October 02, 2006
An effing political solution?
An effing truce?
Cover your ears folks, I never swear. Never. (Lord, forgive me!)
What the fuck is this motherfucking piece of shit doing leading the Republican party in the Senate? He does not get it.
The clarification is no better. Moderate Islamists. Nice.
The only difference between a moderate Islamist and a radical one is that moderates are convinced that they need to participate in the democratic process to come to power. Once in power, though, they make no bones about using their new found legitimacy by democratically enacting sharia law.
You know, cause it's so much better having a democratically elected government cut your fucking head off for blaspheming Mohammed than one that eschews elections as harim.
Fucking nitwits.
That is all.
I'll leave you with this from Ace:
If Afghanistan truly cannot be de-Taibanized, it's time to pull up stakes there and simply begin bombing it as frequently as necessary to kill as many Afghans as possible.Amen, brutha.
No, I have a few things on my mind.
I've tried to refrain from criticisms of the President and the war. Occasionally, you've heard me say things like "fire Donald Rumsfeld". And I meant it. Still do. Rumsfeld is a jackass who has no business leading a modern military.
The only thing that kept me supporting the Republicans, and still does, is that if Bush and Rumsfeld don't know how to fight a war at least they are willing to fight.
The only sure way to lose a war is not to fight it when attakced. So, supporting the Republicans was a longshot gamble, but supporting the Democrats was a sure bet to lose.
I've also tried to refrain from too many criticisms of the neocons and their plans to remake the world in our image. The argument that supporting dicatatorships has not helped reduce terrorism in the world seems like it has some merit to it, so the thought of democratizing the world as a strategy for self defense seemed plausible.
But it becomes increasingly apparent that Muslims cannot be trusted with democracy outside of a framework in which secularism is imposed through force (such as in Turkey where the military is always standing by in the wings to crush democracy if Islamists ever get too uppity).
Our major mistake in Iraq and Afghanistan was adopting the Colin Powell doctrine of "you break it, you buy it."
No, nitwits, we break it we break it. We fought these wars to send messages to the enemies of the United States. I think Pervez Musharraf pretty much sums it up when he quotes Richard Armitage as threatening to bomb his "country back into the stone ages."
That is how foreign policy is done in the real world, kids. How adults do it.
If democracy in the Middle East is a grand experiment, then the null hypothesis has been disproven. No, the majority of Muslim nations are not yet ready for democracy. Give them another hundred years and we'll run this experiment again.
I've alluded to this line of thinking dozens of times here. Especially as I've tried to patiently explain to libtards that there were really two Iraq wars.
One: the invasion. Not only went off without a hitch, went much better than planned.
Two: the occupation. Shit hits fan.
I had been willing to let the neocons do their experimenting of bringing a Muslim nation into the fold of civilization. All the while in the back of my head--and many times in writing--asking what the hell we were doing not giving the secular Kurds a state? These guys are not just allies with mutual interests, but friends who shed blood and would willingly give us places for forward bases. Or why were we not giving Fallujah the Carthage treatment? You know, carpet bombing followed by salting the earth. Or why were we letting freedom of speech enter into a war zone?
And even if this grand experiment in remaking the Muslim world in our image had a modicum of a chance to succeed, then you have to start from the beginning. The beginning is to beat them. Badly. So badly, in fact, that they know they have no chance of ever winning.
Their entire culture and civilization must be completely wiped off the face of the earth. It was only after millions of civilian casualties and the total wasting of all centers of production that the Germans and the Japanese could be rebuilt in our image.
To quote Gladiator, A people should know when they are conquered. Only after this can we even begin to think of changing their ways.
I have always been skeptical of the notion that we can 'win the hearts and minds of moderates'. What we need to do is win the fear of realists. People like Musharraf who understands that if he does not play ball, we destroy him. And if Musharraf is a dictator, better a dictator on our side than a democratically elected nutjob--like in Iran--ready to start WWIII.
Okay, enough said. I'm pissed. You should be too. The State Departmenting of the world has not only begun, it has succeeded. God help us all.
UPDATE: Jim Beam, in the comments says:
You are advocating the carpet-bombing of entire cities. Is this really what you want? Bear in mind, you'll have to look at that face when you shave in the morning.I don't want to kill anybody. I am simply a believer in FDR's strategy on the holocaust, that the surest way to end it was speedy victory. But I also believe in the Truman doctrine that total victory means total victory. Our main goal in bombing Japan was not in making Japan our ally, rather, it was to make it incapable of ever doing us harm again. Truman:
We are now prepared to obliterate more rapidly and completely every productive enterprise the Japanese have above ground in any city. We shall destroy their docks, their factories, and their communications. Let there be no mistake; we shall completely destroy Japan's power to make war.Think about it.
Posted by: Rusty at
06:00 PM
| Comments (33)
| Add Comment
Post contains 1027 words, total size 6 kb.
face of the earth".
Now you know exactly how I feel!
Posted by: Garduneh Mehr at October 02, 2006 06:14 PM (vixLB)
This piece? Just shit, my friend. It leads me to conclude that you're just another bigot, but one who lacks the courage to nail his colours to the wall.
Sure. We have some problems with Islam, and they need to be resolved. Unfortunalty, people so far down the food chain that they never had any part in deciding policy will die as a result of this. I wish it wasn't so, but it's a necessary evil.
You are advocating the carpet-bombing of entire cities. Is this really what you want? Bear in mind, you'll have to look at that face when you shave in the morning.
Ass.
Posted by: Jim Beam at October 02, 2006 06:16 PM (XfjsX)
Posted by: Alex at October 02, 2006 06:18 PM (3VsxC)
GOP IS DONE.
DON'T VOTE FOR ANY GOP CANDIDATE THIS ELECTION.
START IT. SPREAD IT. GOP & CITGO CAN GO TO HELL.
THIS BIT AND THE OPEN SOUTHERN BORDER.
Posted by: QC at October 02, 2006 06:23 PM (PX+vn)
THE REPORTER SAYS THE DEFEATIST STUFF. NOT FRIST.
http://www.iht.com/bin/print_ipub.php?file=/articles/ap/2006/10/02/asia/AS_GEN_Afghanistan_Frist.php
This is more typical defeatist media shit, not GOP going all sideways.
I feel scammed.
Posted by: QC at October 02, 2006 06:52 PM (PX+vn)
Posted by: Editor at October 02, 2006 06:54 PM (adpJH)
Posted by: kneeb at October 02, 2006 07:00 PM (PNnTY)
Let them build their own goddamn schools, electric plants, etc.
OR ...let us fight a war the way it is supposed to be fought, get the job done and get the hell out.
Posted by: Senor PeerPressure at October 02, 2006 07:04 PM (YzR+X)
to survive. From a moral standpoint it kinda sickens me to say that,
but their actions lead me ever more and more to this conclusion.
One just has to look at Israel to see what I'm talking about. I know
both sides in that conflict have done reprehensible things, but for
literally my entire life some Palastinians have strapped nail and screw
embedeed plastic explosives to themselves and detonated in buses,
restaurants, and crowded markets, with special attention paid to trying
to hit targets full of children, even when the Israelis were minding
their own business. Every attempt to negotiate with them has not met
with a cessation, or even a slackening, of hostilities while the talks
go on. In fact, the complete opposite happens; bombings of innocents
increase. The only thing that seems to make them slow down is when the
Israelis go 'disproportionate force' on them or they run out of their monthly symtex shipment. I can only bear this in
mind when their allies, who make them look like completely inept
smallfries, declare themselves our enemies and very vocally and
publicly declare their goal is our complete destruction or subjigation.
Add on top of this the dismal failure of every negotiated peace we've
entered into since at least 1900. There was a reason we firebombed
Japanese and German cities into charred wastes, as Rusty points out. If we
hadn't we ran the risk of the exact same thing happeneing all over
again with the exact same people because they would hold a grudge against us for losing and think we were weak; an 'inferior race'. We were not doing it out of racism and hate, at least on a national level. The message was "police yourselves from the inside and stop these kinds of people if you don't want this to happen to you again."
If we get hit again at home this will definitely be my position, especially if by that time there is some sort of settlement.
"But there are innocents that could be killed who are just afraid of
the jihadis or brainwashed by them" is an argument my mom uses if this
topic comes up at home. So? That's how the nazis got to power. The
radicals frightened and brainwashed the people into obedient
submission. Commies ditto. We all know how much they care(d) about
innocent life. Does that make me as evil as them? I don't thinks so but that could be argued. If that is the case I'd rather be evil, alive, and free than 'good' and living in fear of myself and family under the heel of some smacktard who thinks he's better than me because he says so.
Posted by: Ranba Ral at October 02, 2006 07:50 PM (VvXII)
There are some"peoples" that are really not ready for democracy. Don't go to war with them, swat them like a fly. They don't care for their own and we are supposed to worry?? If we go limp on this we will take some serious damage. Now, how do we get the people informed and energized?
Posted by: bald01 at October 02, 2006 08:05 PM (FAdsr)
Posted by: Rusty at October 02, 2006 09:01 PM (JQjhA)
Eliminate al-Sadr and the Shiite uprising now. When this is done, the Sunnis will fall like dominos. If a whole city needs to be flattened, then that is what needs to be done. Strike them where they are. Everywhere. The hearts and minds will follow the peace.
Posted by: SeeMonk at October 02, 2006 09:09 PM (n4VvM)
There are no "innocents". Just Muslims and kafir. In Islam, innocence means nothing -- OBL already made it clear that there is no distinction between military and civilians. War is war: you can't win a war by playing by all the rules; you have to get as down and dirty as does your enemy. Fuck morality: this is about survival. If survival means the absolute destruction of Islam (the culture, the political Mein Kampf, the religion), then so be it; but do it.
Those idiots who connect this to the GOP are just "useful idiots" in the eyes of the jihadists. Think of who will take their place ... and then pray for your own asses; because your anti-GOP vote will just play into their hands even quicker.
WHAT IS WRONG WITH US? Oh wait. It's political correctness. Never mind, my bad.
Posted by: Kafir at October 02, 2006 09:16 PM (DSZBB)
radicals frightened and brainwashed the people into obedient
submission"
Exactly, lots of innocent Germans had to die along with the radicals they did not stop.
Jim, remind us all please, when was the last war that had a
satisfactory ending without total victory by any means? Here's a hint,
we carpet bombed and nuked cities in it.
In the nuclear age, the stakes have heightened significantly, as enemy
states like Pakistan and Iran have or are building nuclear weapons, and
spreading the information on how across the Middle East, AQ Khan.
Then there are possible advances in producing a nuclear explosion
without the need for pu239 or u235, but simply deuterium, which is
readily available to the world.
Posted by: Naieve at October 02, 2006 09:17 PM (+PWjE)
I've tried to refrain from criticisms of the President and the war. Occasionally, you've heard me say things like "fire Donald Rumsfeld". And I meant it. Still do. Rumsfeld is a jackass who has no business leading a modern military.
This does nothing to advance our party, our president or the struggle we face. It is vacuous and defeatist howling and will only call Democrat wolves to watch as the Republican Party tears itself apart.
Resorting to name-calling and platitudes demeans yourself, Professor.
I've also tried to refrain from too many criticisms of the neocons and their plans to remake the world in our image. The argument that supporting dicatatorships has not helped reduce terrorism in the world seems like it has some merit to it, so the thought of democratizing the world as a strategy for self defense seemed plausible.
Again, another smack at Neoconservatives. The State Department guys would be so happy.
But it becomes increasingly apparent that Muslims cannot be trusted with democracy outside of a framework in which secularism is imposed through force (such as in Turkey where the military is always standing by in the wings to crush democracy if Islamists ever get too uppity).
Why? Because this strategy is only 3 years old and we have had some difficulties? Geezus, talk about defeatist.
Our major mistake in Iraq and Afghanistan was adopting the Colin Powell doctrine of "you break it, you buy it."
Colin Powell was, like yourself, suspicious of and finally opposed to the "Neocons".
No, nitwits, we break it we break it. We fought these wars to send messages to the enemies of the United States. I think Pervez Musharraf pretty much sums it up when he quotes Richard Armitage as threatening to bomb his "country back into the stone ages."
Why are you so hungry to believe this Musharraf statement as opposed to his claims that he did not recently give the Taliban a refuge. If I were you, I would be more leery of anything Musharraf has said, and avoid believing that which matched what I wanted to believe.
If democracy in the Middle East is a grand experiment, then the null hypothesis has been disproven. No, the majority of Muslim nations are not yet ready for democracy. Give them another hundred years and we'll run this experiment again.
I think 3 years is inadequate to say that the Middle East is not ready for democracy.
I've alluded to this line of thinking dozens of times here. Especially as I've tried to patiently explain to libtards that there were really two Iraq wars.
One: the invasion. Not only went off without a hitch, went much better than planned.
Two: the occupation. Shit hits fan.
I think history will enventually reflect that there is one big Iraq war. It started in 1990 when Saddam threatened to invade Kuwait for oil cartel violations (July), then did invade in early August (so it really was about oil after all). There was never a peace agreement, and Iraqi and Coalition forces were shooting at each other daily for over 12 years. We had to intervene to bring finality to this single war, regardless of whether one poo-poos humanitarian objections and the perversity of the UN oil for food scam.
I had been willing to let the neocons do their experimenting of bringing a Muslim nation into the fold of civilization. All the while in the back of my head--and many times in writing--asking what the hell we were doing not giving the secular Kurds a state? These guys are not just allies with mutual interests, but friends who shed blood and would willingly give us places for forward bases.
It's only been 3 years, Professor! Let's not assume it is a failed plan yet. The Kurds may still get an independent state, particularly if you use your blog to contribute to the climate of impending defeat and self-loathing, and thereby help to elect Joe Biden and his merry band of Democrats to power.
Further, the current violence in Iraq is a reflection of the present state of Islam. Baathism is spent. It is Sunnis and Shites killing each other. In the end, History will smile on the United States for its altruism, yes altruism, and self-sacrifice in trying to make Iraq a better place. Iraqis may be difficult to help, but America at least tried.
Or why were we not giving Fallujah the Carthage treatment? You know, carpet bombing followed by salting the earth. Or why were we letting freedom of speech enter into a war zone?
If you become tenured someday, maybe you will have the courage to come out of your anonymity and publically scream for the blood of civilians. Geezus. You advocate fighting wars like Papa Assad smothered Palestinians.
And even if this grand experiment in remaking the Muslim world in our image had a modicum of a chance to succeed, then you have to start from the beginning. The beginning is to beat them. Badly. So badly, in fact, that they know they have no chance of ever winning.
What metrics do you use to determine that a people is finally beaten after you have occupied them? The South knew it had been defeated militarily, but it did not stop their intransigence, it did not stop them from thinking of themselves as a nation for long after the Civil War and it did not stop the subtle insurgency, as manifested by the Klu Kluxers whose main goal was to kill carpet baggers.
Their entire culture and civilization must be completely wiped off the face of the earth.
False. You're next example of Germany and Japan argues against this.
We did not destroy "their entire culture and civilization."It was only after millions of civilian casualties and the total wasting of all centers of production that the Germans and the Japanese could be rebuilt in our image.
No, it was mainly after we killed their political leadership. Once this happened, we did not continue to kill them. The common people of both Germany and Japan, and even the soldiers who fought for them, managed to get on okay after the war. Sherman realized that killing the zealots was what really mattered. But he never inflicted massive civilian casualties, as you advocated.
To quote Gladiator, A people should know when they are conquered. Only after this can we even begin to think of changing their ways.
I would argue that prior to 2001, Afghanistan was never truly conquered, yet it did suffer millions of civilian casualties. Wiliam of Orange conquered England, probably the great seapower at the time, but there were relatively few civilian casualties. Killing civilians may create an empty parking lot and feed one's blood thirst, but it will not always assure the desired victory.
I have always been skeptical of the notion that we can 'win the hearts and minds of moderates'. What we need to do is win the fear of realists. People like Musharraf who understands that if he does not play ball, we destroy him. And if Musharraf is a dictator, better a dictator on our side than a democratically elected nutjob--like in Iran--ready to start WWIII.
Ah ha. Now. Go ahead and say it. JUST GO AHEAD AND SAY IT ! Iraq was better off with Saddam in power, right????
First you piss on "Neocons", then you advocate indiscriminate carpet bombing of cities and the murder of "millions of civilians", now you advocate the realist approach to foreign policy, historically favored by the State Department of James Baker, Clinton's various toadies and Colin Powell, the same bullshit that created the situation we are now confronted with. Create a dictator who we can do business with, even if he kills his own people, then sit back and let the killing go on. After all, they are only civilians who are dying, right?
Okay, enough said. I'm pissed. You should be too. The State Departmenting of the world has not only begun, it has succeeded. God help us all.
Go back to your original point, about the only difference between a moderate Islamist and a radical. "Secular" Saddam used Islam when it suited him (http://regimeofterror.com/archives/2006/06/saddam_husseins_regime_and_isl/). Meanwhile, Pakistan remains a religious state. The Taliban was Pakistan's favorite child, and Afghanistan (prior to 2001) was Pakistan's satellite. To this day Pervez Musharraf coddles the Taliban and will not pursue them, and even went so far as to make peace with them and offer to leave them, unmolested, in a de-facto safe haven. "People like Musharraf who understands that if he does not play ball, we destroy him." Yeah, right.
"State Departmenting of the world"
Ha.
Posted by: Darth Vag at October 02, 2006 09:41 PM (HSkSw)
I wanted to offer a couple of observations. First, the anger and outrage you are feeling is very much like the anger and outrage people on the left have been feeling for some time now. For the exact same reason. You feel betrayed, just like we have for some time now. It's really that simple. It's not something I would wish on anyone.
I point this out with the hope you will have a bit more empathy for the positions we take. They are not because of a hatred for the country, or a desire to damage others, or even a *gotcha*...quite the opposite. It's because we are terribly frustrated and believe that we are watching a slow motion trainwreck. It's because we believe people are making terrible decisions and doing it all in our name.
I think that is what sent Shep Smith over the edge in his recent interview with the always smug Bill Kristol.
In other words, we have more in common than you may realize. I read Frist's comments and there is no doubt they are outrageous, but I merely shrug because I have used up all my outrage with the man. Who knows what deals got cut over dinner with Musharraf and Kharzai. Does anyone doubt a deal was cut and that we will be the last to learn its details? Does anyone doubt that Frist and the other "leaders" (ok ...cronies) are all aware of it? Do I really need a tin foil hat to even contemplate those possibilities? I don't think so.
I have no love lost for the Taliban. They're Medieval. They are a product of the ISI, CIA and Saudi Royal family. Come on, what possible product of that unholy alliance could ever offer anything of value? I look at them and I am not surprised to learn the Mumbai bombing in India has been determined to be the work of the Pakistani ISI. With allies like that I don't believe we can eke out a military victory in either Afghanistan or Iraq. I certainly don't think we are in a posture to start a shooting war with Iran. Yet, I look at our current leadership and there is no doubt they are leading us down the road to ruin. They lie, they cheat, they steal and then they rewrite the laws to absolve themselves of the most heinous acts.
I'm sorry Frist sent you off the deep end. After you get a chance to cool off a bit I hope you will take a look around you and realize the folks he's been telling you are the enemy really aren't. And at the end of the day, that is the problem. We need to decide if we stand for the rule of law or not. If we can't agree on that, then we may as well just toss the Republic, grab some guns and may the best shot win. But before you rush to the gun cabinet think about this little factoid: we go down and the forces of totalitarianism will have precious little to stop them. I would hate to be in the generation that let the vandals sack Rome. What about you?
Posted by: 8ackgr0und N015e at October 02, 2006 10:34 PM (StXdk)
Jim Beam: Crawl back under your rock , you coward. When have I ever been disproved concerning anything I have posted? You ain't nothing but another meanly mouthed punk too cowardly to speak up and face the world. Piss on you.
Posted by: greyrooster at October 03, 2006 07:54 AM (xJ3Xm)
Posted by: Howie at October 03, 2006 08:36 AM (YdcZ0)
Greyrooster, all you ever do here is swear at people and moan about blacks. What's to disprove? And, for that matter, what's so brave about pressing a few buttons and watching entire cities vanish? Maybe it makes some form of sense from a strictly utilitarian point of view, but it's not exactly Rambo-style macho bravery, is it? (Incidentally - it's *mealy* mouthed, you unspectacular mong)
Posted by: Jim Beam at October 03, 2006 10:36 AM (1oVh8)
not victory. We are not at war with islam, but islam is at war with us,
and we may not survive as a culture long enough for enough people to
realize that. It is already too late for Europe, and by the time
children born today are old and gray, the culture that bore Mozart, Da
Vinci, et al, will be extinct.
Islam is nothing but savage arab tribal warfare unified under the
banner of their moon god, and its only goal is is the enslavement and
domination of the entire planet. There are no muslims who are not our
enemies, though many pass as allies of convenience, but the only reason
a muslim will stand behind you is to be in an advantageous position
from which to stand you in the back when the time is convenient. Anyone
who thinks that peace is possible while there is one muslim alive
anywhere on the planet is simply an idiot.
Posted by: Improbulus Maximus at October 03, 2006 10:57 AM (v3I+x)
Posted by: Jim Beam at October 03, 2006 02:38 PM (1oVh8)
Posted by: omar at October 03, 2006 04:13 PM (aA47d)
Posted by: Last gasp Larry at October 04, 2006 12:32 AM (Dd86v)
Posted by: greyrooster at October 04, 2006 11:22 AM (xJ3Xm)
Posted by: greyrooster at October 04, 2006 11:36 AM (xJ3Xm)
Posted by: Jim Beam at October 04, 2006 12:53 PM (xctzC)
Posted by: duffey at October 04, 2006 05:15 PM (lY1KT)
Posted by: duffey at October 04, 2006 05:15 PM (lY1KT)
To the left of the keyboard, somewhere around three buttons up, you'll find one marked 'caps lock'. Try pressing it before you post. Nub.
Posted by: Jim Beam at October 04, 2006 06:39 PM (xctzC)
Posted by: greyrooster at October 04, 2006 10:58 PM (xJ3Xm)
Posted by: greyrooster at October 04, 2006 11:01 PM (xJ3Xm)
First, let me say I agree w most of what you said. w/o going into boring detail.
I know you are frustrated, and in your present state of mind perhaps not fully coherent but think about the sad irony of what you sid here:
"Only two reasons left to vote Republican. Actually, one reason, two words: Nancy Pelosi."
The fact is that at least as to Afghanistan and the Taliban, Pelosi is taking a far more aggresive stand than Frist, regardless of whatever her devious motivation might be.
I think we may be fucked if this is the best we can do.
And while I agree on Afghanistan, Iraq seems to me to be a whole diff game. Some poster mentioned the banning of online poker. Well, in that game you need to know when to hold em and when to fold em.
Darth Vag says, "Iraqis may be difficult to help
but America at least tried."
OMG, if that doesn't sound eerily like Clinton's rant on Bin Ladin, "I tried to get him. I really did. I tried to kill, and I admit I failed, but at least I tried." (mild praphrase)
Sorry, Im getting off that ship and any that dont, have got blinders. For ever, I hung onto the mantra of, "we are where we are regardless of how or why we got there. It was a good concept though crap in the execution. The consequences of not staying the course and losing by withdrwal are too disastrous to contemplate."
BSBSBS, the consequences may be disastrous, but throwing good $$$ and lives after bad aint gonna
do jack. Either, commit the forces necessary to at least give us a shot, and if not, then to hell with em. If they want to kill each other off, have at it.
Posted by: gandalf007 at October 05, 2006 01:09 PM (CPPqH)
Posted by: Jim Beam at October 05, 2006 01:14 PM (+JEf5)
34 queries taking 0.1038 seconds, 188 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.









