenas (french hostage) risk their lives unlike the US press who stays in secured hotels.
Me too I travel and I can see that nowadays it's pretty negative about the US almost everywhere, South America, Asia, Africa...
This Irak war and the WMD hoax has damaged the image of the US very badly. This "incident"' will only make things worse. Especially if some jerks claim that Scregna deserved it.
If the US wants to be a good "world leader" it should have more knowledge and be more sensitive about other people's cultures.
The pommes frites thing was an answer to someone who stated that france and Belgium share the same political system when actually one is a Kingdom and the other a Republic.
Posted by: Michel Meyer at March 05, 2005 07:02 PM (xTwDq)
Posted by: Red Wolf at March 05, 2005 07:12 PM (RqaMW)
Hurt feelings? Because of the comparison of France and Belgium?
Who cares about American "image"?
You all still love our money.
But, have you noticed you're getting less and less of it? Why? Because all those bad imaged yaahoo umerikuns aren't coming over and spending like we've done in the past.
The next time...and it's coming...you get your weenie asses in a fix, don't call us for a rescue and to clean up your effing mess.
As reminder of it not happening again, take a long walk through one of the WWII cemetaries holding OUR young men and women.
Posted by: q at March 05, 2005 07:16 PM (U98ZF)
Posted by: Red Wolf at March 05, 2005 07:59 PM (BzMP/)
You don't get it. I'm not anti american.
I'm just dismayed by the way your president is "leading" you.
After 9:11 most people wanted you to succeed in the war against terror. But then came Irak.
The french and the germans advised you to not to go to Irak. You didn't care and made all the possible mistakes : allow widespread looting, dismantle the Iraki army, the prison scandal and so on. Now you are untangled in a mess for years and the world suffers from the consequences.
The french do not forget the WW2 soldiers who came to liberate.
You should not forget also that France is your only historical ally that never waged war against you.
They wanted to avoid their closest ally the kind of disaster the soviets met in Afghanistan or general Custer with Sitting Bull. Instead of listening you insult them.
You are lucky that most people in France did not really know the level of vulgarity and intensity of the anti french smear campaign. Then they would really become anti american. There was nothing comparable directed against americans here.
If you start loosing your allies you have a problem. This is GWB's major blunder.
As far as the boycot is concerned it is inefficient. The major french companies have declared a record benefit from export late year.
Do the US only want to be loved for their dollars ?
Posted by: Michel Meyer at March 05, 2005 08:00 PM (xTwDq)
America will be there to bail your sorry asses out you ungrateful
sons of bitches! GOD BLESS AMERICA!
M.W.
Posted by: MIGHTY WHITEY at March 05, 2005 08:05 PM (vzIsh)
Respect is a two-way street,you moron. Scregna's actions are repugnant, both before and after the alleged kidnapping. She is now accusing good soldiers of "murder". If you can't see why people are pissed off about that, then you're an idiot. I feel sorry for the special agent that was killed, and for the troops who fired on the vehicle because they are being vilified for trying to protect themselves.
Posted by: Trapeze at March 05, 2005 08:32 PM (ds4O8)
Good question.
When I said she was "set up", that requires you to think about it. Seriously, think about it...
EVERYONE knows that US Soldiers are going to fire on vehicles driving fast towards them. They have to in order to protect themselves. So you must ask yourself this important question: "Why would the Italians be driving fast towards US Military?"
That would be suicide, plain and simple. There is no reason they should want to die. It begs the question then, if they were driving fast, what was their reason? Since we don't have proof (none of us do) we must speculate as to why they would do such a crazy thing.
What would be the most logical reason the Italians, WITH an Intelligence Officer on board, would be driving fast near US Military? The ONLY reason would be that the Italian Officer HAD ASSURANCES from US Intelligence that they would be safe because US Intel would inform US ground troops along their route of what kind of vehicle the Italians are driving.
Now, the set-up. If US Intelligence gave assurances verbally to the Italian Intel Officer there would be NO PAPER TRAIL. Likewise, if the US Intelligence NEVER informed US troops, there would also be NO PAPER TRAIL. Also, US Intelligence could deny ALL KNOWLEDGE (plausible deniability) of having the Italian's vehicle description if the Italian Officer lived.
"Why didn't the US troops kill the journalist?" BECAUSE as far as the US troops know, it was an accident. So they aren't going to "finish her off" if they think they mistakenly shot at a vehicle they shouldn't have.
Someone else here said "Shit Happens". You think the US Intelligence doesn't know that? They were counting on "Shit" to happen. Likewise, if the Italian Officer had lived, the US Intelligence could just say, "We didn't know what type of vehicle you were driving. We never spoke to you. You must have spoken to somebody impersonating US Intelligence."
Your right quake2, I don't have "proof". But this makes a WHOLE LOT MORE SENSE that the parent article does. Of course, it's a horrible hypothesis if you refuse to believe US Intel had motive for it. Did they?
Posted by: Sally at March 05, 2005 08:44 PM (4oTpc)
Oh for sure. She was so important, that they went to all of that trouble
to make out a plan to shoot up her car.
The car was shot at night. I guess you think the soldiers have some
way of identifying who is a car in the dark. ESP?
She got what she went for and some icing for that cake too.
A story. Good on her. I hope she enjoys the fruits of her efforts.
Posted by: quark2 at March 05, 2005 08:50 PM (U98ZF)
What a joke. If Americans had any idea of the depth of anti-Americanism in France, they'd hate the French more as well.
France stabbed the US in the back, plain and simple. Don't expect US sympathy for playing politics. How is the French and German economy these days? I hear Germany has the highest jobless rate since WWII. I also hear that the French are depressed out of their skulls. Tough shit. You made your bed, now you lie in it.
All we ever hear is how me are supposed to apologise for liberating Iraq, while you were playing politics with Iraqs future. You would rather have seen Saddam Hussein continue his murderous reign, than liberate his victims. The French and Germans have a lot of blood on their hands, no doubt about it. You're the one who should apologise.
Posted by: Trapeze at March 05, 2005 08:52 PM (ds4O8)
Maybe, if you're on crack.
Posted by: Trapeze at March 05, 2005 08:54 PM (ds4O8)
Go invent something, fucktards.
Posted by: The Incompetent Trollâ„¢ at March 05, 2005 09:01 PM (lK7Sh)
"I'm just dismayed by the way your president is leading" you."
Presidents usually do lead. That's their job.
"The french and the germans advised you to not to go to Irak. You didn't care and made all the possible mistakes : allow widespread looting, dismantle the Iraki army, the prison scandal and so on. Now you are untangled in a mess for years and the world suffers from the consequences."
The french and germans advised us to not invade
Iraq, because they had their hand in Saddams cookie jar.
The possible mistakes made were the exposure of
the still ongoing oil for food scandal.
The prison scandal is beans compared to the scandal of France and Germany abetting Saddam in 12 more years of horror, brutality and murder of his own people. Of course due to them, he did enjoy the 52 palaces all of that illgained money afforded him.
"The french do not forget the WW2 soldiers who came to liberate. "
Which why in the past year there has been scandalist vandalism of them.
"You should not forget also that France is your only historical ally that never waged war against you.
They wanted to avoid their closest ally the kind of disaster the soviets met in Afghanistan or general Custer with Sitting Bull. Instead of listening you insult them."
Excuse me, but the first soldiers of WWII were KIA in Morrocco by french soldiers. Are have you forgotten the french government set up by and controled by the germans?
Custer getting his ass fried by Crazy Horse was a
victory. Custer was a worm and finally got his just rewards when all heroic awards were stripped from him.
Sometimes the truth can be insulting.
"You are lucky that most people in France did not really know the level of vulgarity and intensity of the anti french smear campaign. Then they would really become anti american. There was nothing comparable directed against americans here.
If you start loosing your allies you have a problem. This is GWB's major blunder."
So, since America disagreed with the french politics it was an anti french smear.
Loosing allies like the ones who were caught with
their hand in the til isn't such a loss.
Getting caught with your pants down is never
a blunder except for the perp.
The excuse you've laid out here are as about as
intelligent as the ones I got from my neighbour today about the gate his teenaged son destroyed.
"Oh, it was vibrations that made the gate fall apart." Right
Posted by: quark2 at March 05, 2005 09:17 PM (U98ZF)
I would like to raise some questions:
1) Do we know that she was intending to turn herself into the Iraqi government when they ran into the patrol?
2)Do we know if that this Italian agent was sent after or before the Italian government was notified of her release?
3)Do we know anything about the agent's political or religious loyalties and so forth? It would be interesting to find out the agent's background. His ability to give witness has been silenced very conveniently; could someone else have fired the weapon besides the US troops?
4)For that matter, has anyone examined the bullet wounds on his body to establish the direction and distance of the weapon?
5)Do we know the weapon that killed the agent matched weapons fired by American troops?
6.If the weapons match, my next question how any group was traveling in darkness, inside a speeding vehicle, who ignores soldiers’ directions to slow down could expect anything else but weapon fire. Any fool would expect US or Iraqi soldiers to fire at a speeding vehicle that refused to slow down within a region known for suicide car bombing. This situation appears contrived to create a scandal.
6)Observers have noted earlier that the authenticity of hostage video authenticity is questionable. Her performance as a "hostage†was lacking any projection of the white-faced terror shown by previous hostages, and she does appear to give directions at one point.
7)You and other observers point out that there is no positive proof she was actually kidnapped, therefore, a possibility exists that she faked her kidnapping.
Hence, she ran into an unexpected obstacle, and the vehicle’s attempt to escape detection. It would explain their irrational attempt to speed up and avoid close examination by the soldiers. The driver's behavior certainly sounds extremely suspicious if not irrational.
Posted by: Mirramele at March 05, 2005 09:33 PM (KtFTf)
You really dug down deep for that one, didn't you Trapeze? Thanks for not adding any constructive thought to this forum, we all appreciate it.
Posted by: Sally at March 05, 2005 09:36 PM (4oTpc)
Even if you believe our soldiers would do such a pointless, idiotic thing as assassinate a little nobody reporterette from the Italian version of the Daily Worker, surely you can't believe that they would be gormless enough to fail, not try again, and leave witnesses, which they then took to the hospital so they would be well enough to testify against them. That's just plain irrational.
Posted by: gail at March 05, 2005 09:46 PM (47cun)
"Oh for sure. She was so important, that they went to all of that trouble to make out a plan to shoot up her car."
If you consider "telling someone they are safe, and then doing nothing" a complicated plan, then I'd hate to hear what your idea of a simple plan would be.
"The car was shot at night. I guess you think the soldiers have some way of identifying who is a car in the dark. ESP?"
ESP may not be as effective as NIGHT VISION EQUIPMENT.
"She got what she went for and some icing for that cake too. A story. Good on her. I hope she enjoys the fruits of her efforts.
Do you work for US Intelligence? Because that is EXACTLY the same attitude that US Intelligence could have that would motivate them to "show her a lesson".
quake2, my post asked the reader "to think". Don't say I didn't warn you...
Posted by: Sally at March 05, 2005 09:48 PM (4oTpc)
Did you even read my post? Read it again.
I never said the US Troops were in on it. They were just doing what they normally do, protecting themselves from random vehicles they thought were dangerous. It's the US Intelligence that NEVER informed the US Troops that they if they see such-and-such a vehicle, NOT to shoot it. It's a simple plan really, and if you don't understand it, then I can't help you. Suspend your patriotic beliefs for just a few minutes and think about this like a murder mystery.
LISTEN CAREFULLY: The US Troops didn't "finish her off" because they were never told to. As far as the US Troops knew, they shot at a suspicious vehicle, realized they made a mistake, and sent the Italian Journalist to the hospital. The crime falls on US Intelligence.
Read my original post. It's ALL there.
Posted by: Sally at March 05, 2005 09:58 PM (4oTpc)
The initial stories were obviously very incomplete, but it doesn't seem like guys who get convicted for putting underwear on peoples heads are going to gun down people just for kicks, and then miss on top of that.
Posted by: Frank at March 05, 2005 09:59 PM (DrvrJ)
At midnight (Italian local time), I saw a coffin wrapped in a Green-White-Red Italian flag at Roma's airport. I saw a woman, with her daughter and her son. That woman lost her husband. Those girl and boy lost their father. I saw Italian Republic President Ciampi imposing his hands on the coffin for several minutes as to embrace a valorous man. Mr. Nicola Calipari.
He was one of the most important SISMI agent. He was the one who was able to free the Italian hostages in 2004 and 2005, until two days ago. When the car in which he was on his last mission was under US fire. And his last action was to protect the woman who was to be protected till her return here in Italy. Ms Sgrena said "He died in my arms". The man who saved her as from Iraq kidnappers as from US soldiers, 2 times in one hour. He was a REAL agent. He surely made ALL the communications needed for the mission. He saved Ms Sgrena after a month of intense work. He couldn't make any mistake, expecially at the end of her prigiony... at 700 m from the airport in a such infamous road.
When she was released, she had a bandage on her eyes, but she could listen to helicopter over her head. The helicopter in Iraq belongs to US, isn't they? So US DID know about her release. But... WHY US soldiers didn't know? Someone among you could say "comunist propaganda".
But there was no checkpoint. There was no actions to stop the car. Only FIRE on the car. Ms Sgrena and Mr Calipari were on the phone with Palazzo Chigi, the Italian Government Palace, when US soldiers opened fire. Roma knows that Ms Sgrena and her Mr. Calipari were on the way to Baghdad's airport. Phones were closed by soldiers... 20 years old scared soldiers... Ms Sgrena was taken to the hospital.
In Italy everyone is horrified. Are we sure that the US soldiers were informed by the ones who should have to inform them in time to avoid this murder? Something is gone too much wrong... where is the fault? Is it Italian fault to be attacked by its own ALLY? By the country who declared itself as FRIEND? By the country whose interests were so big to began a war in which Italian boys lost their lives in Nassiriya? For an US war, depicted as "democracy war" boys are dead, and they continue to die, everyday. Boys of every nation. Can democracy be obtained with blood? Iraq-civil blood, soldier's blood?
From Italy I could only report what is the feeling of Italian people. We didn't want this war in Iraq. Italy IS AGAINST the war in Iraq, as in every other country of the world. But the Italian Government wanted it. It seems that it's not so important what people want. Because Italian Premier Berlusconi is US ally. So Italy (and Italian people) HAD to be US ally. In Iraq there is a war, a war for OIL, and journalists as Ms Sgrena and Ms Abenaus made only their job: to tell people the TRUTH. I hope that the French journalist could return soon in her country, too. That kind of person risks life in every moment. Only to tell the Truth.
We, in Italy, are waiting for a reply by US: TRUTH.
US MUST TELL US TRUTH. US OWES US TRUTH. Not a "political truth" to hide the TRUTH. For Mr. Calipari's family, for Italian people who are still in shock. This isn't communist propaganda... Propaganda is making "brainwashing" to people making them believing world is divided in "good and evil" where good=US and evil=the rest of the world. Evil is blood. World is paying an heavy tribute in human lives: not in money, not in oil. In human BLOOD. And blood has the same colour for every man or woman in the world. Because we are all human beings. And the most foolish thing that human beings could do... is war. But world is full or wars.
Posted by: Koe at March 05, 2005 10:05 PM (KniaQ)
Good points. Why would the CIA want to create a scandal over such an insignificant journalist? That idea doesn't hold weight.
Before this situation, she would have returned, made the usual comments and produced articles with the typical viewpoints heard from that political camp; but the impact would have been minimal. The sucessful Iraqi election has taken the wind out of the Anti-American rants. I doubt if the world would noticed her beyond one day.
Now, she has a convenient death of an Italian agent and an opportunity to make accusations that US soldiers attempted the deliberate murder of a journalist; already it has given a jump-start to her formally limp story with a spicy, attention grabbing twist.
.
Posted by: Mirramele at March 05, 2005 10:06 PM (KtFTf)
Posted by: gail at March 05, 2005 10:08 PM (47cun)
Posted by: quark2 at March 05, 2005 10:16 PM (U98ZF)
1. the assumption that the US government was informed in advance
2 the assumption that the US government did not inform its military personnel that she was being returned
3. the assumption that the driver was a idiot. Even if the driver had been informed that the government knew she was returning, why would the driver assume that his vehicle could be correctly identified by armed troops, while the vehicle sped towards them in the dark?
4. The assumption that the driver would believe it was safe to ignore a shouted military command to slow down, and then make the choice to speed past armed soldiers, in the dark, in a region known for car bombing?
Posted by: Mirramele at March 05, 2005 10:22 PM (KtFTf)
There was a checkpoint. The Italian Secret Service failed to co-ordinate their movements with American forces as is standard operating proceedure in combat zone.
The American forces gave every possible warning, and as I said in my coverage of the event, they should have fired far more rounds into teh vehicle under the circumstances. It is only though some of the greatest fire disciple and professionalism of our soldiers that any of these people lived.
If you must place blame on this tragic turn of events, first place the blame with the ISS for not coordinating their movements with coalition forces on the ground. Then place blame on the driver for not heeding obvious warnings.
And thank God above that these were American soldiers with American training at this checkpoint, for if there was any other army in the world manning this position, there would be three more families of Italian Secret Service agents in mourning, as well as the husband of a dead communist journalist.
Put that in your pipe and smoke it, Koe.
Posted by: Confederate Yankee at March 05, 2005 10:24 PM (e02to)
I for one am calling it a night.
Posted by: gail at March 05, 2005 10:32 PM (47cun)
Maybe you didn't understand that we want TRUTH. We are not the kind of people who accuse BEFORE knowing as others do.
Posted by: Koe at March 05, 2005 10:33 PM (KniaQ)
Just to set the record straight, I am calm, qail. Also, thank you for stating the obvious, that I'm making a public spectacle of myself. I should expect nothing less when actively engaging in discussion on a "public" forum.
I certainly hope you weren't attempting to make some sort of veiled threat with that last sentence, either. Because, if you need to be reminded, this is a public forum of which many eyes read. Threatening someone would be an unwise thing to do. But, surely, you aren't doing that.
Since you have plainly stated that you "don't trust Sgrena", it is clear why you haven't even attempted to understand my original post.
For me, this isn't a matter of trust. This is about analyzing motives. I understand that Sgrena has Anti-American bias in general. However, she was not alone in that car. She was with the Italian Intelligence Officer, Calipari. He wasn't stupid. He wanted to live. And that motive, wanting to live, shared by both Sgrena and Calipari, strongly outweighs any motive they might have for plotting a scandal against the US.
US Intelligence, on the other hand, has a strong motive to create an easily untraceable "unfortunate event" that makes it appear that the "Anti-American" journalist was a victim of the Fog of War.
Does it require me to not trust US Intelligence to believe they have this motive? No. Others might argue that US Intel would never do something like this because the scandal would be to outrageous. Well, look at what US Intel is saying right now: "It was obviously an accident. Our deepist sympathies go out to Calipari's family for this unfortunate occurance. We had no knowledge they would be in the area."
Time to eat pizza....
Posted by: Sally at March 05, 2005 10:33 PM (4oTpc)
Posted by: RicardoVerde at March 05, 2005 10:44 PM (3DOby)
Seems you're throwing rocks through your glass house walls. You apparently cannot read.
Patriotism has nothing to do with good reading skills...........dear.
QUARK2
Posted by: quark2 at March 05, 2005 10:49 PM (U98ZF)
Posted by: gail at March 05, 2005 10:50 PM (47cun)
Posted by: Mirramele at March 05, 2005 10:51 PM (KtFTf)
Posted by: Koe at March 05, 2005 10:52 PM (KniaQ)
Posted by: gail at March 05, 2005 10:56 PM (47cun)
Posted by: quark2 at March 05, 2005 10:57 PM (U98ZF)
Posted by: Walter E. Wallis at March 05, 2005 10:59 PM (7XPVo)
TBF says" "Remember Occam's razor" ...well I'm not sure that some sort of collusion with the kidnappers or an attempt to force a confrontation would be excluded at this point. ...Or it could be she's just plain stupid... which would explain more than just this incident.
Posted by: Chuck at March 05, 2005 11:04 PM (0syAf)
Oh, and by the way, as far as Bush & Co. lying about the WMD's - it was a view held by EVERY major intelligence agency in the world (I'm including France in there even though the words France & intelligence don't mesh well).
So shut your pissing and moaning mouths, admit that Bush was right and go about your business. Damn if you losers expended as much energy doing something productive instead of bitching about the mythical big-bad America you might have unemployment in single digits some time. You don't necessarily have to agree with everything we do, but at least you should have the common courtesy of humping dolphins or saving trees and leave the adults to the chores of changing a repulsive (and profitable to EU) Middle East into something that resembles civilization.
And one more thing - this is one American who doesn't give two shits about a communist's story stacked up against an American soldiers. Anyone who stands up and proclaims themselves an adherent to an ideology that killed MANY more people in the 20th century then Nazis doesn't deserve any respect. My only regret is that your intelligence officer was killed and not that b**ch that deserved it.
Posted by: F-Her at March 05, 2005 11:05 PM (PG+qd)
I couldn't understand how she thought you posted a threat either. A very odd reaction.
Perhaps English is not Sally's native language. She may have misunderstood when reading "making a public spectacle of yourself" (ie. you're making yourself look foolish), and instead, interpreted the remark to mean that she would have a "public execution".
Who knows?
Posted by: Mirramele at March 05, 2005 11:07 PM (KtFTf)
It's lovely to watch two people that can't (or won't) wrap their minds around a simple concept regress to juvenile "one liners". If that's the best the readers that this forum can offer up, then I've mistakenly stumbled across a "beginners" play ground in blogger commentary. So I must move be moving on, and I'll be sure to direct any kids practicing their "kung-fu" skills down your direction.
Cheers!
Posted by: Sally at March 05, 2005 11:10 PM (4oTpc)
People commented that currently, the sole news source was this Italian Communist news publication. However, one genius thought that the information posted was referring to Marx's original "THE Communist Manifesto" and so posted that "we were all morons".
I almost choked while reading his post.
Posted by: Mirramele at March 05, 2005 11:15 PM (KtFTf)
Posted by: quark2 at March 05, 2005 11:16 PM (U98ZF)
To answer your ridiculous question re: Can democracy be achieved with blood? Uhhhhh....yes, why don't you look up a few small countries by the name of Japan and Germany.
And yes, you are right this is a war was about OIL. Only it's the "righteous" countries opposed to the war that we're reaping cash from the Food for Oil scandal. Probably don't read much about that in your EU papers I'll bet. Probably don't read much about the child-rapist UN peacekeepers in the Congo, Haiti, etc either. And American are the dumb ones......Okay.....
Posted by: Richard James at March 05, 2005 11:23 PM (PG+qd)
I find very curious as US people doesn't know the history of Europe, 'cause if you're referring to an ideology (60 years ago ideology) related to Italy, it would be called Fascism. Germany, Italy and Japan were ally. But not all the people who lived (or live) in those countries would be "nazist/fascism/jap". And I'm talking about a thing of two days ago (1 day for US for time zone) and not 60 years ago.
I find also strange how it's so strange for many people to understand that diplomacy exists also to avoid wars. But making war is better because also army-producer had to eat... War is better, is easier, and requires only a tribute in blood and money. Diplomacy requires too much sophisticated way of thinking. Try to thing only for one minute: US has the right to impose its policy/civilization on other countries? You consider civilization to shoot agaist everyone, children, women, men? I think that civilization is RESPECT for ourself and others, and also accepting differences. NOT impose one ego on another one.
Posted by: Koe at March 05, 2005 11:24 PM (KniaQ)
sorry to contradict you. I don't believe you could understand the REAL politics of Japan during and after IIWW. There are some many documents which are unknown to Western. So If you call that "democracy" I close an eye, and think "yes, US version". Many US storics don't understand even today some way of acting of Japan at time. But it was 60 years matters again.
I only stated a simple sentence. If you can't read that, I can't do nothing. I don't believe in war. Simply. Because war is first of all a mental state. The mental state of people who claim/consider themselves better than others. But someone could ironically respond: "yes you (generic you) are better... (but you can't even understand what I'm saying)."
Posted by: Koe at March 05, 2005 11:34 PM (KniaQ)
Michael, what do you think, I just make things up? I will readily admit that I don't know if Bloomberg got the quote right or not, but it's in their story, and its in the article associated with this comment group, so I should think you would have known this if you had read the article before commenting. If you did but missed it, I suggest you go back and read it.
Posted by: Charles Wayne CT at March 05, 2005 11:36 PM (t2ioQ)
I'm glad to hear of your concern for History. Tell me Koe, what nationality formed the majority of the soldiers of the WWII Allied Force invasion Italy?
The Allied invasion force which fought and died to rid Italy of Benito Mussolini's dictatorship. A fascist dictator responsible for the invasion of neighboring countries and the murder of thousands of innocent people. A fascist dictator who allied Italy with Hitler's Germany during the greatest genocidal bloodbath in modern history.
Koe, from what country did most those Allied soldiers originate?
Koe by the way, most of the European students that I work with have demonstrated a horrible background in American history, and most surprisingly, little knowledge of their own country's history during the last 200 years.
Posted by: Mirramele at March 05, 2005 11:43 PM (KtFTf)
chosen to act out Darwins law. Culling the gene pool.
Posted by: quark2 at March 05, 2005 11:43 PM (U98ZF)
You will have to come up with far more to make your illogical ravings even appear coherent. At this point, without more information, logic leads us to conclude that this incident arose from incompetence at the hands of someone - most likely those transporting Sgrena - than from any whacky conspiracy.
Posted by: Robin Roberts at March 05, 2005 11:44 PM (xauGB)
Posted by: Robin Roberts at March 05, 2005 11:46 PM (xauGB)
Also, I know the party line in Europe is that Americans don't understand history, Europe etc. It give you all a sense of superiority. You need it, because you have lost all sense of morals and ethics, you have few if any accomplishments. So you resort to...how did you put it..."sophisticated diplomacy"...well, I guess if you have ransacked your military in order to supplement a lavish social welfare system, then "sophisticated diplomacy" is kinda...you know...the only thing you can do. We tried diplomacy, and it was the cease-fire at the end of the Gulf War. If you try thinking outside of your European echo-chamber, you might realize that, in fact, this war was not illegal at all because Iraq had not adhered to the cease fire after the first Gulf War. So, yes diplomacy has its place....you should talk to Neville Chamberlain about how great diplomacy works...if England/France had responded to Hitler's aggression vis-a-vis Czechoslavakia with armed force do you have any idea how many lives would have been saved....don't just brush that off...think about it....millions and millions of people would have been saved, including many Italians. Millions, but hey, diplomacy is GREAT!!
We, on the other hand have options. We are not restrained to "diplomacy" due to overindulgence in welfare. The status quo in the Middle East was not working. 40+ years of extremism culminating in the World Trade Center attacks. Al Quaeda was the instigator, but as leftist like to say there were "root causes". We saw the "root causes" as corrupt, authoritarian regimes. Democracies don't, as a rule, make war on each other. So why not give it a try, we thought. Seems to be working so far, and spreading a little bit too. Must eat you guys up having to see it working to plan.
You can talk all you want about shooting women, children, etc. but you and I both know that when America does it is an accident. If you deny this then you are just simply a raving lunatic. My only question for you is - why the selective outrage? Where is the anger at China for imposing abortions? Where is the anger at North Korea, for starving men, women (and YES!) children while building expensive nuclear weapons? Not as fun to go after them, is it? Maybe because it is not as cool...not as hip....
Just food for though. I think most Europeans don't realize they are being led by the nose by a media and political elite to anti-Americanism because it gets them votes. You shouldn't bite the hand that feeds (ie protects) you. We may remember our friends when your "sophisticated" diplomacy results in an Iranian nuke heading your way....and maybe we just will decide to say "NO" to war then. Food for thought.
Posted by: F-Her at March 05, 2005 11:52 PM (PG+qd)
I'm sorry, but maybe I wasn't clear as I would. I try to explain again. I'm not against US. I'm against "this kind of policy choosen by US". And for my own regret, Italy has taken the same policy. The US have helped to free Italy in the IIWW, but I can't believe you make the assumption Italian person=Fascism=Mussolini. I hate ALL the genocide, made during IIWW, in many states of Africa, in Bosnia, Kossovo, or in Iraq. It's not a patriotic matter. It's a problem or prospective: the idea that ONLY war could the the way to obtain progress. I simply don't believe that. You don't have to remid me facts of 60 years ago. I write in this blog to report only FACTS about a loss that Italy had. I'm not here to defend or oppose a US or other country Government. I simply disagree with some choices. Can someone disagree? Or is it better to not say what someone thinks? Sartre said " If I can't say NO, the war is also MY war". Because otherwise it would be a form of agreement. US have many beautiful things. But have also ugly ones. As every nation. Every nation has its problems. I don't despise US. I despice war as the unique way of acting.
I hope that my words helped to clarify. Otherwise I can't say in another way...
Posted by: Koe at March 05, 2005 11:58 PM (KniaQ)
Naivete is not a principle.
Posted by: Robin Roberts at March 06, 2005 12:04 AM (xauGB)
But in my precedent posts I simply express my concern on a serious "accident" and I claimed that we are only waiting for TRUTH. I pointed no finger to nobody... so I don't understand why it's so difficult for you guys to understand my point of view. I don't think my English is so bad (and sorry if it is), but I only expressed my concern here. Everyone could think what he/she wants. But it's the lack of information that would cause post as some I've seen here. And I can't accept to see someone calling bad words on a woman who was shooten by soldiers, even if it's for error.
Thinking is nothing releated with patriotism or ideology. Thinking is simply two or more people that reason together and respect each other, as I try to do... If someone can't reach it...
Good night.
Posted by: Koe at March 06, 2005 12:18 AM (KniaQ)
You don't believe in war? See this is exactly the type of simplistic, childish, viewpoint that is going to lead your country to a very unsightly place. Don't believe in war??? What the hell does that even mean? War is ugly, brutal, nasty and is a last resort. But until the rest of us live in the perfect world you seem to already live in, there will be a need for armies to protect us. I guess that shouldn't worry you though, the US will always step in for you as the adult. Keep living your dreams, and don't drink the bong water, dude.
As far as Japan goes, I know English isn't your native language, and I'm not going to put you down for that, but I need to make this clear: Japan NEVER had a democracy. Not close. Not even a non-"American-style" democracy. NONE. How did they get there? Was it the mysterious paperwork you refer to? NOOOOOO....it was at a cost of blood!!! Democracy quite literally at the barrel of a gun. General McArthur wrote their friggin constitution. Now, I don't expect you to know this....you probably only hear about our evil (sorry you probably don't use words like good and evil unless referring to the US) dropping of the bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki. I'm here to tell you, today, that Japan is a democracy because men were willing to die, and America came not as a conquerer but a redeemer. And yes, you are right, that was sixty years ago, but America hasn't changed in this regard. We do what's right. Not what's easy. Not what's more profitabable (see France, Russia, China and just about every other backwater country). What's right...and it is why we are in Iraq. You might say..."but, but women, children,...dying...it's not worth it..." Funny those that say this were not very loud and emotional about Saddams and Uday's rape rooms...the people (300,000 last count) that just disappeared, never to be seen again until American and coalition forces uncovered their mass graves. I dare say there is some racism at work with the anti-war folks. They don't believe brown people are worth saving.
And to quote you "if you don't understand what I'm saying there is nothing I can do"...how typically European of me.
Posted by: Richard James at March 06, 2005 12:20 AM (R4FGI)
Posted by: bullwinkle at March 06, 2005 12:21 AM (9KpI+)
Posted by: Koe at March 06, 2005 12:22 AM (KniaQ)
Posted by: F-Her at March 06, 2005 12:29 AM (R4FGI)
Perhaps I am misunderstanding you.
We are criticizing one female, Italian, communist journalist; not assuming that all Italians agree with her political views. No-one thinks Italy is still controlled by the Fascist party. Americans know that Italy is more of a middle-of-the-road or conservative nation than the rest of Europe. Even the Italian Communist party is more conservative than elsewhere in Europe.
Neither am I confusing Italy's current political environment with Fascist political movements which existed during earlier decades.
Diplomatic history doesn't always bear out your argument that war is the easier route. Yes, diplomacy has its uses and works well within certain conditions, yet there are several historical examples where continued diplomatic negiotiations made matters worse. For example, diplomats brought about all those secret European alliances leading to WWI.
Moreover, there are historical situations where military actions have been necessary to end tyranny. For example, your friend Garibaldi would not have agreed that all war is bad. Without warfare, Italy would never rid itself of the Hapsbergs and have remained an Austrian domain. Neither would Italy have become a unified nation constitutional monarchy,(later a republic) instead of the 19th-century hodgepodge of separate Italian countries.
Posted by: Mirramele at March 06, 2005 12:32 AM (KtFTf)
PS. If I don't respond, it's because I do really need to sleep. Here there are at least 6/8 hours of time zone. Bye bye
Posted by: Koe at March 06, 2005 12:35 AM (KniaQ)
You are way out there dude. Your memorized slogans make no sense. War is not genocide...uh...genocide is genocide. As a matter of fact.....I..believe...yes...there it is in the old history book....war can actually STOP genocide. See chapter 5: Nazis, also chapter 9: Bosnia. And to see what happens when you don't make war on genocide see chapter 7: Rawanda).
And here is the clincher "stupidity is violence because it makes you attack rather then think". Well, Mr Slogan, what happens when a stupid person attacks you?
My God, are all Europeans like you? I'm losing the last remaining respect I had for your countries as I read your posts. I had actually bought a little into the idea that your people were somehow more educated. Silly me. Now go recite some more slogans that, even if they don't contradict, are just plain nonesense.
Posted by: Koe-ron at March 06, 2005 12:38 AM (R4FGI)
America helped rid Italy of the Nazi/Fascist stench.
Italy returned the favor with the most wonderful of gifts.
The Mafia.
Thank you, Koe, and your country, for helping us in our war on Islamofascism.
Fuck you Koe, and your country, for murdering thousands of our citizens based on your medieval Cosa Nostra. Which strongly resembles a certain "religion of peace."
I do like fettucine alfredo, though.
Posted by: The Ayatollah Assahola at March 06, 2005 12:40 AM (lK7Sh)
"remained an Austrian domain" to "large regions remaining under to control of Austrian monarchs."
Also, although, this next example is overused but: Neville Chamber's diplomatic meeting with Hitler.
Time for sleep, goodnight
Posted by: Mirramele at March 06, 2005 12:41 AM (KtFTf)
Now, continue on with your anti-Americanism. Oh, yeah, I forgot...your not anti-American....right....
Posted by: F-Her at March 06, 2005 12:45 AM (R4FGI)
please... She is a "comunist"? Ok, let your mouth take all the air you need. She was in Iraq, she talked us abour what she saw. Her photos. The bombs used there on children. Comunists hate children, didn't you know?
Mirramele,
Italian's politic is very strange. Too difficult to understand even for us in our country. Really. Too much ideology. Too much attaks government/opposition. It's their favourite sport. Forza Italia (Berlusconi's political force) is not Fascism. Even if it's conservatory-like. As for Garibaldi... he did war. History is made up of war. Well he make the Italy unified for the first time, 'cause we have dominionations of foreign Empires. But he was ITALIAN. Not a foreign man.
Posted by: Koe at March 06, 2005 12:49 AM (KniaQ)
I'm sorry for the US people who are civil and intelligent enough to understand and talk without shout. As in every nation, there are intelligent people and stupid people. It's life. Who doesn't own a brain, can't understand... and see comunism everywhere. And there is no need to reply further...
Posted by: Koe at March 06, 2005 01:00 AM (KniaQ)
Yes, I will take some air. Fresh air is good for the mind. You must have quite a bit of pollution where your at.
- Yes she's a communist. That is established.
- No, communists don't hate kids, but their actions have killed more kids then any other ideology. Don't argue that, its fact.
- If you can't tell the ethical difference between accidental bombing killing MINIMAL amounts of innocent civilians as opposed intentional killing by Saddam, then you are a miserable human wretch. I'm tired of pulling punches. You are not a peace advocate, you are an advocate for homicidal dictators and the like. America is a force for good. Period. Cite me evidence where America INTENIONALLY killed innocents in this war and we'll discuss. Don't say that America covers it up either, we have every single press agency in the world trying to pin something on us, so that doesn't work buddy. You know America is bad, so 1 single intentional death. Just one....I'll wait....still waiting.....
Posted by: F-Her at March 06, 2005 01:00 AM (R4FGI)
Communism murdered over 100 million in the last century - including children. Pathetic rhetoric about "bombs" just shows you are not a serious person.
Posted by: Robin Roberts at March 06, 2005 01:02 AM (xauGB)
Posted by: bullwinkle at March 06, 2005 01:03 AM (9KpI+)
Ahhh, when all else fails and you start losing an argument, start crying about how uncivilized the other person is. You are the typicall liberal. And no, we don't see communists everywhere, only when it is an ADMITTED communist reporting for a COMMUNIST newspaper. That is just so paranoid of us.....
As far as many Europeans being anti-US, I think it is high time some Americans got a little anti-European. We've got plenty of reasons, and you are a poster child for those reasons.
Posted by: Koe-ron at March 06, 2005 01:05 AM (R4FGI)
Posted by: F-Her at March 06, 2005 01:11 AM (R4FGI)
Yeah, when are we going to get around to that? Oh, wait...
Posted by: mantis at March 06, 2005 02:23 AM (zmcHh)
I suppose that is what passes for a snappy retort where you're from. Let me put in a simpler way for you - you'll know the US is anti-European when we start voting a certain way in the UN just because it is in opposition to European interests, much the way a good part of Europe does with the US. Also, some behind the scenes maneuvering/cajoling to entice others to vote against European interests, ala the French in the run-up to the Iraq war. Then, even witty people like you will know we are being anti-European.
Until then we will just wait for Europe to implode as they bite at our ankles, criticizing incessantly as the US goes about the business of trying to make the world a better place for future generations of ALL countries, not just welfare-state European nitwits.
Posted by: Daisy Duke at March 06, 2005 03:14 AM (R4FGI)
Eeew! It ascribes execrable motives and mores to an already tainted woman!
Posted by: Carridine at March 06, 2005 03:25 AM (Splh2)
I look forward to that. In the meantime I'll just enjoy freedom fries and Bill O'Reilly's boycott. High-larious
Posted by: mantis at March 06, 2005 03:29 AM (zmcHh)
Yes, we'll just have to wait. For now the US doesn't need to turn diplomatic relations into something resembling a teenage temper tantrum like some of our erstwhile "allies" seem to do. By the way, if memory serves me, it is not just Bill O'Reilly boycotting Europe (more specifically France). Last article I read about relations had interviews with several Parisian hotel and restaraunt owners begging Americans to return in their previous numbers. I'll bet this "high-larious" boycott added a few tenths of a point to the upswing in already high (I believe record-high)unemployment in France. If so you may want to ask those displaced employees how "high-larious" Bill O'Reilly is.
Then again it that may be more attributable to French economic inaptitude, 3 hour liquid lunches and continuous union strikes combined with the loss of their sugar-daddy Saddam's blood money via the Oil-for-food program.
Keep eating them freedom fries!!!
Posted by: Daisy Duke at March 06, 2005 03:45 AM (R4FGI)
The blame for this woman's death lies with the "insurgents". If they weren't posing as civilians in their attacks then US soldiers, Iraqi security personnel and Iraqi civilians wouldn't need to defend themselves from civilian automobiles.
Posted by: am at March 06, 2005 03:58 AM (ruCAs)
Posted by: hulley at March 06, 2005 05:31 AM (y4PlS)
You really must believe that the US intelligence service is the worst in the world, nay, in the universe. If they wanted her to be dead, they would have done what they did to those 4 Al-Qaeda guys a couple of years back in Yemen(?). Used a remote controled plane with a Hellfire missile.
They wouldn't even been able recognize the remains.
Posted by: madne0 at March 06, 2005 06:46 AM (S9ApA)
As a Pro-US Italian who is disgusted with many of her countrymen,I have to say that I agree 100% with what you say here.
Posted by: Stefania at March 06, 2005 07:14 AM (6NBdg)
Commie fraud Beee-Ach!
Dear Lord: Please send this hairy lipped commie scribbler a horrific case of anal warts.
Posted by: obsnooks at March 06, 2005 07:51 AM (cXqSY)
I wonder if they ALSO advised the driver to speed through US checkpoints. I wonder who the driver was ... This story stinks.
PS Minor point ... there are all these comments made by Sgrena's boyfriend ... but isn't she ALSO supposed to be married with 2 kids back in Italy ... ????
Also ...Wasn't she wounded in the arm? And she can still type an account ????
Posted by: FrauBudgie at March 06, 2005 07:56 AM (Q6HU9)
Posted by: Spartaco at March 06, 2005 08:00 AM (0GJ72)
Guardian
But in an interview Saturday with Italian La 7 TV, Sgrena said "there was no bright light, no signal."
CNN
"It wasn't a checkpoint, but a patrol that shot as soon as they lit us up with a spotlight," she told him.
Posted by: drscroogemcduck at March 06, 2005 08:13 AM (NgHvK)
Posted by: profwalker at March 06, 2005 09:54 AM (IeZnt)
Read my list of questions posted in the earlier part of the comments. The Italian government should have a police forensics expert examine the agent's wounds to determine type, distance and direction of the weapon that killed him.
Posted by: Mirramele at March 06, 2005 09:54 AM (Eoe3J)
http://www.repubblica.it/2005/c/sezioni/esteri/iraq45/cermiss/cermiss.html
Posted by: Spartaco at March 06, 2005 10:03 AM (0GJ72)
Posted by: stupidanddumb at March 06, 2005 10:09 AM (0Unub)
Posted by: Stefania at March 06, 2005 10:42 AM (6NBdg)
Posted by: CJ at March 06, 2005 11:20 AM (cEqQB)
The worst part for me is that the Italian Secret Service agent died to save her worthless life. That is a shame.
Posted by: Trapeze at March 06, 2005 11:44 AM (ds4O8)
http://216.239.37.104/translate_c?hl=en&sl=it&u=http://www.ilmanifesto.it/&prev=/search%3Fq%3Dil%2Bmanifesto%26hl%3Den%26lr%3D
Posted by: Mirramele at March 06, 2005 11:45 AM (Eoe3J)
Posted by: Rich at March 06, 2005 12:00 PM (KSEUz)
The Communist anti-democracy radical left are planning on an early rally, before any formal investigations prove this reporter to be a lier.
Once the forensics report, interviews with the soldiers and other investigative information becomes available, IL Manfesto will be revealed to be screaming assumptions, speculations and lies.
Are there any Italian Protest Warriors available to present the other side?
Questions to be answered:
Was the weapon proven to be used by the soldiers? How do we know the reporter didn’t murder the agent to create a story and gain political power?
We need to know what type of weapon was used, and the distance and direction of the bullet.
We need to find out if the driver worked for the kidnappers/terrorist group t(hat she claimed kidnapped her) and if so, could the driver have volunteered for a suicide mission by attempting to speed past a checkpoint ordering them to slow down?
Again, any Italian Protest Warriors available?
Posted by: Mirramele at March 06, 2005 12:21 PM (Eoe3J)
Posted by: JohnW at March 06, 2005 12:48 PM (N+V3m)
Uncanny -- Peculiarly unsettling, as if of supernatural origin or nature; eerie.
I believe you meant to use uncanny rather than canny in the 8th paragraph down.
Posted by: Mr. Monk at March 06, 2005 01:06 PM (0UpPc)
First glance appears to be a friendly fire death which is sad.
Posted by: EP at March 06, 2005 02:19 PM (6krEN)
Posted by: Spartaco at March 06, 2005 02:51 PM (XpINw)
Posted by: Vic at March 06, 2005 02:57 PM (uq30O)
Just wait a few days, and we'll find out there's a lot more to this story than meets the eye.
Posted by: EyeDoc at March 06, 2005 02:58 PM (WjQ47)
There's a story here that doesn't add up, and it's not the checkpoint soldiers'. "Ambush," my sweet little donkey.
Posted by: Spanky at March 06, 2005 03:14 PM (botyS)
God, said I needed to do penance and so he sent me to Italy. Well, the pasta and vino was good.
Posted by: vic at March 06, 2005 03:16 PM (uq30O)
Posted by: Vic at March 06, 2005 04:08 PM (uq30O)
http://snipurl.com/d9iu
Amazing how they shot out the front windshield! And look at all the bullet holes!
Oh wait. They didn't blow out the windshield, and there AREN'T any bullet holes!
Hmm... I sniff a fish.
Posted by: Wonderduck at March 06, 2005 04:08 PM (ywZa8)
Posted by: h0mi at March 06, 2005 04:16 PM (LuPL2)
You really dug down deep for that one, didn't you Trapeze? Thanks for not adding any constructive thought to this forum, we all appreciate it.
Your contribution is some idiotic conspiracy, and you're accusing me of not adding anything constructive? You are stupid beyond belief. Get a grip on reality and maybe I'll indulge your request. Until then, lay off the crack.
Posted by: Trapeze at March 06, 2005 04:57 PM (ds4O8)
Posted by: Trapeze at March 06, 2005 04:58 PM (ds4O8)
Posted by: Brad at March 06, 2005 05:48 PM (ywZa8)
Posted by: I'm french' & I'm proud at March 06, 2005 06:11 PM (xTwDq)
In NI everyone knows the score - checkpoint? Sloooow down or get shot. Simple no? How come these experienced security chaps did not?
Wait until the facts are all gathered in but I for one do not beleive half of what the mad woman is saying now as she keeps changing her story. BBC is now saying she says she was targeted deliberately. Yeah right. Had she been so then she'd be dead.
Posted by: dave t at March 06, 2005 06:29 PM (4zT3Y)
Shootings like this occur daily. However, they are a necessary evil and despite what some of you idiots thoughtlessly blurt out, these checkpoints have thwarted several prospective car bomb attacks, or in the least minimized their damage. She said it wasn't a checkpoint, but that they flashed lights on her????? Yes, lights from a CHECKPOINT which are used at night to warn incoming vehicles. What is WRONG with this woman? She escapes from the hands of a disgusting breed of mostly-foreigners who have decided they're going to slaughter any Iraqi involved with rebuilding the country and she talks about them like they're freedom fighters. And now America purposefully tried to kill her??????
Do you really think that in the dark of night ANY soldier at that checkpoint knew who was inside the car???? Clearly there is a very POOR line of communication between the Italian efforts in this release and the Americans and there needs to be an investigation. We need to find out whether the Italians made the Coalition aware of their efforts and where they were going to be. If it is found that there was no knowledge of her release, then you cannot blame the soldiers at the checkpoint for following the protocol that has been IN PLACE FOR OVER A YEAR. Geez, people, THINK. Stop these heated trainwrecks-of discussions about an Italian left-wing conspiracy or an American right-wing conspiracy. You're both WRONG.
Posted by: Igor Kazakov at March 06, 2005 06:42 PM (xM3Dg)
"You're driving along and you see a couple of soldiers standing by the side of the road - but that's a pretty ubiquitous sight in Baghdad, so you don't think anything of it. Next thing you know, soldiers are screaming at you, pointing their rifles and swiveling tank guns in your direction, and you didn't even know it was a checkpoint."
....
"This feeling is a holdover from the days of Saddam, when driving slowly past a government building or installation was considered suspicious behavior. Get caught idling past the wrong palaces or ministry, and you might never be seen again....This fear comes into play at checkpoints because US troops are often accompanied by a cordon of Iraqi security forces - and a lot of the assassinations and kidnappings have been carried out by Iraqi security forces or people dressed in their uniforms. Often the Iraqi security forces are the first troops visible at checkpoints. If they are angry-looking and you hear shots being fired, it becomes easier to misread the situation and put the pedal to the metal."
....
"The essential problem with checkpoints is that the Americans don't know if the Iraqis are "friendlies" or not, and the Iraqis don't know what the Americans want them to do."
Food for thought.
Posted by: mantis at March 06, 2005 06:43 PM (zmcHh)
Posted by: Igor Kazakov at March 06, 2005 06:46 PM (xM3Dg)
Things happen fast in war zones. And, most people who have been to Italy will tell you just crossing the street takes your life into your hands. Italian drivers are nuts. They aren't spooked by roadway definitions, either.
And, the guy's dead from a single bullet wound to the head. While sitting in the back of the car. And, the passenger in the front seat was doing what? Who forced the driver to use speed, when caution was necessary?
So many holes in this story. Thank goodness for the Internet. And, the ability of many who read this to raise the questions that need to be asked.
HA! Once, the MSM thought the weekends were slow newsdays. But not to us in pajamas. I hope our Iraqi troops know we're going to be on top of this until the TRUTH COMES OUT! And, as far as Eason Jordan goes, I don't want to hear from him until he releases his remarks from Davos.
HIP DEEP IN THE BIG MUDDY. NO TURNING AROUND, NOW.
Posted by: Carol Herman at March 06, 2005 06:52 PM (4BTRS)
Posted by: Robin Roberts at March 06, 2005 07:17 PM (xauGB)
Posted by: Comrade_Tovarich at March 06, 2005 07:25 PM (W1wPB)
BTW, I think we need to come up with a name for this traffic phenomenon that seems somewhat unique to The Jawa Report. Some ideas:
MoonBatalanche
Leftalanche
Moronalanche
Same-Loser-Posting-Over-And-Over-aLanche
Wow-DU-Must-be-Downalanche
Posted by: John from WuzzaDem at March 06, 2005 07:46 PM (Pt3Le)
Posted by: Igor Kazakov at March 06, 2005 08:02 PM (xM3Dg)
Two points:
- of what do you have to be proud of, being French? Jeez, you may want to look at your country and rethink that pride.
- yes we are putting this "courageous" (as you put it) woman down. She is a dirty communist, and as fun as you think they are (much like you thought Facism was a good time when you entertained the Nazis for 4 years), they are responsible for more human suffering in world history then any other ideological force. Any. She is a filthy whore for the communist cause, and, I'm sorry to say, we Americans don't think that a person who furthers this ideology is "courageous". But I guess we and a handful of other populations, are the only ones who actually combine intellect WITH backbone in order to form our plans of actions.
As to your point about taking a "holyday" (it's holiday moron) to go to Iraq, it may be beyond you to understand, but one can have an opinion about something without being knee deep in combat. And I'm fairly certain that a majority of Iraqis would indeed show us gratitude, unlike you filthy frogs.
French = Cowards
Posted by: Richard James at March 06, 2005 08:24 PM (PG+qd)
And never forget, an italian whore is a pizza ass.
Posted by: Mr. K at March 06, 2005 09:21 PM (w/2iI)
Posted by: Robin Roberts at March 06, 2005 09:55 PM (xauGB)
Sorry. In my defense, the AP is being INCREDIBLY vague here.
Posted by: Wonderduck at March 06, 2005 10:50 PM (ywZa8)
Posted by: John H. at March 06, 2005 11:22 PM (nlWFp)
There are rules, she would have made it past the checkpoint without issue had she complied with the requirements. I have no sense of urgency when it comes to journalists...they get in line with John Doe.
Specifially to John H., come to my house for cocktails tommorrow, and I'll give you a class on where your rights come from.
Posted by: Major Mike at March 07, 2005 12:42 AM (fLlQ8)
Not.
Well said, Major Mike. Its clear that Sgrena is on the side of the terrorists.
Posted by: Robin Roberts at March 07, 2005 01:02 AM (xauGB)
In the middle ages the test was pretty simple. I'm probably remembering incorrectly as my head is crowded by the 'MontyPythonHolyGrail-as-light-as-a-duck' test... but it boils down to if the woman floats she's burned as a witch and if she sinks, she's mourned, but proven innocent.
So as with the three Japanese 'hostage-frauds', the two Italian 'hostage-frauds', the recently released "journalist" who was able to prove his anti-American writings to be excused, and now Mrs. Hail-of-Bullets...
This woman faced the "test".
Would she die and so be proven an innocent victim, or be released and be proven a collaborator?
The irony of course is that the 'witch' is released to burn us... rather then be burned.
My apologies to Witches of course... I don't mean to compare you to terrorists... rather I was struck by the Medieval nature of the Islamofascist methodology.
Posted by: DANEgerus at March 07, 2005 02:15 AM (WbXzj)
Posted by: GUITAR X at March 07, 2005 02:22 AM (4glSZ)
Well, as a trader yes, you should be a proud Frenchman. In the invasion of Normandy, there were five beach heads, one Canadian, two British, and two American, not one god blessed French beach heads. In that invasion there were 170 Frenchmen, and not one single one got a scratch, all the rest of the cowards were in Africa sunning themselves and waiting for the liberation of Paris. Real proud of that aren't you, you had to have someone else liberate you stupid asses from the Germans, You gave up all of France in 20 minutes when Germany invaded your country. Be proud of that hero, make a poster of it and put it on the Paris walls. All your country did was sell arms to Saddam conniving and corruption, Bush got wise to you doings, and kicked your asses out of Iraq Hope you never get to go back to do your dirty corruptions again. Frogs, arrgghhh!!
===========
*["We do not accept a false caricature that divides the Western world between
an idealistic United States and a cynical Euro
Posted by: Vic at March 07, 2005 02:46 AM (ul3Uv)
Posted by: Spartaco at March 07, 2005 08:05 AM (jmWCy)
Posted by: Robin Roberts at March 07, 2005 09:30 AM (xauGB)
Posted by: Roman at March 07, 2005 09:44 AM (3ApEW)
I hope this gets some attention...
US citizens should understand that some political positions in Italy are anti-american "a priori", regardless of what the US does, or doesn't.
Giuliana Sgrena's fiancee declared on Italian TV that he was sure she had been ambushed, because the Americans didn't want her to get back to Italy.
With all due respect for Giuliana Sgrena, I had never heard of her before her abduction, and I am an Italian living in Italy. So I imagine she wasn't exactly an household name in the USA either...
Why then would the US want to try and kill her?
And more to the point, (and I speak as an officer who spent 10 years working with US personnel)if the US wanted her dead, she would be dead. A machine gun burst, a frag lobbed into the wreck...
So, in my opinion, the truth is: lack of coordination between US and Italian people on the field; maybe some overeagerness of the Italian driver, darkness, some soldier who had lost 1500 friends and didn't really want to be the next to go back in a body bag. Please feel free to comment on my little literary work. regds gb
Posted by: giulio at March 07, 2005 09:57 AM (MIWAC)
Posted by: Den at March 07, 2005 10:24 AM (I4wCe)
March 6, 2005 (from Il Manifesto)—I am still in the darkness. Last Friday was the most dramatic day of my life since I was abducted.
I had just spoken with my abductors, who for days kept telling me I would be released. So I was living in wait. They said things that I would understand only later. They talked of transfer related problems. I had learned to understand which way the wind blew from the attitude of my two "sentinels," the two fellows who watched over me every day—especially one of them, who attended to my requests, was incredibly bold. In the attempt to understand what was going on, I provocatively asked him if he was happy because I would go away or because I would stay. I was surprised and happy when, for the first time, he told me, "I only know you will go, but I don't know when."
To confirm that something new was happening, at one point they both came in the room to reassure me and joke: "Congratulations," they said, "you are leaving for Rome." To Rome, that's what they were saying.
I had a weird feeling, because that word immediately evoked liberation but also projected a void inside myself. I realized it was the most difficult moment of my abduction and that if all I had lived yet was certain, now an abyss of heavy uncertainties was widening. I changed my clothes.
They came back: "We'll escort you, but don't give signals of your presence, otherwise the Americans might intervene." That was not what wanted to hear. It was the happiest and also the most dangerous moment. If we ran into someone, meaning American troops, there would be an exchange of fire, and my captors were ready and they would have responded. I had to have my eyes covered. I was already getting used to a temporary blindness.
About what happened outside, I only knew that in Baghdad it had rained. The car ran safely in a muddy area. There was the driver and the same old abductors. I soon heard something I didn't want to hear. A helicopter flying low over the area we had stopped in. "Don't worry, now they will come look for you . . . within ten minutes they will come." They had spoken Arabic all the time, some French and much broken English. Now they spoke in this way, too.
Then they got out of the car. I stayed in that condition of immobility and blindness. My eyes were stuffed with cotton, and covered by sunglasses. I was motionless. I thought . . . what do I do? Should I start counting the passing seconds to another condition, the one of freedom? I had just started counting when I heard a friendly voice: "Giuliana, Giuliana, this is Nicola, don't worry, I've talked to Gabriele Polo, don't worry, you're free."
He took my cotton blindfold and sunglasses off. I felt relieved, not for what was going on, which I didn't understand, but for Nicola's words. He kept talking nonstop, he was uncontainable, a flood of friendly words and jokes. I finally found comfort, almost physically, a warm comfort I had long since forgotten.
The car proceeded on its way, through an underpass full of puddles, almost skidding to avoid them. We engaged in incredible laughter. It was relieving. Skidding along a road full of water in Baghdad and maybe have a bad car crash after all I had experienced would not be really explainable. Nicola Calipari sat by my side. The driver had notified the embassy and Italy twice that we were heading to the airport, which I knew was controlled by the American troops. It was less than one kilometre, they told me . . . when. . . . I remember only fire. At that point a rain of fire and bullets came at us, forever silencing the happy voices from a few minutes earlier.
The driver started shouting we were Italians, "We are Italians! We are Italians . . ." Nicola Calipari dove on top of me to protect me and immediately, and I mean immediately, I felt his last breath as he died on me. I must have felt physical pain, I didn't know why. But I had a sudden thought: I recalled my abductors' words. They said they were deeply committed to releasing me, but that I had to be careful because "the Americans don't want you to return." Back then, as soon as they had said that, I had judged their words to be meaningless and ideological. In that moment such words risked to take the taste of the most bitter truth away. I can't tell the rest yet.
This was the most dramatic moment. But the month I spent as a kidnap victim has probably changed my life forever. One month alone with myself, prisoner of my deepest belief. Each hour was a pitiless test of my work. Sometimes they kidded me. They even asked me why I would leave and asked me to stay. I pointed out that I had personal relationships. They led me to think to such priorities that too often we put aside.
"Ask for your husband's help," they told me. And I did so in the first video, the one I think you all have watched. My life has changed. Same as Ra'ad Ali Abdulaziz's, the Iraqi engineer from "Un Ponte per" who was abducted with Simona & Simona. "My life is no longer the same," he told me. I didn't understand. Now I know what he meant. Because I have experienced the hardness of the truth, I realize the difficulty of communicating it, and the weakness of trying to.
In the first days of my abduction I didn't shed a single tear. I was simply mad. I told them directly: "How can you abduct me, if I am against the war?" And they started a fierce debate. "Yes, because you want to speak to the people, we would never abduct a reporter who stays shut in the hotel. And then the fact you say you're against the war could be a cover up." I would reply, almost provoking them: "It's easy to abduct a weak woman like me, why don't you do it to the American officers?" I insisted that they couldn't ask the Italian government to withdraw its troops; that they had to address the Italian people who were and are against the war, not Italian government.
It was a month of ups and downs, moments of hope and moments of deep depression. Like when the first Sunday after my abduction, in the Baghdad house where I was prisoner and where there was a satellite television dish, they let me see the EuroNews. I saw my poster on the Rome city hall building. I was relieved. Soon after, however, a claim from the Jihad announced I would be executed if Italy didn't withdraw its troops. I was frightened. But they reassured me that it wasn't them, that people should have mistrusted those proclamations, that they were a "provocation." I often asked the one who seemed more approachable and who looked more like a soldier: "Tell me the truth, you will kill me". Nonetheless, many times, we talked. "Come see a movie on TV," they told me, while a Wahhabi woman, covered from head to foot, hung around the house taking care of me.
The abductors seemed a very religious group, constantly praying the Koran verses. But on Friday, at the time of my release, the one who seemed the most religious and who used to wake up at 5 o'clock every morning to pray, "congratulated" me and incredibly shook my hand—it is not a usual behaviour for an Islamic fundamentalist—adding "If you behave, you'll leave soon." That was followed by a rather humorous episode. One of my two guards came to me astonished because the TV showed my photographs displayed in European towns and also on Totti. Yes, Totti (the Rome football team player, T.N.). The guard said he said he was a Rome team fan and he was amazed that his favourite player had taken to field with "Free Giuliana" on his T-shirt.
I now live with no more certainties. I find myself deeply weak. I failed in my belief. I had always claimed there was need to go tell about that dirty war. And I had to decide whether to stay in the hotel or going out and chance being abducted because of my work. "We don't want anyone any more," the abductors told me. But I wanted to tell about the bloodbath in Falluja through the refugees' tales. And that morning the refugees and some of their "leaders" didn't listen to me. I had in front of me the evidence of what the Iraqi society has become with the war and they threw their truth in my face: "We don't want anyone. Why don't you stay home? What such interview can be useful for?". The worst collateral damage, the war killing communication, was falling on me. On me, who had risked it all, challenging the Italian government that didn't want reporters gong to Iraq, and the Americans who don't want our work that gives witness to what that country has really turned into with the war, despite what they call elections.
Now I wonder. Is their refusal a failure?
Posted by: Joe Longo at March 07, 2005 10:36 AM (sC/iV)
Posted by: Dorothy Hyden at March 07, 2005 03:54 PM (YekN6)
Its a person's CHOICE to go over there, and they go. They get beheaded, shot at live in crappy conditions and are subject to car bombs. If your in the WRONG place at the WRONG time and take a Strafing of fire, YOUR to blame. You don't have to be there, there are plenty other jobs that are less deadly. YOU carry your happy ass there. Go, do it... well ?! Why not? EXACTLY.
Posted by: Major_Tom at March 07, 2005 06:05 PM (psM9e)
I don't know of too many other countries that make it a standing goal that they are willing to bleed for the freedom of others. So don't tell us we don't care. The goverment is "of the people" therefore we do care if our government is freeing people...duh?
As far as the rest of your paragraph, I really don't understand what you're going for there. Your either foreign or stupid, possibly both.
Posted by: Major Idiot at March 07, 2005 07:06 PM (KgBCx)
Posted by: tradewind 111 at March 07, 2005 09:04 PM (6krEN)
Posted by: Robin Roberts at March 07, 2005 09:35 PM (xauGB)
The woman is enjoying her 15 minutes fame. Doing a victim/ drama queen show. She probably expect an increase in salary and her statue by the torre Pizza.
She fake her own kidnapping. We all know that in Iraq, kidnapped women get raped, bitten and then beheaded.
Do you guys believe this communist?, that she was freed because her kidnappers saw she worked to withdraw the italian troops from iraq?. HER NOSE IS GROWING LIKE PINOCHIO!
Do you guys remember few months ago when margaret Hassan, the British-born head of CARE International's was kidnapped?, that woman did a lot for 25 years for the iraqui people. SHe really did a lot!, and she was raped, beaten, abused and then horrendously murdered.
Now tell me that the kidnappers of this idiotic italian communist were "moved" by her journalistic work. It is sickening!
Posted by: Pelagio at March 07, 2005 10:43 PM (q9/MB)
This is really the problem: US soldiers are pussies who start firing at the buzz of a fly. Stop sending snot-nosed kids down into war zones, you'll only get them and others (like Calipari, who was a real pro) killed.
Posted by: al at March 08, 2005 09:36 AM (ChMKy)
If he was such a pro, then how come I have to use the word "was"?
My own crazy theory, based on his repeat performances of these obviously phony "negotiated releases" of anti-American terrorist supporters for millions of dollars from non-existent insurgent groups, is that he was in on it, and kept most of the ransom money for his own rogue contingent.
Maybe the people in the car knew that if they stopped at the checkpoint, discovery of the unpaid ransom in the car would be their undoing. We'll see what the investigation turns up.
Kooky and unsubstantiated? Sure! But it holds a heck of a lot more water than saying these American soldiers are "hair-trigger." That's the comment of a moron.
As far as I'm concerned, though, we'd be better off if ALL of our allies would not join us in these wars. Their effort is appreciated, but their presence only becomes a liability and a complication. This is why it was a damn good thing that Bush kept NATO out of the initial Afghan campaign. And that went off a lot more smoothly.
P.S. It's time to kick the insurgent-supporting "journalists" out of Iraq. They are in league with murderers.
Posted by: Korla Pundit at March 08, 2005 10:04 AM (l+MMl)
Sgrena is no journalist, she writes biast articles for a biast newspaper (probably financed by RC or PCI political parties - Yuk!)
Calipari, on the other hand, was a pro. You should look at his personal story. He was a policeman for a long time, in Reggio Calabria (which makes the Bronx look like grade school). He was killed by some snot-nosed kid with a gun in his hand. It is unacceptable that the US send it's frustrated youth to get some kicks at the expense of some poor bastards (Bulgarian, Iraqi, Italian alike).
Oh, one more thing: youguys asked for help. I bet that none of the other nationalities would have gone to Iraqi if they weren't forced to by Bush and renegade mafioso Berlusconi.
Posted by: al at March 08, 2005 10:13 AM (ChMKy)
FOR AL
Well, al, I feel compelled to say something about what you wrote.
How much combat time have you got? Have you ever been fired at? We might have a constructive discussion about the political savvy of American leaders, but this is now beyond the point.
Things look different when viewed from behind a Hummvee's door or from your armchair.
Yes, maybe you can find young snotty US soldiers, I've met some; but the vast majority of them were highly trained, highly motivated young men and women. Have you ever seen your best friend burn alive inside a Bradley, or have you ever tried to help him hold his own entrails gushing from a belly wound?
After a few months of this, you don't treat an approaching car the same way your local traffic cop would.
The fact is: some very politically biased minds will never forgive anything that the US do, regardless of common sense.
Posted by: giulio at March 08, 2005 11:04 AM (MIWAC)
Posted by: Al Blows at March 08, 2005 12:14 PM (2ymJe)
And another thing - if you think for one second that your 3,000 soldiers in Iraq make a difference and we "needed" your help your hopeless. It is a political cover so that when communists like your whore reporter say that we are unilateral we can say "no - look the Poles and Italians are here too". The Brits are the only ones making a significant contribution, so shove it up your ass.
Posted by: Al Blows at March 08, 2005 12:17 PM (2ymJe)
Posted by: anvarat at March 08, 2005 02:29 PM (YBUFf)
Says it ALL right there. I gave this woman the benefit of the doubt but I have come to the conclusion that she is just a piece of shit.
And why would they follow the commands from the abductors not to signal to the U.S??? They're in a car by themselves in U.S controlled areas. I would signal to the Americans IMMEDIATELY.
Posted by: Igor Kazakov at March 08, 2005 03:57 PM (xM3Dg)
The "it's their society leave them be" excuse is getting out-dated. If the U.S was as apathetic as most of Europe is then the situation in the middle east right now would be COMPLETELY unchanged. And why would it matter? The aforementioned countries would still be nice and dandy. Also, I love the irony of "leave the Iraqis in peace." Really? IS that what they were living in since the 70s? Peace? Read your history books.
I really don't care about the non-participants anymore. Let the current Coalition and hopefully the U.N get together and facilitate change where it is needed. It's time we stop pretending like we all live on different fucking planets.
Posted by: Igor Kazakov at March 08, 2005 04:14 PM (xM3Dg)
Posted by: Guido at March 08, 2005 05:53 PM (fCGGa)
I posted a similar opinion about her nonsensical claim of being a threat to the American government. Sgrena lacked any international reputation of importance until this "kidnapping" and death of an Italian agent. Now her accusations of "deliberate targeting" have conveniently placed her in the spotlight. Otherwise her return would have not generated much attention beyond a few days.
The easiest explanation for this situation appears to point at the "stupid or insane driver causes terrible accident" theory, i.e. speeding car mistaken for terrorist bomber.
However, I think someone should investigate the direction and distance of the weapon that killed the agent. If this wasn’t just a bad accident, but instead an actual murder, then investigators should be look for who had the motivation.
So then one must ask:
Who stood to gain by the death of an Italian secret service agent? Certainly, not the US government. So far, Sgrena and her Communist paper and the kidnappers have been raking in the benefits. So, as an alterative explanation, could Sgrena or one of her kidnappers been responsible?
If I may speculate further in this direction; Sgrena has vilified the USA in earlier articles and without providing documentation. She went to Iraq with the express purpose of assisting the very group that kidnapped her. Outside of the suggestion that she could have gained a cut of the ransom money, her political goals for Italy failed despite her kidnappers' demands. So Sgrena was about to return home without the prize.
How far would she being willing to go in order to create a world class story, and turn her failing efforts into a victory?
Would Sgrena have capable of suggesting to her hosts that killing the agent would allow her to discredit the Americans?
Posted by: Mirramele at March 08, 2005 08:52 PM (hmPkH)
However, such reckless, indicting speculation and hysterical accusations manufactured, retracted here, yet already passed on as the truth, will cause more damage than the Right can imagine.
This is what the Italians will read as the 'reaction' of the Americans! Their tabloid news media will eat this up - mark my words!
Posted by: Clive Tolson at March 08, 2005 10:07 PM (3iQs9)
There was initially a report of 4 people in the car, someone must have disappeared because now suddenly, that is disputed, they say there were only three people. Where the hell did the 4th one go?
Posted by: Eric at March 09, 2005 02:44 AM (hlvoT)
Accidents similar to this happen all the time. Sometimes during the commision of a crime innocents get hurt. The responsibility lies on the crooks (kidnappers), not the cops (soldiers).
Now pieces of dog shit like this AL call our young soldiers snot nosed kids and pussies.
How pussy were they when they kicked the shit out of the Italian army 60 years ago? Half the time you sissies wouldn't even fight back.
Short memory? We are the same people that liberated your people.
Posted by: greyrooster at March 09, 2005 03:40 AM (CBNGy)
As far as wars, I've seen my share. I was in Congo during the revolt in the 90's (still ongoing). Four million dead in 4 years (I think that's a record) so don't lecture me. How many wars have you actually seen (with your own eyes, not on CNN).
So if you think that the war was waged to oust Saddam and save the Iraqis, think again. There are hundreds of places in the world that are being ignored because they are not strategic enough (economically) for the US.
Don't be children. We all know why wars are fought.
Al.
Posted by: al at March 09, 2005 03:58 AM (ChMKy)
May I remind you that after you disembarked in Sicily 60 years ago, we were the ones to invade your ass, seen as your administration is now mafia-ridden more-so than ours. So why don't you stuff it.
Al.
Posted by: al at March 09, 2005 04:01 AM (ChMKy)
Al.
Posted by: al at March 09, 2005 04:07 AM (ChMKy)
Posted by: greyrooster at March 09, 2005 06:30 AM (CBNGy)
As to knowing about war. I served in Viet Nam. My uncle Albert was killed in Korea. Mr father was killed when I was 2 years old by the Japs. My son, a marine, is presently in Iraq. My wife will retire in 2 months, after 30 years in the Coast Guard.
You should have stayed in the Congo. You know, Birds of a feather.
Posted by: greyrooster at March 09, 2005 06:48 AM (CBNGy)
Don't kid yourself, you didn't free anyone during WWII. You were just another damn invader (perhaps you should read how you pricks murdered hundreds of Italian farmers who already thought that the war was over.
Maybe you like to wave your gun around so much for lack of something else.
Al.
Posted by: al at March 09, 2005 09:52 AM (ChMKy)
I would be interested in seeing proof of how Americans killed "hundreds" of Italian farmers. They probably shit themselves to death when they saw what a real army was like, but I don't believe this ever happened.
As far as us only fighting "kids with slingshots" you obviously never were in the Congo you lying POS. Cause I'll bet these "kids with slingshots" (financed by the Syrians, Iranians, and Baathist holdouts) have some weapons that would make the spears used against you in the Congo look like, well,....spears. Numbnuts.
We are the best country and army in the world, it pains you, I know. But look, get rid of communists like that "hostage" bitch, take a bath and clean the grease off, quit taking 4 hour lunches and dinners until midnight and maybe you too can go kick some ass. Until then I think I speak for everyone if you would just shut the hell up and maybe whisper in gratitude a "thank-you" to America for sacrificing her youth because Europe is too pussy to do so....and don't tell me about your 3,000 troops.
And yes, the President asked the Italians, Poles, etc what the hell's your point? I guess your point must be that you are such great friends of the US, and you know what yes - your Prime Minister is, but don't go looking for sympathy around here because your PM went against people like you to do the right thing and change a civilization bent on destruction while the rest of your ivory-tower mates in the EU looked on and derided the "cowboy" President Bush. That "cowboys" actions have resulted in great things happening in the Middle East at a pace unheard of in history. It hurts when a chimp, as you call him, has more brains then yourself, doesn't it. That "cowboy" has changed the world for the better, and pussies like you will reap the rewards and probably lie to your grandkids about how you "fought" in the Congo AND Iraq. Fought in the Congo, what a joke....
Posted by: Al Blows at March 09, 2005 09:37 PM (RmwvT)
Posted by: Treepie.sf.net at March 10, 2005 12:51 AM (4rkMo)
Why not?
Al.
Posted by: al at March 10, 2005 04:29 AM (ChMKy)
By the way Mr Congo/Zaire expert, why don't you get some real learnin' on and find out the MAIN suppliers of weapons. Gee, last I checked the US didn't produce Kalishnikovs. And gee, looks like at the top of the list is....oh my gosh, France and Russia, arms whores to the world. So take your America bashing back to uneducated people in Europe that shit ain't flying here numbnuts.
Posted by: Al Blows at March 10, 2005 05:13 PM (RmwvT)
And although the intentions may have been good, presently those weapons are just adding to the killing. I agree with you that terrorists should be wiped away and I am not America-bashing, but I think that you should be more critical about your own before you criticize others.
One more thing. What makes you think I'm not American?
Al.
Posted by: al at March 11, 2005 07:57 AM (ChMKy)
Al.
Posted by: Al at March 11, 2005 08:02 AM (ChMKy)
- That's what makes me think your not American genius, among other snippets like "we invaded your ass....w/mafioso" (paraphrasing).
So there you go. Either you are American initially pretending not to be, or your not, either way I had good reason to think you weren't. Especially when you add in anti-American gibberish that sounds oh-so-European (although that is getting harder to distinguish from mainstream democrat gibberish).
But I got to say I'll give you your dues for your last post admitting some mistakes. Most people cannot/will not do this and it sometimes reminds me of the reality police shows where the suspect denies doing something that he does right in front of the cops and looks foolish, so kudos for you, and sorry about the rough language, I'm a news junkie and just get overwhelmed by the depth of unthinking anti-Americanism. No problem if there is good reason, but it seems like many people bend anything story they can to damage America. It gets frustrating.
Posted by: Al Blows at March 12, 2005 02:33 PM (0y+ms)
Anyways, what do you think of the whole Syria deal. At first I thought that Syrians should defenetly be kicked out of Lebanon to free the country. Then a girl I know from Beirut told me that most people there want the Syrians to stay because they feel protected by them (this is also supported by last week's mass demonstration in favor of Hizbollah. It's actually quite confusing.
Al.
Posted by: Al at March 14, 2005 03:45 AM (ChMKy)
However, and this is a beat-up cliche but fits so many situations - as one of our forefathers said - "those who would sacrifice freedom for security deserve neither". If the Lebanese can't ensure their own country's security maybe Syria should just annex it.
Posted by: Al Blows at March 14, 2005 05:16 PM (VZV9e)
Posted by: Biggy at March 17, 2005 06:10 PM (CbR96)
Remember one thing if not for the Americans in WWII you probably would have never left Italy to come to the best place on Earth NYC,and you would not be writing in English you would be writing in GERMAN............Duh oh yeah if you are a Catholic you would have been burnt like a well pizza ya vol
Posted by: Al Blows2 at March 17, 2005 08:04 PM (I4wCe)
If it weren't for us you probably would never exist at all, so don't start going back to the past, because if your merits go back 50 years, ours go back at least 2000 years.
So why don't you shut your ignorant trap, you idiot.
Al
Posted by: al at March 18, 2005 06:04 AM (ChMKy)
Posted by: Great at March 19, 2005 07:07 PM (au7Fb)
We're sick of USA army attacking all over the world and killing journalists just because they want to control everything that can be said about your wars. Giulana is the last one, but there have been more cases of USA troops murdering journalists like Jose Couso (when they attacked the journalists hotel in Iraq) the same day that they attacked 2 journalists buildings, the same day they entered Bagdad...
They lost vietnam war because the whole world could see the brutailties being done there, using napalm, orange agent or cutting people ears to make necklaces.
Where are the mass destruction weapons? This was is based in lies, just for oil, I'm so sorry you can't see it... your soldiers are paying the price of your government's avarice, but also people in iraq are suffering it.
Greetings from Spain.
Posted by: Attanar at March 22, 2005 03:15 PM (T7ziU)
SAFU describes what happened. An American patrol shines a bright light at an unidentified car (to that patrol), the driver is confused by the light and slows down but the somebody on patrol panics and starts shooting. A very upset reporter who thought that her convoy had clearance to go to the airport claims that the shooting wasn't accidental.
From my reading of left wing web sites this happens quite a bit. Can't really balm the soldiers, they are always in danger of being blown up and not all check points are as obvious as they should be.
Posted by: Qzada at March 26, 2005 12:56 AM (yVXTt)
Posted by: Vicktor at April 29, 2005 11:10 AM (AVAfo)
Posted by: Marvin Ellis at May 06, 2005 03:59 PM (DjW5R)
Alastair, Ireland.
Posted by: Alastair at July 04, 2005 11:02 PM (bmfSx)
Posted by: Spandy Packard at July 08, 2005 02:11 PM (DmTUS)
March 04, 2005
Giuliana Sgrena, the female Italian hostage held in Iraq since Feb. 4th, has been freed. The Communist daily Il Manifesto has reported that the Italian secret-service had notified them of their employee's release. Update: Sgrena was wounded as her driver sped toward a US checkpoint near the Baghdad airport. Do not believe MSM reports on this as they are all being fed information through the Communist Il Manifesto. Sgrena's vehicle was warned to stop but continued speeding toward a US checkpoint on a road which has been the scene of frequent terrorist attacks. US soldiers signaled for the car to stop, flashed lights at it, and then fired warning shots at the vehicle before opening fire on the car. The troops then shot the car's engine block, not the passengers. The car spun out of control. It was the car accident which killed one occupant and wounded Sgrena. UPDATE: Apprently Sgena did suffer a shrapenal wound, but this is consistent with the soldier's version of the story that the engine block was shot which would cause metal debris. more...
Posted by: Rusty at
05:12 PM
| Comments (75)
| Add Comment
Post contains 920 words, total size 7 kb.
Praise Allah.
Posted by: FILTHY ALLAH at March 04, 2005 01:25 PM (yBHNA)
Posted by: Earl Dittman at March 04, 2005 01:26 PM (yBHNA)
Posted by: Rusty Shackleford at March 04, 2005 01:53 PM (JQjhA)
Posted by: Confederate Yankee at March 04, 2005 01:55 PM (C5gjM)
She will now come out and say she was treated like a lady(that will be a first) and how the Evil Americans are the invaders and killers of babies. Wait and see-
Posted by: Filthy Allah at March 04, 2005 01:58 PM (yBHNA)
That is what happens when you spew anti american Jabber and fake your own kidnapping.
SHE WAS SHOT!!!
Posted by: Ob Snooks at March 04, 2005 02:03 PM (yBHNA)
The Marine recognized a terrorist and shot her.
Allah is Good!
Posted by: Filthy Allah at March 04, 2005 02:04 PM (yBHNA)
Posted by: Rusty Shackleford at March 04, 2005 02:04 PM (JQjhA)
Posted by: Preston Taylor Holmes at March 04, 2005 02:05 PM (WsZ4F)
This is an honest accident. Italian drivers have a worldwide reputation for being bad and overly aggressive, and they probably came into the chekpoint "hot" having just a littel adreniline running at the time. The soldiers probably thought they had a suicide bomber on their hands, and acted accordingly.
A tragic mistake all around, but still just a mistake.
Now if her plane gets shot down, you're on your own to explain that one...
Posted by: Confederate Yankee at March 04, 2005 02:29 PM (C5gjM)
Posted by: Rusty Shackleford at March 04, 2005 02:32 PM (JQjhA)
Posted by: Confederate Yankee at March 04, 2005 02:54 PM (C5gjM)
Chris
Posted by: Chris at March 04, 2005 02:55 PM (jwx51)
Posted by: Rusty Shackleford at March 04, 2005 03:06 PM (JQjhA)
Posted by: Confederate Yankee at March 04, 2005 03:16 PM (C5gjM)
Posted by: Rusty Shackleford at March 04, 2005 03:25 PM (JQjhA)
Posted by: filthy allah at March 04, 2005 03:39 PM (yBHNA)
Posted by: Rusty Shackleford at March 04, 2005 03:42 PM (JQjhA)
He refuses to answer so far.
Posted by: Confederate Yankee at March 04, 2005 03:44 PM (C5gjM)
That's about as coherent as you'd get.
Posted by: Rusty Shackleford at March 04, 2005 03:50 PM (JQjhA)
I just updated my post on this subject, and I'm pissed at what I'm finding out the U.S. soldiers may have in this case.
We'll need to get more information to see if the criricism is warranted, but based upon what I've read, they were far too restrained when they opened fire on Sgrena's car under those circumstances.
They may have put too many civilians and military lives at risk withholding additional fire on the off chance this wasn't another suicide bomber.
They should have blown this vehicle completely away.
Posted by: Confederate Yankee at March 04, 2005 04:52 PM (C5gjM)
Posted by: larry at March 04, 2005 04:54 PM (yceNC)
What do you not understand about the phrases "may have" and "we'll need to get more information?"
Posted by: Confederate Yankee at March 04, 2005 05:15 PM (C5gjM)
Posted by: Confederate Yankee at March 04, 2005 05:16 PM (C5gjM)
Of course in the story they just say 'sources reveal' or 'an internet source reports' (the bastards at MSNBC even ripped off one of my exclusive photos once).
Look at all the MSM reports on this story. Every one involves a press release from the military, the government, or Il Manifesto. As if I am not already privy to those reports? What information does Reuters have that I don't????
Asshat.
Posted by: Rusty Shackleford at March 04, 2005 05:20 PM (JQjhA)
Posted by: Rusty Shackleford at March 04, 2005 05:21 PM (JQjhA)
Plenty of people, myself included, wouldn't write in such a manner but still would consider this reporter to be an enabler of Islamic/Baathist/Insurgent/ME violence.
Posted by: blame them at March 04, 2005 05:27 PM (N7KDJ)
Posted by: Henry at March 04, 2005 05:28 PM (yH3xh)
Posted by: anon at March 04, 2005 05:35 PM (APpwB)
Posted by: Rusty Shackleford at March 04, 2005 05:55 PM (JQjhA)
Posted by: The Dread Pundit Bluto at March 04, 2005 06:37 PM (RHG+K)
Posted by: dbase at March 04, 2005 06:37 PM (yGqlj)
You must be a leftwing troll. Piss off.
Posted by: Trapeze at March 04, 2005 06:47 PM (D3vXg)
>She will now come out and say she was treated like a lady(that will be a first) and how the Evil Americans are the invaders and killers of babies. Wait and see-
And that Berlusconi (eeevil fascist dictator Berlusconi - what, you thought only the US got the RightWing President Is A Nazi shtick?), who worked hard (possibly paid) to free her, is a collaborator with eeevil fascist nazistic ameriKKKans, while the godforsaken commies she works with and for (and that did NOTHING for her except protest against the US) are heroes. Fucking bastards. They're lucky we live in a gun-fearing country, or they'd get a piece of the real Italy's mind.
>The Jawa Report has speculated in the past the Sgrena was either the victim of her own close ties with terrorist forces, or had staged her own abduction to convince the Italian people of their folly for supporting the US led occupation.
My take, knowing the situation on the ground very well (duh, I'm from Italy): if the terrorists had kidnapped a non-leftie, the commie papers (which generate more noise than anything else) wouldn't have given them the time of the day. A commie kidnapped for a month means a month of anti-Berlusconi (who is sane, and therefore strongly pro-USA) protests. A non-commie kidnapped means a few snide news titles of the likes of 'collaborator', 'die fascist pig', and other DU worthy crap.
>A word of caution. All reports about Sgrena to date have been carefully routed through her Communist newspaper, Il Manifesto.
This might be a good moment to state that the vast majority of news you hear from Italy come, if not from one of the three communist papers we have, from the many leftie papers and/or antisemitic news agencies. US 'journalists' *cough* 'verify' (read: get) their news at Il Corriere della Sera. It's vaguely to the right of the NYT, if you're wondering.
Don't believe *anything* you get from the MSM regarding Italy.
Posted by: Francesco Poli at March 04, 2005 07:02 PM (lkb/V)
I was in Italy last September during the ordeal of "Le Due Simone," the two abducted Italian aid workers, which was splashed over the front page of every newspaper. Unfortunately my Italian wasn't good enough to get all the details from the stories I read at the time, but I never quite understood much about the two women - whether they were working for an agency that took sides in the conflict, whether they personally said anything implicating their sympathies one way or the other, etc.
I was very happy when they were released, but found it unfortunate that apparently a ransom was paid for them. But at least they never turned up on a horrible videotape like that blubbering Brit, Bigley. And it doesn't appear that the ransom payment wound up encouraging a rash of further abductions of Italians, as I feared it might.
Maybe you could fill us in a little more on the after-story? I returned from Italy only a few days after that ordeal was over, and didn't have access to any good coverage of it once I returned here -- election coverage seemed to overshadow everything at that point, and US domestic news coverage of events outside the US is pretty poor anyway.
I'm glad Italy is on our side in this affair, and I hope that this incident is investigated and reported fairly and accurately, and turns out to be what it appears to be at this point given the limited amount of information, which is a bad screwup by the driver in approaching a hot checkpoint.
I for one haven't forgotten Fabrizio Quattrocchi, and was very touched by the city of Bologna dedicating a park to the memory of "11 Settembre 2001." On a continent surrounded by weasels, Italy has been a standout, and stand-up, ally.
Posted by: Alex at March 04, 2005 08:16 PM (fgyj8)
ernie
Posted by: ernie at March 04, 2005 08:51 PM (ursvs)
If you are a soldier at a check point and believe a car bomb is heading at you your only thought will be; MUST STOP CAR! You are expecting it to blow up so you want it stopped.
What is the best way to do that? Shoot the engine! 50 cals go through car engines like butter. And the ensuing explosion would take care of any occupants in the car.
Posted by: Vince at March 05, 2005 05:41 AM (gANRs)
Thanks for the support. It seems many Americans, even those in the blogosphere, are eager to lump Italy with the rest of the leftwing anti-american eurocrats.
As for the two Simonas, they were operatives of an openly communist organization, and had been in Iraq since the first Gulf War. They had been openly supporting the Saddamite version of facts (it was the embargo, not the dictator, that starved children etc. etc.).
The kidnapping is still being investigated, but I wouldn't put much faith on results coming anywhere near soon. The most probable hypotesis is that they were sold out by their Iraqi 'friends', and then kidnapped by common thugs (vs. terrorists) who just wanted the money.
Real terrorist groups issued a fatwa on this, as they were pro-Saddam, pro-terrorism supporters, and so the thugs sold them to a real terrorist group. Terrorists asked for anti-Berlusconi (i.e. anti-USA) protests, and of course, a ransom.
The ransom was paid, the protests enacted (as if lefties needed any invitation to protest against the US), and the two commies were freed.
They were quick to thank the kidnappers, the Italian left, and oh, yes, the Italian prime minister who freed them (but that came later, and only after even the lefties chastised them).
The aftermath: they became heroes within the left, they got their 15 days of fame on national TV and papers, and then the majority who voted Berlusconi (and is thus far from anti-american) condemned them to niche oblivion.
One of them is already back in Iraq. The Italian right is ready to protest against any attempts to free her should she be kidnapped again.
Posted by: Francesco Poli at March 05, 2005 06:46 AM (9z453)
Posted by: sandpiper at March 05, 2005 08:35 AM (ITWfd)
WOW!............you people are IDIOTS!
Posted by: Red Wolf at March 05, 2005 11:31 AM (sA4iy)
They don't speak on my behalf.
Posted by: Stefania at March 05, 2005 11:34 AM (MK9vm)
Posted by: Red Wolf at March 05, 2005 11:45 AM (sA4iy)
Their orders were to halt all vehicles trying to to get past them.
they followed procedure:
Hand signals- no result
flashing lights-no result
warning shots-no result
fire on the vehicle- result
The soldiers did exactly what they were ordered to do , exactly the way they wee trained to do it.
America HAS trained its soldiers properly.
That is NOT the problem.
The problem lies in idiots thinking the rules of engagement do not apply to them.
They got a brief, but rigorous education.
The lesson here, Red Wolf. is that if these boys tell you to stop, you will stop ; dead or alive, you WILL stop. In that situation, you have a choice: are you going to be a nice cooperative wolfie and allowed to go on his way, with thanks? Or, are you going to be a dead dog in a ditch?
If it is any help to you, you can consider this an intelligence test- and it is strictly PASS/FAIL, M'kay?
Posted by: Lucius Severus Pertinax at March 05, 2005 01:40 PM (r95xu)
Ok.........picture this......YOUR diving down a street in IRAQ in the middle of a WAR ZONE after freeing a peson whom 25 mins. before was a hostage and then........BANG! you hear those "warning shots".........I will make a wager that the first thought that comes to YOUR mind is not "WOW! IT MUST BE AMERICAN TROOPS FIRING WARNING SHOTS! LETS SLOW DOWN"........is more likly to be "HOLY CR*P! AMBUSH!!!!!!! DRIVE!!!!!"
and don't call me a DOG!!!!......thats an insult
Posted by: Red Wolf at March 05, 2005 06:41 PM (RqaMW)
Posted by: Memo at March 05, 2005 07:40 PM (MR7cx)
Posted by: Capt. R at March 06, 2005 12:34 AM (e1ni2)
Posted by: Collin Baber at March 06, 2005 02:21 AM (fufbw)
SOIS UNOS CERDOS Y UNOS MENTIROSOS
VUESTRAS ACCIONES ESTAN LLENAS DE METIRA.
PERO COMO ENCIMA SOIS TONTOS Y NO TENEIS NI CULTURA NI FORMACION NO SABEIS TODAS LAS METIRAS AMERICANOS.
POBRECITOS QUE LOS MOROS OS VUELAN EL CULO CON DINAMITA.
A LA MIERDA
Posted by: EVA BRAUN at March 06, 2005 03:12 PM (YH6oj)
ernie
Posted by: ernie at March 06, 2005 03:14 PM (ursvs)
Y CUANDO SE LEVANTA EL RESTO DE GENTE PENSANTE DE ESTA NACION ?
CUANDO LE PONEN LOS POCOS AMERICANOS MENTALMENTE SANOS UNA BOMBA BAJO EL CULO PODRIDO DEL FASCIST BUSH.
COMO CREO EN LA RE-ENCARNACION:
BUSH = HITLER
AMERICANOS FIELES AL ESTADO = NAZIS
Posted by: EVA BRAUN at March 06, 2005 03:25 PM (YH6oj)
Posted by: vic at March 06, 2005 03:49 PM (uq30O)
A La Mierda que los de Al Qaeda te metan a ti y a tu mierda de Bush una bomba por el culo y en cada una de vuestras podridas ciudades.
No servis ni para NAZIS decentes
Posted by: Eva Braun at March 06, 2005 06:20 PM (YH6oj)
Posted by: Rod Stanton at March 06, 2005 08:08 PM (l5t6M)
Eva, I always take the word of US soldiers over a communist.
Posted by: Robin Roberts at March 06, 2005 09:32 PM (xauGB)
Posted by: Dean S. at March 06, 2005 11:47 PM (nlWFp)
Posted by: Robin Roberts at March 07, 2005 01:04 AM (xauGB)
Soon this dirty whore who faked her own kidnapping will be exposed for the foul dirt that she is.
Posted by: Filthy Allah at March 07, 2005 07:43 AM (yBHNA)
Posted by: Vicki at March 07, 2005 09:20 AM (LciZX)
It should also be possible to accept that sometimes our guys panic and don't follow procedure, or they just have crummy procedures. We should be taking every precaution to limit this kind of incident, and not relying on civilians to understand "rules of engagement".
If you are one of those who believes that people who react incorrectly when warning shots are fired at them should be killed, then please just remember that every time we do something like this, where foreign journalists or Iraqi kids are killed, it ends up costing us support and helps enemy recruitment. Get that through your thick head. This kind of f*-up loses American lives in the long run.
Posted by: Dr. Dr. at March 07, 2005 09:42 AM (9+bUG)
Dipshit, Allah is God, you heathen cocksucker. Study your religion, same omnipotent being.
Posted by: allison at March 07, 2005 12:22 PM (EKMxC)
EVA BRAUN writes spanish, clear? this is italian:
MORTACCI VOSTRA FOTTETEVI PORCI RAZZISTI AMERIKANI; VE VENISSE UN CANCHERO AL CULO A TUTTI QUANTI; DOVETE MORIRE UCCISI MANGIATI DAI RATTI;DANNATA SIA LA VOSTRA STIRPE IN ETERNO; POSSANO I VOSTRI FIGLI NASCERE DEFORMI;LURIDI NAZISTI ANALFABETI GUERRAFONDAI ASSASSINI SIONISTI PEDOFILI SCHIFOSI.
bush SEI UN FOTTUTO LADRO PLURIOMICIDA MERDOSO TI AUGURO UNA MORTE LUNGA E DOLOROSA.
Posted by: BUSH IS GAY at March 07, 2005 05:03 PM (nHo5c)
As for "BUSH IS GAY", I've noticed a distinct latent homophobia among the anti-Bush crowd lately. Must have been the silly Gannon thing that unleashed it. Time to grow up.
Posted by: Robin Roberts at March 07, 2005 11:26 PM (xauGB)
Here there are people more serious than that.
Posted by: pius at March 08, 2005 06:04 AM (IRvXN)
Car bombs are an immediate threat, this is true, but, the fact is that I wasn't talking about that. All I'm talking about is the feeble-minds posting here who seem to think it's no big deal when these incidents happen. Try and understand this - killing Calipari may have been unavoidable tactically for a small unit, but it was a global strategic blunder.
Plus, don't be so ready to assume that our procedures were properly followed. Right now, there are only a handful of people in the world that know exactly what happened - and none of them are posting here, even though most of you cheese-heads are willing to jump straight to blind conclusions based on your own political leanings.
Posted by: Dr. Dr. at March 08, 2005 08:43 AM (9+bUG)
P.S., I wouldn't call saying "Bush is Gay" latent homophobia. I'm not at all homophobic, but that doesn't stop me from using homosexuality as an insult when bantering with friends. Plus, if the left is being homophobic lately, the right has been that way since time immemorial.
I believe that the handle "Bush is Gay" that this person is using is just an attempt to get a reaction out Bush supporters, and you've either completely fallen into that trap, or you're just covering for the embarrassing revelation that you can't distinguish Spanish from Italian. Ciao!
Posted by: Dr. Dr. at March 08, 2005 09:14 AM (9+bUG)
Is that true?
As far as I can see here this is a kind of website where anyone can leave his messagge, soldier or not, American or not.
To all the American troups engaged in Iraq: I really hope that you will able to come home safe and very soon!
Posted by: LorenzoP at March 08, 2005 10:27 AM (30Rpo)
Posted by: BUSH IS GAY at March 08, 2005 10:36 AM (nHo5c)
Posted by: Dr. Dr. at March 08, 2005 01:33 PM (9+bUG)
Posted by: greyrooster at March 09, 2005 06:26 AM (CBNGy)
Posted by: taffy at March 10, 2005 01:16 PM (WRDpc)
Posted by: pius at March 11, 2005 05:15 AM (IRvXN)
Posted by: bushsuckstroopsrule at March 15, 2005 12:28 AM (5+GLS)
Posted by: Ryan at March 15, 2005 09:52 PM (TPd9P)
No te conozco, pero he visto tus comentarios en este blog. No te da la gana de echar la pota cuando lees los comentarios de estos cabrones, hijos de la gran puta que se llaman patriotas? Y esto porque apoyan a cualquier cosa que haga el puto ejercito EEUU. Bueno, desgraciadamente (por el momento) soy de EEUU pero actualment me encuentro en Corea del Sur pq ya no quedan curros en EEUU y afortunadamente los coreanos quieren aprender el ingles asi que les sirvo pa algo. Bueno, solo te queria decir que estoy cien por cien de acuerdo con todo lo que dices y odio lo que hace mi pais en el nombre de "libertad." Que arda Bush en el infierno, veras que hay una silla que le espera al lado de Cheney y Rumsfeld, junto con los demas neo-fascistas,
Ryan
si kieres escribirme, hazlo al ryan c downing (sin espacios) luego la sena @ y es en el yahoo de Espana. Ojala entiendas, es que no quiero un virus de 1 de estos hijos de la gran puta, ya sabes?
Posted by: Ryan at March 15, 2005 10:08 PM (TPd9P)
I'm sitting here with the pictures of the car, both sides; I count and re count but I really can see no more than 10 holes 10 at all.
The half of them seem to be shot at the engine.
Posted by: pius at March 21, 2005 12:10 PM (IRvXN)
March 02, 2005
Posted by: Rusty at
03:08 PM
| Comments (1)
| Add Comment
Post contains 154 words, total size 1 kb.
Posted by: greyrooster at March 02, 2005 07:07 PM (CBNGy)
A new video showing Minas Ibrahim al-Yussufi (also al-Yousifi, Yusefi) the secretary general of Iraq's Christian Democratic Party and a man who has been held hostage for a month, has been delivered to AFP. On the video, al-Yussefi begs for the intervention of the Pope and to the King of Sweden."I appeal to (Sweden's) King Carl XVI Gustaf, Queen Silvia, Pope John Paul II, the international union of Christian parties and the Committee of Muslim Scholars... to work for my release and enable me to complete my national mission," he says.
Al-Yussefi also makes this heart-wrenching appeal, "I have been transferred to the execution unit of the Iraqi Vengeance Brigades, which certainly means my death and execution."
On a February 18th video Minas Ibrahim al-Yussufi made a similar appeal. He is to be beheaded unless his captors are paid $4 million dollars.
Al-Yousifi fled Northern Iraq in 1984 and emmigrated to Sweden. He returned to Iraq after the US led invasion to found a Christian politcal party. His wife and family remain in Sweden.
Posted by: Rusty at
12:40 PM
| Comments (12)
| Add Comment
Post contains 184 words, total size 1 kb.
Posted by: Young Bourbon Professional at March 02, 2005 05:47 PM (sEM/d)
Posted by: Leopold Stotch at March 02, 2005 06:39 PM (pbpra)
You're a Christian. Pray for him.
Know what. Ever had those mint flavored girl scout cookies? Damn they're good. Dip them in a frozen Brandy Alexander made with vanilla ice cream instead of cream. Off the subject, but this is something to share with special people.
It just keeps getting better and better. Only in America.
Posted by: greyrooster at March 02, 2005 07:48 PM (CBNGy)
Posted by: greyrooster at March 02, 2005 07:51 PM (CBNGy)
That would show us you meant what you said. I'll be looking for you on CNN.
Posted by: flabbergoozled at March 02, 2005 09:26 PM (KmKDL)
Flabbergoozled: "That would show us you meant what you said."
This is pithy but meaningless unless I had stated that I, in the same situation, would definitely act differently.
Posted by: Young Bourbon Professional at March 03, 2005 08:06 AM (x+5JB)
PLEASE NUKE MECCA. Wait until they are all walking around in that 5 mile circle, when they're all there together, and drop the big one.
All these pussies saying "gee but most muslims are peace loving" need to pull their head out of their a$$. Insurgency=Islam.
Get rid of them now, while we have a leadership willing to do so.
Posted by: King A at March 03, 2005 01:01 PM (+4mO/)
King A: Don't sugercoat your feelings. How do you really feel?!
Posted by: Young Bourbon Professional at March 03, 2005 01:07 PM (x+5JB)
Posted by: Jim at March 03, 2005 01:22 PM (Hm7re)
Don't mind Jim. He's just a lonely, sniveling freak looking for attention. One of those Kerry loving leftouts. Feels he's neglected and don't know why. We know.
Posted by: greyrooster at March 03, 2005 06:40 PM (CBNGy)
Posted by: casinos at March 20, 2005 07:52 AM (e8X6h)
Posted by: casinos: casino vegas red at March 24, 2005 08:26 AM (VO5++)
Il Manifesto made the cryptic claim that they believed, "Giuliana will arrive from nowhere just like she disappeared".
Yesterday a hunger strike was coordinated between the Catholic and Muslim communities in Italy in support of Giuliana Sgrena's plight. The protesters, so concerned about Sgrena focused much of their attention on calling for the US to end its attack against terrorists in Ramadi.
Developing....
Posted by: Rusty at
12:00 PM
| Comments (2)
| Add Comment
Post contains 124 words, total size 1 kb.
Cindy
Posted by: firstbrokenangel at March 02, 2005 09:14 PM (PEKrh)
Posted by: Filthy Allah at March 03, 2005 07:54 AM (yBHNA)
March 01, 2005
Yesterday we reported that an American child was rescued from his kidnappers in Iraq [earlier story here]. The boy's name is Hussein al-Saadi. The ten year old boy is an American citizen and was taken hostage two weeks ago in Basra, Iraq. Yesterday, the Iraqi police discovered the boy and arrested his captors.
The above AP photo via (Daily Tribune) shows young Hussein al-Saadi pointing at his captors, now in custody. Not so tough now, eh?
Posted by: Rusty at
12:30 PM
| Comments (10)
| Add Comment
Post contains 82 words, total size 1 kb.
Posted by: Young Bourbon Professional at March 01, 2005 08:43 AM (x+5JB)
Posted by: mike at March 01, 2005 10:41 AM (a8b5N)
Posted by: Martin at March 01, 2005 10:48 AM (WnUPO)
Posted by: -keith in mtn. view at March 01, 2005 11:11 AM (sE9R7)
Posted by: elliott at March 01, 2005 01:41 PM (RLooS)
Now, allowing the kid to cut their heads off as punishment, that has possibility. Of course, he looks to young to use anything sharper than a butter knife, but is that really a problem?
Posted by: kbiel at March 01, 2005 03:17 PM (KSCkS)
Posted by: Bubbe at March 01, 2005 07:35 PM (4BlQ+)
Posted by: greyrooster at March 01, 2005 09:23 PM (CBNGy)
Posted by: greyrooster at March 01, 2005 09:29 PM (CBNGy)
Posted by: tee bee at March 03, 2005 03:24 PM (q1JHF)
French journalist Florence Aubenas has appeared in a new video pleading for her life. Unlike other hostage videos, no clear demands were reportedly made for her release.She is described in the video as looking in poor health and her clothing filthy. The one-minute video is in English. Al Jazeera reports Ms. Aubenas as saying:
My name is Florence Aubenas. I'm French. I'm a journalist with Liberation....Reuters adds that Aubenas makes a direct plea to French Member of Parliament, Didier Julia, a member of Jacques Chirac's UMP party:Please help me. My health is very bad. I'm very bad psychologically also...
I ask particularly for the help of the French deputy Didier Julia. Help me Mr Julia, help me. It's urgent.Mr. Julia went on a special mission to Iraq last fall in an effort to free two other French journalists, Christian Chesnot and Georges Malbrunot. The two were eventually freed, reportedly for ransom.
Because Florence Aubenas comes from a country that opposed the war in Iraq, it is presumed that her captors are simply seeking ransom. Common criminals and terrorist groups have resorted to hostage taking as a way of funding their activities in Iraq.
(Image: AFP)
Posted by: Rusty at
08:14 AM
| Comments (6)
| Add Comment
Post contains 199 words, total size 1 kb.
Posted by: Young Bourbon Professional at March 01, 2005 08:48 AM (x+5JB)
mission far from accomplished
Posted by: todd at March 01, 2005 09:02 AM (zyuzi)
Posted by: Rusty Shackleford at March 01, 2005 09:10 AM (JQjhA)
Posted by: Young Bourbon Professional at March 01, 2005 09:33 AM (x+5JB)
Posted by: Razorgirl at March 01, 2005 02:55 PM (7z98K)
Todd: The only thing worse than a moonbat is a blind moonbat.
Posted by: greyrooster at March 01, 2005 09:36 PM (CBNGy)
February 28, 2005
The terrorists have resorted to holding children hostage. This is the only information I could gather about Hussein al Saadi. How many more American hostages are there in Iraq? From the AP:
US citizen Hussein al-Saadi, 10, who was kidnapped for a ransom of 150,000 US dollars two weeks ago, is kissed by his father Saadi Abdul-Aziz as they are reunited in the southern town of Basra in Iraq Monday, Feb. 28, 2005, after he was rescued by the Iraqi police who raided the kidnapper's hideout.
Posted by: Rusty at
02:03 PM
| Comments (4)
| Add Comment
Post contains 94 words, total size 1 kb.
Posted by: Nicole at February 28, 2005 03:17 PM (+7VNs)
Posted by: Leopold Stotch at February 28, 2005 03:52 PM (IeOl3)
Posted by: Rusty Shackleford at February 28, 2005 03:56 PM (JQjhA)
Posted by: greyrooster at March 01, 2005 04:57 AM (CBNGy)
Posted by: Rusty at
01:33 PM
| No Comments
| Add Comment
Post contains 93 words, total size 1 kb.
Various news sources, including al Jazeera, report that the woman was dressed in black, her body wrapped in a carpet. A note attached to the corpse simply read: "Spy".
It is quite common for Islamic terrorists to accuse their victims of being a spy or collaborator. Hostages are often forced to make confessions before their captors murder them--whether they are beheaded or shot. Usually, working in any capacity with the Iraqi government is enough to convince terrorist forces that a person is a spy. [hat tip: Paul at Wizbang who e-mailed this to me] more...
Posted by: Rusty at
11:51 AM
| Comments (4)
| Add Comment
Post contains 249 words, total size 2 kb.
Posted by: Laura at February 28, 2005 12:03 PM (ptOpl)
Posted by: mike at February 28, 2005 01:01 PM (nyxv/)
Posted by: Dirty Allah at February 28, 2005 01:11 PM (yBHNA)
Posted by: greyrooster at March 01, 2005 05:21 AM (CBNGy)
February 26, 2005
Let's not forget that there are at least four other Americans hostages in Iraq: Roy Hallums, Dean Sadek, Tim Bell, and Bill Bradley. We urge our troops in Iraq to continue the search for their comrades. The fight will not be over until all American civilians held hostage come home. Roy Hallums and Dean Sadek are known to be alive as both were shown in videos pleading for their lives. Tim Bell and Bill Bradley's fate are unknown.
For Keith and Carolyn Maupin, there can be no closure as long as their son remains missing....Throughout Greater Cincinnati, and particularly near his home in Clermont County, yellow ribbons adorn trees, cars and mailboxes as reminders of Matt Maupin. In August, the Maupin family said they had received 10,000 letters of support from around the country, sometimes 500 a day. A store in Batavia reported selling out of yellow ribbon. There have been rallies, vigils and calls from President Bush.
The memories of Maupin are not of a soldier, but of a young man working to build a life. He graduated from Glen Este High School and enrolled at University of Cincinnati's Clermont College. He joined the reserves to help pay for school. And then his unit was called up and life changed for him, as it has for so many other young men and women in the past few years...
Their concern remains our concern. Their son is our neighbor. He represents the sons and daughters of all our neighbors who are serving their country.
This community has shown its heart to the Maupin family and will continue to do so. We will help them maintain their vigil. This community's watch will remain until Matt Maupin finally comes home.
Posted by: Rusty at
10:46 AM
| Comments (3)
| Add Comment
Post contains 353 words, total size 2 kb.
Cindy
Posted by: firstbrokenangel at February 26, 2005 06:13 PM (PEKrh)
Posted by: Eliza Ricks at February 27, 2005 02:38 AM (EBCQW)
Cindy
Posted by: firstbrokenangel at February 28, 2005 10:45 PM (PEKrh)
February 24, 2005
...Guiliana Sgrena should be "slaughtered" in order to teach the Europeans in general and the Italians in particular a lesson as a result of their support to the "crusaders"..."My brothers in Al-Qaeda, kill this ugly old woman and do not show any mercy towards her. Do not forget that the Italians, as a people and as a government, hate Islam and the Muslims."...
"Chop off the head of Guiliana Sgrena"
Posted by: Rusty at
12:20 PM
| Comments (5)
| Add Comment
Post contains 96 words, total size 1 kb.
Posted by: firstbrokenangel at February 24, 2005 12:27 PM (PEKrh)
I admit, I do not like this woman who has taken herself hostage. I am sure her left wing commie friend who is calling for her head to be "chopped" off does not mean her any harm.
Posted by: filth allah at February 24, 2005 01:06 PM (yBHNA)
Posted by: clayton at March 03, 2005 12:46 PM (0Q94X)
Posted by: The Italian at March 06, 2005 03:15 PM (iNCuo)
Iraq NEEDS outside journalists to tell the truth about US abuse of Iraqi people such as the US led genocide at Fallujah. Who will show outside world what the US is doing in Iraq if not dissident journalists? Why did the jihad groups kidnap a DISSIDENT, and not all the imbedded propagandists the US and its criminal pals have running all over Iraq?
Posted by: qyinn at March 07, 2005 08:38 PM (+7VNs)
But propaganda is a two-way street. Media images can also serve to discredit our enemies, the Islamist extremists who wish for the return of the Caliphate and the imposition of sharia law. Hence, the following message from the terrorist through two Indonesian reporters recently released comes as no surprise. Reuters:
Two Indonesian television reporters who had been held captive by Iraqi guerrillas said on Tuesday their kidnappers asked them after their release to warn foreign journalists not to come to the conflict-ridden country.Yeah, and I'm sure all those beheading snuff videos did wonders for their credibility."They told us we should tell journalists they should not enter Iraq and that it is not a safe place for them and they also said they were dissatisfied by reports that discredited them," Meutya Hafid, 26, told reporters after her arrival in Amman from the Iraqi border with cameraman Budiyanto, 38, a day after their release.
Posted by: Rusty at
11:43 AM
| Comments (12)
| Add Comment
Post contains 212 words, total size 2 kb.
Posted by: elliott at February 24, 2005 08:36 AM (RLooS)
Posted by: Rod Stanton at February 24, 2005 08:59 AM (fLlQ8)
I'm glad that's over.
Posted by: Laura at February 24, 2005 09:04 AM (ptOpl)
Posted by: Young Bourbon Professional at February 24, 2005 09:51 AM (x+5JB)
Posted by: Rusty Shackleford at February 24, 2005 10:58 AM (JQjhA)
Posted by: Young Bourbon Professional at February 24, 2005 11:35 AM (x+5JB)
Posted by: greyrooster at February 24, 2005 02:04 PM (CBNGy)
Personal note to Chicken Little brain, I saw some of your other posts, and since my lack of proof reading has disturbed so much, I promise I will proof read my posts before I send them in. I’m sure you have heard that people say you are what you eat, and since you are an old "Cock", do you really eat them or just suck the juice out of them. Not that I really care what you do, I was just curious. When you do your reply, be sure to watch out for that “Fowl†mouth of yours.
Posted by: Butch at February 24, 2005 03:45 PM (Gqhi9)
Posted by: greyrooster at February 24, 2005 08:14 PM (b335s)
bed sheets and pillowcases like your Krazy Krappy Klan. I also see you have not been able to clean up you trashy mouth either. So why don’t you just pull your pillow case over your ugly face, and if the rest of the world is lucky, the human gene pool will be improved by you suffocating yourself.
Posted by: Butch at February 25, 2005 10:59 AM (Gqhi9)
Posted by: greyrooster at February 26, 2005 12:34 AM (CBNGy)
Posted by: Young Bourbon Professional at February 26, 2005 02:19 PM (Tzm5D)
The beheaded body of a woman has been discovered in the suburbs of the town of Erbil, Northern Iraq, the Iraqi daily Sabah reported. Police say the body might of the journalist who was kidnapped two days ago in the town of Mosul. Raeda Wazzan, a journalist working for a government-funded television station, was kidnapped along with her son, aged 10.
Posted by: Rusty at
09:03 AM
| Comments (3)
| Add Comment
Post contains 133 words, total size 1 kb.
Posted by: firstbrokenangel at February 24, 2005 12:41 PM (PEKrh)
if its true god help her son
Posted by: sparky at February 24, 2005 01:29 PM (F1nba)
should show the world what truly depraved people we
are dealing with. They deserve the cruelest death
imaginable. What a sad story...........
M.W.
Posted by: MIGHTY WHITEY at February 24, 2005 04:17 PM (0vLW8)
February 21, 2005
MOSUL, Iraq – An Iraqi Media Network worker was kidnapped by terrorists in Mosul Feb. 20.Chad at In the Bullpen speculates this is the work of the Islamic Army in Iraq. Hat tip: reader SparkyIraqi Media Network reporter Raaeda Al-Wazan was abducted while on her way to work. Terrorists contacted the station and threatened to continue to target employees.
The Mosul IMN station has been targeted by terorrists several times in the past week because they have been broadcasting programs that highlighted the negative effects of terrorist activity. Those programs have had rapidly growing support from Iraqi citizens and therefore have caused the station to be targeted.
Terrorists continue to disregard their fellow citizens, as Iraqi Security Forces and Multi-National Forces continue to perform operations to ensure the safety of Iraqi citizens.
Posted by: Rusty at
12:21 PM
| Comments (1)
| Add Comment
Post contains 142 words, total size 1 kb.
this may not be appropriate for this comments but
i heard this the other day, dont know if youve heard it
i thought it was quite funny but you have to wait about
30 secs before it starts
http://www.terrorists-suck.org/fight/winds of jihad.html
Posted by: sparky at February 21, 2005 01:12 PM (F1nba)
Two Indonesian journalists have been released by their captors. A video and still photographs were delivered to the Associated Press today showing the hostages receiving gift baskets, books, and shaking hands with the terrorists who had threatened to murder them only days before.The two, Meutya Hafid and her cameraman known only as Budianto, were captured on January 31st, but Indonesia did not report their plight until last week [background here]. A hostage video then emerged two days ago and aired by the openly pro-terrorist al Jazeera televison [background here].
The AP reports that one of the masked terrorists in the video says:
"For reasons of suspicion, these two journalists were arrested. Based on the goodwill they showed, and respecting the feelings of brotherhood and Islam between the two countries, and respecting the Indonesian anti-occupation role, we decided to release the two journalists without any conditions or ransom."
Had the two been found guilty of 'collaborating with the Zionist-Crusader forces' they would have been killed. Instead they recieved the consolation prize of not being beheaded and an array of valuable gifts. Included in the gift basket were a copy of the Quran, prayer beads, a skull cap, a pen, and a lovely scarf.Apparently, their sympathy with the terrorists saved their lives. Those worried about Giuliana Sgrena might be somewhat relieved to hear that.
Posted by: Rusty at
09:40 AM
| Comments (1)
| Add Comment
Post contains 225 words, total size 2 kb.
February 18, 2005
Posted by: Rusty at
08:37 AM
| Comments (1)
| Add Comment
Post contains 219 words, total size 1 kb.
Posted by: Steven J. Kelso Sr. at February 18, 2005 05:45 PM (U4SDZ)
Two Indonesian journalists have been taken hostage in Iraq, one of them a woman. Meutya Hafid (pictured right), a female television reporter for Metro TV, and her cameraman Budianto have been missing since January 31st.The Associated Press reports that according to an Indonesian Foreign Ministry Spokeperson, the two were heard from shortly after they crossed the border from Jordan into Iraq. When contact was attempted, someone other than the two answered the telephone. The person claimed that the pair had been stopped near Ramadi by people wearing 'uniforms'. However, there have been no reports from either the Coalition Authority or the Iraqi government that the two had been detained.
Al Arabiya television has reported that the two have been taken hostage.
ht: Jeff Quinton
Posted by: Rusty at
08:30 AM
| No Comments
| Add Comment
Post contains 131 words, total size 1 kb.
February 17, 2005
Meanwhile, a former Turkish hostage, Kahraman Sadikoglu, released last week admitted to paying a ransom of $500,000. Some hostage takers, it would seem, are nothing more than common criminals. more...
Posted by: Rusty at
01:37 PM
| Comments (2)
| Add Comment
Post contains 215 words, total size 2 kb.
Posted by: J at February 17, 2005 02:28 PM (PaPyu)
Posted by: Leopold Stotch at February 17, 2005 06:05 PM (nYGKi)
February 16, 2005
A new video has surfaced of Giuliana Sgrena. In the video she claims the only way her life will be saved is if the occupation of Iraq ends. Sgrena pleas are heard in both Italian and French. The video also superimposes the Arabic words "Mujahadin Without Borders" on the video.
The Associated Press translates her pleas:
You must end the occupation, it's the only way we can get out of this situation...What is interesting about the plea is that Giuliana Sgrena was already trying to end the occupation before she was kidnapped. Further, the Mujahadin Without Borders group is previously unknown and is a different organization than the Islamic Jihad Organization that initially claimed her abduction. Moreover, her claim that the jihadis do not want foreigners in the country is simply empirically false. What the jihadis do not want is non-dhimmi infidels in the country. Foreigners who wish to fight the 'Zionist-Crusader Forces' are always welcome.I ask the Italian government, the Italian people struggling against the occupation, I ask my husband, 'Please, help me You must do all you can to end the occupation. I'm counting on you, you can help me'...
Show all the pictures I have taken of the Iraqis, of the children hit by the cluster bombs, of the women. I beg you. Help me, help me to demand the withdrawal of the troops, help me spare my life.
These people don't want foreigners here, nobody should come to Iraq at this time. Not even journalists. Nobody.
Thousands of people are in prison, children, the elderly, women are raped, people die because they have nothing to eat, no electricity, no water.
While Sgrena seems to be visibly shaken in the video, the fact that she believes exactly what the terrorists believe, namely that the US is an evil aggressor, makes it somewhat difficult to swallow that she would actually be killed. Unlike other hostages, Sgrena was in Iraq for the sole purpose of producing anti-American propaganda.
Still, the video does seem to be authentic. Our initial reaction that this possibly could be a hoax seems less plausible now. Even so, it seems unlikely that she will be killed. In any event, anti-American activist with an agenda or not, we pray for her safe return.
However, we would also remind readers that several Americans are still being held hostage in Iraq. They are: Roy Hallums, Dean Sadek, Tim Bell, and Bill Bradley.
Update: Confederate Yankee chimes in with this:
A vigorous anti-war protestor, Sgrena's video was shown just hours before Italy's Senate started voting on extending the nation's 3,000-member military mission in Iraq until June.He also points out this MSNBC story and notes that Sgrena seems to be directing the video:
At one point, her eyes watering as she struggled to recite her message, she waved the camera to stop.If the intent of the video was to influence today's vote in Italy, it failed. BBC:
The Italian Senate voted by 141 to 112 to extend the country's 3,000-strong military presence in Iraq until June.
(Photo: Reuters. Sources: Agencies)
Bloggers react: Digger on the fact that 3 organizations have now taken credit--Most of these organizations don't seem to want to take credit for taking Mrs. Sgrena hostage and that may be because she was an outspoken anti-war advocate against the Iraq war.
Likwidshu at Say Anything--The people who kidnapped her don’t care that she’s against this war. They care about the propaganda aspect of her saying what they want her to say. She’s what is called a “useful idiotâ€.
Chad at ITB thinks the video strengthens the case of this being a hoax.
Others: Command Post
Posted by: Rusty at
03:43 PM
| Comments (52)
| Add Comment
Post contains 609 words, total size 5 kb.
Posted by: BigFire at February 16, 2005 09:59 AM (i5qPG)
Posted by: Rusty at February 16, 2005 10:18 AM (JQjhA)
Posted by: Obsnooks at February 16, 2005 10:37 AM (yBHNA)
Fake- She is a fraud.
Wonder how long it took her to set up the video camera. She did a good job with the graphics.
Posted by: Filthy Allah at February 16, 2005 10:39 AM (yBHNA)
Remember when we went into Fallajah and they found hundreds of discs with executions and beheadings on them? People we didn't even know were there or kidnapped/killed? If they kill her and they are using her right now basically because she is a woman, will be on another disc somewhere.
Can't trust those fanatics.
Cindy
Posted by: firstbrokenangel at February 16, 2005 10:52 AM (PEKrh)
I hope she gets twat blisters from a dirty toilet seat.
Posted by: obsnooks at February 16, 2005 10:58 AM (yBHNA)
Anyone ever read the trash she prints on the USA?
Posted by: Allah's Cousin Pootay at February 16, 2005 10:59 AM (yBHNA)
Posted by: Rightwingsparkle at February 16, 2005 11:02 AM (18nhC)
Plus, none of you can come up with a plausible reason why Ms. Sgrena would stage this anyway. Are you too thick to get that it only gives political ammo to people that she disagrees with?
The world is never just black vs. white; in this case, the terrorists hate us, but they hate people like Ms. Sgrena, too. She hates us and (I'm sure) the terrorists, and you guys hate her and the terrorists.
As for me, I hate the terrorists, I severely dislike most of you - but I want the fewest number of people on any side involved to die. Too hard for your black and white minds to deal with? Well, then, you can hate me all you want, but just remember, all of your mothers love me.
Posted by: Dr. Dr. at February 16, 2005 11:48 AM (9+bUG)
February 07, 2005
Italian Hostage Hoax: Terrorists to Release Giuliana Sgrena
As predicted, Italian hostage Giuliana Sgrena is to be released:
Comments
I think that you can pretty much give yourself a highfive for that call Rusty.
Nice job!
Posted by: elliott at February 7, 2005 02:04 PM
Pats self on back...
Posted by: Rusty at February 7, 2005 02:16 PM
That stunk from the beginning. Good call!
Posted by: Beth at February 7, 2005 07:40 PM
Use the same hand that you used to pat your own backs to now wipe all that egg off of your faces.
Posted by: Dr. Dr. at February 16, 2005 11:51 AM (9+bUG)
Posted by: OneDrummer at February 16, 2005 12:02 PM (85oJs)
Sgrena was a reporter for a left-wing paper that supports the terrorists as 'freedom fighters'. I never said I "knew' this was all a hoax, only suspected it. I also 'suspect' that even if not a hoax Sgrena will be released.
Posted by: Rusty at February 16, 2005 12:14 PM (JQjhA)
I still would like for someone to dream up a plausible scenario that would explain why should would come up with a hoax like this, even though, like I had said previously, this only helps out her opponents in the West. Anyone?
Posted by: Dr. Dr. at February 16, 2005 12:22 PM (9+bUG)
My first thought was that this could have been the same person or persons who made that stupid hostage video starring the G.I. Joe doll.
And her plea? We must show the pictures of the dead children and the women being raped? Nope. I'm not buying this "hostage" video. You were right with your initial skepticism. To me, her and her cohorts are trying a different tactic, since her initial pleas to get out have been ignored.
Posted by: mark at February 16, 2005 12:28 PM (ZitLd)
Posted by: Rusty at February 16, 2005 12:29 PM (JQjhA)
I'm not saying it is defiately fake, but deserves some skepticism.
Posted by: Confederate Yankee at February 16, 2005 02:03 PM (C5gjM)
All right, mark, since you're so sure, why don't you take a shot at explaining what this gains her. Come on, I'm really interested.
Or anyone else for that matter! Anyone? Don't just say that you think it's a hoax because a few things are fishy, and then not have any plausible explanation for why. Try to understand both the effect and the cause.
If you don't focus on the "why" of things, you're likely to fall victim to being a full-time conspiracy theorist - and then you're a slave to either Rush Limbaugh or Oliver Stone.
Posted by: Dr. Dr. at February 16, 2005 02:11 PM (9+bUG)
Posted by: likwidshoe at February 16, 2005 02:29 PM (XJO7P)
It gets more people looking at her video.
Posted by: Mark Flacy at February 16, 2005 02:44 PM (x4Uf3)
Posted by: Andre at February 16, 2005 03:08 PM (2kPXV)
I'm sure the discovery that the action-figure kidnapping was a hoax emboldened a lot of people here into thinking they're smarter than they actually are, but the sad fact remains that they're more conspiracy theorists than actual detectives. As such, asking them for proof is pretty much an exercise in futility.
Do I believe it's a hoax? No. Not yet anyways. I haven't seen anything suggesting it is, and the fact these criminals kidnap and murder anyone shows that it doesn't matter who's kidnapped.
Although I'm sure that if this turns out to be a hoax, you'll probably see half-a-dozen people suddenly exclaim how "right" they were.
Posted by: Venom at February 16, 2005 03:23 PM (dbxVM)
She shares a common goal with her kidnappers. The question remaining is whether they feel that way as well.
Posted by: Confederate Yankee at February 16, 2005 03:54 PM (C5gjM)
What did Dan Rather think his presenting forged documents would gain him?
ass.
Posted by: filthy allah at February 16, 2005 03:54 PM (yBHNA)
Press is eating this up-
Posted by: obsnooks at February 16, 2005 03:56 PM (yBHNA)
Again, I never said I was positive about this. As for my readers, I don't know if they're conspiracy theorists or not. I don't think there is a conspiracy theory I've ever truly believed. This would be a first.
Posted by: Rusty at February 16, 2005 03:58 PM (JQjhA)
Posted by: Venom at February 16, 2005 03:59 PM (dbxVM)
She was, at that very moment, interviewing refugees from Fallujah camped at a mosque. The story was to be on how horrible it was for the Americans to invade that city.
She also happened to be on the phone, at the moment she was kidnapped, with another journalist.
Her own newspaper says she has a working relationship with radical Jihadi clerics in Iraq.
There's more like that.
Like I said, I have no evidence, I'm just speculating. Part of me thinks it's a hoax. The greater part of me thinks that while the abduction was real, the fact she has not been let out by now is propaganda. Her own newspaper has publicly stated that they have SEEN HER WHILE IN CAPTIVITY. That would be a first and it is the fishiest thing I've ever heard.
Posted by: Rusty at February 16, 2005 04:05 PM (JQjhA)
Andre, your head is jammed so far in your butt that you can lick your own tonsils from behind. If you want to broadcast your mind's thoughts to the World, it's a good idea actually think while you're doing it. This will help your cause instead of making it look like it's supported by people with less understanding of things than a sponge.
Posted by: Dr. Dr. at February 16, 2005 04:16 PM (9+bUG)
In response to this comment by Beth:
"3) The reason some of us suspect it could be a hoax, Venom & Dr. Dr., is because she is virulently anti-war and before this, she was campaigning, if you will, for Italian forces to leave Iraq. Now she's the one who will die if the Italians don't leave. Get it???"
*cough* Margaret Hassan *cough*
Like I said, the Islamofascists behind these kinds of kidnappings don't care who they're holding or what their political beliefs are.
Posted by: Venom at February 16, 2005 04:17 PM (dbxVM)
I would be both saddened and surprised to learn of Sgrena's demise.
Posted by: Rusty at February 16, 2005 04:21 PM (JQjhA)
1. Actually, a good number of the people here seem like they'd be happy to see her get what she's got coming. I'm not going to say that you're like them anymore than it would be smart to lump Ms. Sgreda together with her kidnappers, but don't act like the people here are all good people.
2. Hey, I'm completely aware of it. You don't see me out there. But I'm also capable of seeing that there are at least three sides in Iraq, probably closer to 20 million sides. Nothing is as simple as those who would like to see everything in binary want it to be.
3. If that's all it takes for you to think the worst of her, so be it. I return to the argument that you didn't read well either, that she has to be aware that this will only make her side weaker in Italy.
Terrorists the World over sometimes believe that irrational acts will goad the enemy into committing irrational acts in return, which is the best recruiting tool they can have. Look at the most extreme acts of terrorism in Israel, the Basque homeland, Ireland, Sri Lanka, heck, look at Al Qaeda, for God sakes. You don't really think that they thought that we wouldn't come after them, do you?
Posted by: Dr. Dr. at February 16, 2005 04:30 PM (9+bUG)
This may or may not weaken her side's position in Italy, but her motivations would be based purely on her subjective read of public opinion in Italy. If she believed it would help the anti-war position than that is all that is needed. Many people make bad political moves with the best of intentions.
Posted by: Rusty at February 16, 2005 04:53 PM (JQjhA)
Posted by: Karl at February 16, 2005 04:55 PM (PM/BC)
Posted by: pow at February 16, 2005 08:45 PM (pd5Gf)
starving and dead children etc ......
what was islamoslobs' problems with margaret hassan ? she was one of them and a humanitarian aid worker for iraqis.
these POS just like to kill for fun.
Posted by: salome at February 16, 2005 10:31 PM (6krEN)
Posted by: greyrooster at February 17, 2005 02:06 AM (CBNGy)
She is a vile sack of puss in a skin suit.
Why would she fake her own kidnapping?
C'mon. Same reason Dan Rather brought out the forged docs and claimed they were authentic. Grow up Venum.
Posted by: Obsnooks at February 17, 2005 07:53 AM (yBHNA)
FAKER FAKER FAKER FAKER FAKER FAKER
Posted by: Filthy Allah at February 17, 2005 07:55 AM (yBHNA)
But thats just what I think...
Posted by: Night Weasel at February 17, 2005 08:09 AM (tkj+t)
Posted by: Andre at February 17, 2005 08:12 AM (2kPXV)
The filthy Commie Skag, is a fake.
Posted by: filthy allah at February 17, 2005 08:20 AM (yBHNA)
Posted by: Venom at February 17, 2005 09:35 AM (dbxVM)
Dr. Dr., if you're asking for proof of why people think this is a hoax, you've probably come to the wrong place. Most people here rarely back up they're "thoughts" with little more than a "because"-style answer.
V, it's easy to confuse trolls on hot posts with people who actually have an interest in a topic. trolls know no ideology [more like an idiot-ology] and often mirror what they perceive to be the high ground in any conversation. they curse and wish ill and don't bother with facts or consequences. they are trolls, little garbage-eating, bile-spewing, scenery-chewing beasts with some sort of nuclear exchange thing fueling their spleen. tarring everyone in a room with the same brush is fun sometimes, but ultimately pointless (unless you are a troll, then this works into that nuclear exchange thing).
I'm sure the discovery that the action-figure kidnapping was a hoax emboldened a lot of people here into thinking they're smarter than they actually are, but the sad fact remains that they're more conspiracy theorists than actual detectives. As such, asking them for proof is pretty much an exercise in futility.
you're responding to the trolls, not Rusty or the more thoughtful posters. but hey - if it's fun, carry on.
Do I believe it's a hoax? No. Not yet anyways. I haven't seen anything suggesting it is, and the fact these criminals kidnap and murder anyone shows that it doesn't matter who's kidnapped.
you'd be right about the Islamofascists, if they are behind this. what you've said is probably the only thing I would claim to know about them. Rusty is the expert. am I convinced of a hoax? it looks odd, that's for sure, but if anything, I think this woman has been hoodwinked into thinking it will be a useful hoax, and I fear that she will be woefully disabused when the captors find they have no more use for her, other than to prove they will put any infidel to the sword to maintain the fear and demonstrate their power and resolve. nonetheless, if she has cooperated, she is part of the hoax.
Although I'm sure that if this turns out to be a hoax, you'll probably see half-a-dozen people suddenly exclaim how "right" they were.
well, so? they will have been, but that doesn't make them smart or respectable or reliable. me? I'll be glad if she escapes with her life, sad if not, but bad behavior like hoaxes is like trolls - sometimes amusing, sometimes just a waste of energy to acknowledge, and sometimes tragically sad. but it should be unmasked when it attempts to weild political clout, because it ushers in anarchy.
Posted by: tee bee at February 17, 2005 09:48 AM (q1JHF)
Posted by: Larry Bon Jones at February 17, 2005 10:05 AM (yBHNA)
Good points made on your third paragraph. Thanks for using your head in replying.
Also, the people on here who will claim they were "right" about this being a hoax if it is one won't be "right," they'll have been lucky. Big difference.
Posted by: Venom at February 17, 2005 10:05 AM (dbxVM)
have fun with the trolls! invert the nuclear reactor that is mindless energy expense! hey... the greenies should get on this one. think of the global warming coming from all that energy - think of the potential for meltdown!
Posted by: tee bee at February 17, 2005 10:41 AM (q1JHF)
Posted by: obsnooks at February 18, 2005 02:00 PM (yBHNA)
These terrorists kill even their own Muslim fellows, why wouldn't they kill her? I think you guys are going a little overboard with the conspiracy theories! It's war and it sucks.
EVERYONE kills.
Posted by: iaia at February 21, 2005 07:41 AM (Xfl4H)
Posted by: greyrooster at February 24, 2005 05:34 AM (CBNGy)
Oh, and one more thing, leftists are a bunch of retards, or as Lenin called them, "useful idiots".
Posted by: Improbulus Maximus at March 06, 2005 06:57 PM (mMn6/)
Posted by: Giuliana Srgena at March 07, 2005 02:07 PM (+JyVE)
Pot Luck behind the keyboards, whom never leave their own backyards.
Out Of The Inner Circle
Posted by: Pathogen at March 12, 2005 10:40 AM (cJXfY)
February 15, 2005
French musicians sing for the release of left-wing journalist Florence Aubenas: Around 30 singers put on a free concert in Paris on Monday in a show of support for a French female journalist and her Iraqi translator, missing in Iraq and believed to have been kidnapped.
Italians march to free Sgrena.
Arab media up in arms over Sgrena's kidnapping.
Arab media, European media on Roy Hallums, held hostage since Nov. 1, 2004: Silence.
FREE ROY NOW!!!!!!!!
Posted by: Rusty at
12:29 PM
| Comments (5)
| Add Comment
Post contains 127 words, total size 1 kb.
Posted by: Wine-aholic at February 15, 2005 01:01 PM (Wsn+K)
Posted by: Snooks at February 15, 2005 02:18 PM (yBHNA)
Why has it to be an issue if they do a march for Giuliana Sgrena and not for Roy?
After all she is against the war in Iraq, and the Europeans who were against the war, they did not oppose the war because they are cowards but because they did not want to help carry an illegal invasion and robbery of a sovreign country. What the terrorists are doing is horrible, but it is America who fired the first shot on Iraq, no actually the second! Those horrible terrorist activities started because the US are there, so it's the US fault, it's the US who created these monster. The Us is to blame as much as the terrorists.
I am really amused when Americans point the finger at the terrorists and say that what they are doing is worse than what the US military did in Abu Ghraib prison... As, if the terrorists are committing such horrible acts we should then condone the Americans who are committing cleaner crimes, like killing civilians with artillery or by dropping bombs. Crimes are crimes, and murders are murders, which ever way they are carried, horrific or civilized, at the end the result is the same... it's killing, period!
I pray that they release Giuliana from the bottom of my heart, may god protect her from any harm! amaen!
Posted by: totolemoko at February 17, 2005 03:40 PM (vVsL3)
Posted by: Susan Hallums at March 02, 2005 12:14 AM (/tgDb)
Posted by: Rick at March 28, 2005 05:16 PM (QjUTg)
Kidnappers have released a wealthy Turkish businessman after holding him hostage in Iraq for two months, the Turkish Foreign Ministry said Tuesday.It must be a terribly difficult situation to be in having a loved one held hostage. On the one hand, there is the need of the family to see their family members returned home safe and sound. On the other hand, the act of paying ransom may have the effect of inspiring other groups to try the same tactic.Kahraman Sadikoglu, president of the Istanbul-based Tuzla Shipyard, was released late Monday, and flown to Baghdad after spending the evening at a British base in southern Iraq, a Foreign Ministry official said. He was scheduled to return to Turkey later Tuesday through Jordan.
The ministry official did not give further details, but newspaper reports said Sadikoglu was released after his family paid hundreds of thousands of dollars in ransom.
Posted by: Rusty at
12:09 PM
| Comments (2)
| Add Comment
Post contains 155 words, total size 1 kb.
February 14, 2005
"Truly moving is the involvement of the Iraqi people in Giuliana Sgrena's ordeal," writes Il Manifesto's correspondent from Baghdad, Stefano Chiarini. "Suffering daily abuses and violence from occupation forces or their proxies, the Iraqis themselves are subjected to routine hostage-taking by the occupiers. If the father is not at home, they arrest his son, or brother, or other relative. Under the pretext of looking for arms, American soldiers and their Iraqi trainees look for jewels and money . And, yet, the whole country has mobilised for the liberation of Giuliana."Sgrena comes from a long line of anti-Americans. As reported in the previous story, her father is a member of the Communist party. The report also confirms that she was a sixties radical opposed to all US efforts since her days in college.
Posted by: Rusty at
10:06 AM
| Comments (3)
| Add Comment
Post contains 183 words, total size 1 kb.
Well that statment is Just A LITTLE EXTREAME..............oh but wait......her Father was a Communist and (therefor)it MUST be a hoax I mean WHAT OTHER explaination could there POSSIBLY be?
HMMMMMMMMMMM.....Prehaps she REALLY DID get kiddnapped.................................................WOW what a novel idea!
Posted by: Common Sense at February 14, 2005 07:53 PM (ISUWO)
Posted by: Rusty at February 15, 2005 07:59 AM (JQjhA)
Posted by: greyrooster at February 21, 2005 04:23 AM (CBNGy)
February 11, 2005
Wretchard has a post up about Lynne Stewart's conviction wherein he makes the observation not only that the compassion of the left is selective, but that it's conditioned by the Left's "refusal to acknowledge anything smaller than a mass noun." The essence of this perspective concerns the evidence that Stewart, along with some co-conspirators, sought to use the leverage of the kidnapping of civilians, including "poor" Filipinos and children as well as the sick and elderly, to leverage their negotiations for the Sheik's treatment and release. In essence it concerns a defacto alliance with the Al Qaeda-affiliated kidnappers. It's instructive to consider just how the Left and Stewart's team are spinning this story, including the presentation of their attempts to employ the leverage of the kidnappings. more...
Posted by: Demosophist at
12:11 PM
| Comments (7)
| Add Comment
Post contains 730 words, total size 5 kb.
Lynne Stewart is lucky she wasnt tried for TREASON!!!
Thank god a jury saw through her ridiculous defense and
did the right thing. Our only hope is that they throw
the book at her and let her rot in prison!
M.W.
Posted by: MIGHTY WHITEY at February 11, 2005 12:40 PM (julWr)
Posted by: Rod Stanton at February 11, 2005 01:39 PM (gVJtb)
Posted by: Steve D at February 11, 2005 02:24 PM (L/wan)
Posted by: Hammertime at February 11, 2005 02:28 PM (cFg3z)
Posted by: Rod Stanton at February 12, 2005 07:48 AM (gVJtb)
Posted by: Cao at February 12, 2005 09:10 PM (RyucI)
I am sure however, that she will find hot,sweet love in jail.
Posted by: Filthy Allah at February 13, 2005 09:47 AM (cXqSY)
February 10, 2005
Posted by: Rusty at
03:16 PM
| Comments (1)
| Add Comment
Post contains 229 words, total size 2 kb.
Posted by: Digger at February 11, 2005 02:42 AM (c2i02)
54 queries taking 0.0889 seconds, 696 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.









