August 01, 2006

The Flawed Moral Compass of the Antiwar Left

Grab some coffee - this one's a little windy. Consider this my excercise in channeling my inner Bill Whittle. Cross-posted at Mein Blogovault.

As the current Israeli-Hezbullah conflict hurtles forward, I am uneasy. I am not uneasy because I am afraid. I do not doubt Israel’s military capabilities. I do not question the capabilities of our troops either. I have doubts about the resolve of our “leaders,” and I use the term loosely. I don’t think that there has been good political leadership in this war effort, despite the incredible and valuable accomplishments of our military and our country (thank G-d the Generals in the field don’t act like our politicians). That is also not the same thing as saying that the attempt at leadership is at fault. The situation we face today is in many ways unlike one the nation’s leadership has faced before – an amorphous, religious death cult that has inserted itself into the woodwork of the civilized world and lies in wait to attack on its own terms. This presents a multitude of difficulties that we see unfolding in our courts, on the battlefield and in our discourse. The “face” of the political leadership, however, is at times frighteningly absent. I’m sure that there are plenty of back-door dealings going on to try to cool the temperature of the world diplomatically in any way possible, but the Administration really needs to (and seems a bit late to do it at this point) to come out and keep hammering the policy home. I know that the President is not particularly well-spoken in an era where communications are the name of the game. I know that many perceive this lack of erudite articulation as an indication of “stupidity.” That is on its face ridiculous. I have several very intelligent old college friends who have a stutter and slight speech problems. They are successful and intelligent people. That is not, to me, an indication of intelligence. It can’t hurt to be articulate, but it isn’t the be-all and end-all of assessment of talents, abilities or intellect to a reasonable person.

In addition, there are plenty of “rock stars” against the war who can’t articulate a cohesive though without a curse word , and movie and TV actors that speak nothing to nobody unless their scriptwriters write it for them. Their opinions are regarded by the anti-war left as valid, important, courageous and heroic without question. The President fumbles words from time to time, however, and he is the stupidest, dumbest liar, fraud and dictator that has ever lived. Food for thought. And please - no lectures about “Yeah, but rock stars aren’t in charge of the country” crap – they aren’t indeed, and that’s why the nation has been voting the Clintons and their groupies out of office for 12 years now. You are essentially making an argument to return the Clinton-tour groupies to power. Clowns like that shouldn’t be in charge (especially in a time of war), and now they aren’t. Isn’t it lovely how that works?

Diversions aside, I want to get to a central premise. Leadership deficiencies noted, I also question with greater veracity the so-called “moral” stance of the antiwar left. Their moral magnets have been completely warped by a generation of subtle Gramscian Marxism and Derridaian deconstructionist “critical thinking” being taught to captive audiences in the public education system and to passive audiences in the American mass media (particularly, TV news media and print media). Yes – I guess this makes me a believer in the strong media effects, especially during a time of war (when the populace is likely to defer to the news media to report facts objectively on world events that they don't have the resources nor time to find out themselves.) The modern near-diagnosable mental condition known affectionately as BDS (Bush Derangement Syndrome) is a manifestation of anger at the rejection of these inherently socialist, pacifist and post-modern views. Spurned, the American left (think Denaiac left) has instead chosen to give their political opponents the rhetorical, moral and intellectual cold-shoulder. Facts and history no longer matter, unless they advance the dying antiwar ideology. Moral contradictions of “human rights advocates” screaming about alleged slapping of terrorists in a detention center while remaining inanimate about real torture, atrocities, repression and political murder in countries like Iran, Syria, China, North Korea, etc. are quite commonplace. Votes made by Democrats and the international community (UN 1441) authorizing the war are quickly forgotten and are replaced by new narratives that do not include these politically inconvenient facts. There is no intellectual honesty whatsoever. Claims of “moral high ground” ring hollow coming from such obvious hypocrites. As such, a solid block of Americans has essentially surrendered. In their hearts, in their minds and in their souls, they have given up on responding to 9-11. They are not necessarily bad people, but they have been irreversibly convinced of their own fears and shortcomings by forces all too eager to sell them those fears and shortcomings. My personal belief is that they actually surrendered in late 2001, when the last ashes of 9-11 finally settled and it became apparent we were not going to lie down like a good little victim and take it.

My view is not unique among conservatives and war supporters, and is not simply a matter of an honest difference of opinion regarding policy pursuits. My point is aimed more at the non-religious “spiritual” side of this issue. There is a disturbing lack of moral clarity coming from our American leftwing, and it is hurting the short and long-term interests of the country. Style has replaced substance as a frame for issue discussion. Diplomats, “peace advocates/activists” and “critics” are every day repeating the delusions of 1939 Britain and Europe – believing that “land for peace” is somehow going to broker goodwill and mercy from an enemy who has plainly stated their intentions to do away with mercy and goodwill towards their perceived enemies. When Chamberlain signed over the Rhineland to Germany, he consigned to death and Nazi occupation thousands of Czechs (the momentum of which then carried the Nazis into Poland and the world into a necessary but unwanted conflict).

What was saved? Egos? Platitudes? Lives? Leftism? Jews? Europe? None of it was saved by negotiation or appeasement – and leftists (socialists) simply denied their central role in the conflict (National Socialism) and moved on as their ideology allows them to divorce themselves from their past. Appeasement from official governing powers made the situation infinitely worse by rewarding the behavior and intentions of Hitler, thereby emboldening him further and weakening Europe’s ability and will to fight a rapidly gathering threat.

Of course, we hear about World War II a lot in this current conflict, but seldom coming from the left. Why? Simple – we won WWII. It seems that they are unwilling to get into the parallels about WWII when it comes to absolute victory, propaganda wars, treasonous press / activist behavior, national unity, political disagreements, and the like. The American left (the 60’s-led “counterculture”) instead like to refer to America’s “loss” in Vietnam as an example of their foreign-policy wisdom and are trying furiously to equate the effort in Iraq with a war in which they dictated our terms of surrender. So the conservative line of thought refers to wars we have won for historical examples of what needs to be done to win this current one. The liberal thought refers to a conflict America lost to give examples of what needs to be done to…lose the current war? That is unfortunately the conclusion we are left to draw from the Vietnam syndrome that has infected the leftwing of America politics over the past 50 years.

The current conflict in the Middle East is neither WWII or Vietnam, but it bears much more resemblance to the run-up to World War II than hampered and complcated sociopolitical-centric war effort in Vietnam. There is rampant poverty, repression and hopelessness in many regions of the Arab world (just like in Germany pre-WWII). Arab cultures, in both their own eyes and the eyes of many powers, have suffered what they perceive as a series of ongoing humiliations on the international stage over the past century– some of which include a penchant for paranoid dictatorships and hard-line Islamic internal law, the creation of Israel itself, the ongoing disgraces that are the West Bank and Gaza, the defeat of most of their militaries by the United States and Israel, the “debasement” of Western culture and its influences in Islamic culture, etc. Germany was humiliated, blamed, and saddled with mounting debts to society and foreign powers in the years between World War I and II, and Hitler rose to prominence by taking those humiliations, doubts and fears, and instead turned them to his personal scapegoats – the Jews, the non-Aryans and non-Germans. Both military and internal opposition to Hitler was met with brutal and swift punishment. Civilians in the path of the Nazis were given a choice – get on board or die. Islamic sharia law and the principles of jihad are no different – either submit to the ideology or die as an infidel to the ideology. It is very easy to draw comparisons between Nazism and Radical Islamism –the anti-Semitism and dehumanization of apostates and opponents is there, the repression, the intolerance for internal and external dissent, the constant state of rage and foamented hatred that pours into the streets on a daily basis, etc. Its all there - the Nazis simply harnessed it and converted it through industrial processes into a mobilized and uniformed fighting force.

Mistakes happen in every major world conflict on both sides, but there is a segment of our own populace determined to use those mistakes and only those mistakes to turn a massive and, quite frankly, benevolent American effort into a unilateral defeat to “celebrate” until we are shocked out of our sleep again by another massive tragedy on the scale of 9-11. Nearly half of the US population (many who claim to be paying close attention) seem to be unable or unwilling to make a difficult moral judgment in this conflict. This is entirely within the rights of any citizen – you have the right not to do something or not to support something you think is wrong. There is a fundamental inconsistency in American anti-war thought, however, that has been made glaringly obvious during the public rhetorical battle over the last few years. Forgive the straw man, but it is necessary to make the point palpable.

An old lefty anti-Catholic saw goes something like “The Catholic Church did nothing to save the Jews in the concentration camps. They stood idly by while millions were slaughtered!” Beside this statement being inaccurate, it is also politically convenient for those opposed to the Catholic Church to begin with. It also makes a moral judgment – that the concentration camps were morally wrong, and needed to be stopped. Now – since a moral judgment on the Nazis is made, there must be some ability or criterion among the purveyors of such logic to judge what is wrong and right.

It is now that the test of consistent logic needs to be applied. In the second set of responses, I’ve filled in hypothetical answers that I’ve heard, read or seen argued by the left in the past 4.5 years. Here we go.

Is anti-Semitism wrong? Yes.

Is a desire to blame Jews and to kill them an appropriate mind frame for a proponent of Nazism? Yes.

Despite heavy casualties on our part and the lack of direct provocation by Germany, were we right to invade Europe and to destroy the Nazis? Absolutely.

We won, and that was an infinitely better thing for Europe and the world then would’ve been if Hitler had conquered Europe, right? Correct.

Sounds reasonable, right? Now move forward and ask the same questions regarding today’s Middle East war:

In the case of Islamic radicalism, is anti-Semitism wrong? Well, yes and no - the US supports Israel, so I can see why they hate Israelis, as well as the inherent anti-Semitism that is rampant in Islamic societies anyway – to be expected, but not necessarily wrong.

Is a desire to blame Jews and to kill them an appropriate frame of mind for a radical Islamist? Well, yes, but again, the US supports Israel, and the Arabs don’t like Israel, and are therefore justified in their rhetoric, beliefs, who are we to tell them what they believe is wrong etc.

Despite heavy casualties on our part and direct provocation on the part of Iraq and Afghanistan, were we right to invade the countries and to destroy their oppressive regimes (one dictator, and the Taliban)? Iraq was wrong, Afghanistan was right.

Would it not be better for the region if the United States and Coalition were to succeed in their current objectives than would be if we let the status quo go on for another 25 years? I think we’ve made the problem infinitely worse – jihadis are being recruited etc.

Corollaries: If Afghanistan was right but Iraq wrong, then you were in favor of leaving Saddam in power for another X years, followed by his psychotic rapist sons? Well…we’re not talking about that…

If our Iraq / Afgh. War causes more recruitment for jihadis, then what were these organizations and terrorists doing in the years prior to 9-11? How about in 1993, when the WTC was bombed? That is not relevant...Bush 'lied,' etc.

These hypothetical/reality based answers are not just hyperbolic assertions on the part of the left - they are rationales for the divorce of the left and their classical liberal values regarding this war. The moral compass of the left has shifted significantly from the traditional “right/wrong” to a conditional “right/wrong.” That conditional right/wrong has clouded the left’s groupthink in this country to the point that it is virtually impossible to discern the connection between their self-described “humanitarian” concern and its translation into their rhetoric during this current conflict. This is not to say that all liberals don’t support the conflict, that they are unpatriotic, that they are immoral or even that they are necessarily wrong in all of their critiques (they are in most of them). It is merely to point out that their logic and philosophical doctrine is flawed logically, and their rhetoric and actions used to support this doctrine are subsequently inconsistent and logically flawed.

There are a great many more tangents that one could branch off of this central lack of moral clarity, but that is fodder for another discussion. I will conclude with an anecdote.

When playing a football game, you do not spend the whole time focusing on the score of the opponent. Even if you are down, you still play. No team in history has advanced through a Super bowl season focused exclusively on their mistakes, their losses and the scores against them. Those who are victorious count their losses, and move forward with the plays and players that achieve victory. The focus must instead be on what is being done right, rather that using what is being done wrong to cripple the ability for the team to fix the problems to attain the win.

Have at it, if you’re still here and awake. :-)

Posted by: Good Lt. at 07:23 AM | Comments (25) | Add Comment
Post contains 2568 words, total size 16 kb.

1 excellent!

the world has different expectations for each side i the gwot.

the world has low expectations of the enemy, and expecially high ones for the usa and israel.

the expectations underlie the standards and tests.

the usa and israel are held to different standards.

our leaders - from bush and rice to olmert and blair, et al - are making us fight the enemy with one hand behind our back.

fdr and truman didnl;t fight ww2 this way.

that's why they won so fast and it's why they won unconditonal surrenders.

we shoulda whacked mookie alsatyr in 2003.
we should whacked saddam - ionstead of giving him a trial.
weshoulda whcked assad and nasrallah - they way the idf whacked yassin.

they shoulda whacked arafat DECADES ago.
we shoulda never agreed to a cease-fire in the korean war.

we shouda attacked the ussr in 1946.

and so on.

ALL the problems we face today were problems we coulda STOPPED YEARS AGO - at a much lower cost - in money and LIVES, (on all sides), if our "leaders" just had balls.

of course, a HUGE problem is the act that sincve ww2 the post-modern left has taken over the MS and the academy and this fifth column has hobbled us IMMEASUREABLY.

i just hope we survive to 2008 and elect a prez who is less dovish than GWBush - who , with his RoP talk and willingness to talk to kimjongil and let the euroweenies talk to iran - has proven to be a rather weak-kneed nevous nellie incapabe of dealing the enemy a death-blow.

he is too "compassionate" towards our enemies at home and abroad.

we need another truman - someone who will drop TWO big bombs if necessary.

Posted by: reliapundit at August 01, 2006 07:34 AM (cgkHA)

2 Phew... bit of a marathon, but worth it. Well-written.

I'd note, though, that's it's not just two camps labelled 'left' and 'right' - it's a continuum, with every conceivable combination of beliefs and opinions represented somewhere along the line.

I have a few lefty leanings in domestic policy, but believe the current war is right, and being fought with good reason. Seems simple - if you have an itch, you scratch it.

Posted by: Mr Nobody at August 01, 2006 07:47 AM (BV7IP)

3 True to an extent. I tried to throw in a little "fairness" by asserting that this is not necessarily the logical paradigm of all liberals, but it certainly is for anti-Americans of any and all stripes. The fact is that nearly all of those anti-American/anti-Israel characters (many of them the ideological engines and leaders of their respective left-wing causes) reside on the left side of the ideological divide.
 
Generalizations are a bitch, because you're automatically going to miss the details. I don't mind in this case - I'm merely trying to articulate my problem with some of the "loyal opposition."
 
Glad y'all enjoyed it.

Posted by: Good Lt at August 01, 2006 07:56 AM (yT+NK)

4 Saddam Hussein had agents in the U.S. prewar?
Yes, more than you think, and they were selling info on U.S. intelligence agents and trying to buy off anti-war votes..........
updates here
http://regimeofterror.com/archives/2006/07/iraqi_agents_on_trial_in_us_ir/

Posted by: Mark at August 01, 2006 08:16 AM (j+tr0)

5 Lt., you give the lefturds too much credit, probably because you, like most conservatives who refuse to think the worst of people, (optimism is a conservative trait), are subconsciously projecting your values on them. What you either fail to realize or refuse to see is that they are either brainwashed zombies incapable of objective, critical thought, or they are some flavor of anarchists, nihilists, or totalitarians who know very well what the consequences of this conflict will be if we lose, and they're cheering for the enemy. Lefturds unquestioningly support and defend every form of tyranny around the globe, and ceaselessly fight against the spread of freedom. They are scum who pose a clear and present threat to the future of humanity and civilization, and should be dealt with as such.

Posted by: Improbulus Maximus at August 01, 2006 08:21 AM (v3I+x)

6 reliapundit: How true. Does anyone realize that a big one on Iran will stop all this shit in its tracks. When I say big one I don't neccessarily mean nukes. We can give them 72 hrs to evactuate Tehran and then hit it with everything else. That should drive something into their rotten minds.
Then again, perhaps we would do the world a favor if we didn't give any notice. The Mongol way. Worked then. Why not now?

Posted by: Greyrooster at August 01, 2006 08:49 AM (7vK3e)

7

I read it all. Not bored or tired.


Posted by: Howie at August 01, 2006 09:02 AM (D3+20)

8 Before the crybabies chime in. Here's what I believe. Sooner or later Iran will get nuclear weapons. They will either buy them or create them. The religious zealot mind is not like other dangerous people. Example North Korea. Commies don't destroy others for the sake of God. Religious nut cases do.
The Iranians are so decietful thay may not use the weapons themselves but would give then to a Hamas or Hezbollah to use. Does anyone out there doubt that Hezbollah would use them today? Do you doubt that Iran would supply nukes to terrorists groups that would try to sneak them into other countries? Groups like Al Queda. Either buy or hijack a commericial jet or other high payload aircraft and fly it to New York City. Or even worse a southern city.(Heh, heh, the devil made me do it). I mean hell they could even parachute out and not have to die for the cause.
CAN WE TAKE THAT CHANCE? I say NO! End it now. Destroy Hezbollah's mother. Iran. And outlaw Islam.
Then perhaps, the world can mend. This crap cannot go on forever. We must think of our children and grand children. It's not right or fair for them to live in terror because we did not cure the problem in its infancy.

Posted by: Greyrooster at August 01, 2006 09:10 AM (7vK3e)

9 Sorry, I couldn't muster the patience to read through all that jibber-jabber! Reads like an 8th grade essay. Good example to make a case for the merits of brevity. Nothing to see here, onward ho!

Posted by: Last gasp Larry at August 01, 2006 10:31 AM (gLMre)

10 "Sorry, I couldn't muster the patience to read through all that jibber-jabber! Reads like an 8th grade essay. Good example to make a case for the merits of brevity. Nothing to see here, onward ho!"

Bwahaha! That's why I buried 97% below the fold. Fooled you!

Brevity is great when warranted. It isn't always called for, though. Brevity is the soul of wit. I wasn't trying to be flippant or witty. I was being methodical and deliberate - kind of how one would lay out a comprehensive argument or the crux of a thesis in more than a few sentences.

Sounds to me more like an 8th grade reading of the piece, not an 8th grade writing.

Patience is a virtue, LGL! ;-)

Posted by: Good Lt at August 01, 2006 10:43 AM (yT+NK)

11 Don't worry about Larry, Lt., he's over his head with the funny papers.

Posted by: Improbulus Maximus at August 01, 2006 12:18 PM (v3I+x)

12 Hmmm...seems like I'm banned on your stuff, Lt.
 
Incidentally, I thought it was well-written, and I appreciate that very little of worth can be said in five paragraphs.  Many complex ideas (federalist papers, for example) could not be conveyed on the blogs, for the reason.  Kudos for making the attempt.

I disagree with several aspects, but let's focus on just one: do you really think that Derrida is socialist in influence?  Or that Gramsci has much influence at all in our "public education" system?  My guess is that the vast majority have never read either, and that their influence is great attenuated.  Ayn Rand is always at the top of the list of books read by young Americans, Gramsci doesn't place in the top 1000.  And where in Derrida do you find socialism?  I haven't read everything the guy wrote (far from it) but I see him as more corrosive of the nature of inquiry and rationality.  That has helped the right in this country much more than the left, by reducing all truths to truth claims, power grabs.  Thus, the disrespect for science can be laid at Derrida's feet, among other deconstructionists.

Posted by: notdj at August 01, 2006 01:04 PM (aqTJB)

13 Dude,

Learn how to package paragraphs for your format. Thanks.

Posted by: Don Long at August 01, 2006 05:06 PM (W+MCZ)

14 Dude -

If you think that's bad, try reading the Communist Manifesto. There are about five paragraphs in the whole thing.

I abandoned newswriting style for this one because you can't complete complicated cohesive thoughts within three sentences per paragraph. Sorry - I felt long form was better suited to lay out a comprehensive point.

Posted by: Good Lt at August 01, 2006 06:34 PM (jWYAe)

15 jd (notdj)-

Derrida was a the father of postmodernism and what is known as the paradigm of exclusive deconstructivist thought. I never claimed he was a socialist. Socialism, a derivative of communism, is deconstructionist in its nature, in that it seeks not to build on Western thought, but to alter and invert it. Make of that what you will.

Gramsci was highly influential in journalism and media (like Menken), and I have been required to read many of his and other similar thinkers (Marx, obviously, alsoAdorno, Horkhiemer, Jameson, etc.) during my undergrad and grad comm. studies. He was not a philosopher as much as he was a propagandist and practitioner, but was influential and inspirational to early newspaper moguls like Hearst (as well as generations of muckrakers). Just finished school, not going back thank you very much. :-)

Sorry for the inside theoretical baseball and CV, all. Try to keep it a little shorter and sweeter in the comments as well, jd. I do appreciate the pointed questions.

That's all I'm going to pursue your line of questioning here. Email me if ya want.

Posted by: Good Lt at August 01, 2006 06:54 PM (jWYAe)

16 Some things simply aren't suited to brevity.

What we have here is a bloke trying to make a point. If you can write down everything in your head within twenty words - you're probably not worth listening to.

As it goes - one of my degrees is in English, I've had things published, and I'm no stranger to prose.

It was a decent piece.

For my money, Good Lt. is one of the best contributors to this site.

Posted by: Mr Nobody at August 01, 2006 07:10 PM (BV7IP)

17 Thanks, Mr. N!

Posted by: Good Lt at August 01, 2006 07:17 PM (jWYAe)

18 Everyone should have already figured out the strategy of this government. The government should not be underestimated. First of all, they cunningly divide their enemies along political and class lines. That is why there is a divide between paleoconservates like Pat Buchanan and neoconservatives. In terms of 9/11, there is another gap between people like Michael Moore who believed that Saudia Arabia was behind the attacks and people like the libertarian Alex Jones who believe that 9/11 was an inside job. People often underestimate the government because they think that they are not militaristic enough. By now, people should know that the U.S. government perfers covert operations and the divide and conquer strategy. That is also why the Democrat Party serves as a buffer for the Republicans just like the Republicans served as Clinton's buffer to avoid fundamental criticism. As the Mossad slogan goes "By way of deception, thou shall do war". War is all about smokes and mirrors.

Posted by: anarchistmanifesto at August 01, 2006 07:32 PM (YsTfk)

19 Umm . . . Howard Zinn's classroom is down the hall, anarchist.

Posted by: Good Lt at August 01, 2006 07:40 PM (jWYAe)

20 Lt., don't you know that polysyllabic words, compound sentences, and paragraphs of more than two or three sentences are like kryptonite to the average person?

Posted by: Improbulus Maximus at August 02, 2006 01:05 PM (v3I+x)

21 I do. I'll put the fair warning for the kiddies in caps next time.

:-)

Posted by: Good Lt at August 02, 2006 01:13 PM (jWYAe)

22 Here's a question for you, Good Lt, since you like WWII comparisons:
 
I think you are correct that the war on terror is unlike anything we have ever fought before.  It necessitates a new way of thinking (and some old attention to counter insurgency).  But as we entered WWII, General George C. Marshall found it necessary to fire over a hundred generals and colonels, because he didn't think they were up to the job. 
 
In the war in Iraq, now in its fourth year...we have fired NO generals.  Not one.  Has it really been going that well?  Have there really been no mistakes?  Did we make that many more of them in 1941? 
 
How do you explain that?  (this is not original with me, it is from Ricks' book Fiasco)
 
Also, Derrida is not the father of deconstructionism.  You are thinking of DeMan, who was a Nazi symp in his early years, as was deconstructionism's godfather, Heidegger.  You might as well say that deconstructionism has right wing roots, although the status of the Nazis as 'right' also has to address the socialist aspects of their ugly thought.

Posted by: dj at August 02, 2006 04:21 PM (aqTJB)

23 Has it really been going that well?  Have there really been no mistakes?  Did we make that many more of them in 1941? 
 
How do you explain that?

Mistakes are made in every war - every war in human history. Mistakes are made every day in every part of the world in any manner of daily life. So what? That doesn't mean that you give up and run away because a mistake was made. You readjust and move on.


That was the only actual question in the comment.

Also, it doesn't also necessarily follow that just because "not one General" has been fired in Iraq that there must be for it own sake. I don't know what standard or logistic criterion you are using to measure their "successes" and "failures," and then arbitrarily declare that they must be fired because you and someone else says so, but that seems to be a matter of opinion and not an objective "fact." You certainly can't be using a historical standard, and you can't be using a bodycount rate argument. This is merely your opinion.

Which you are entitled to.


Posted by: Good Lt at August 02, 2006 08:41 PM (jWYAe)

24 Good one jd - trying to lay deconstructionism at the feet of modern American conservatives vie the Nazi's, who were authoritarian socialists, like you and all other lefturds- when it's the lefturds, like you, who use relativism and deconstructionism in your arguments. I really have to hand it to you; you're really working hard to earn a place at the head of the line. Don't think that your treason to civilization will go unpunished forever, because with every passing day, the efforts that you and other lefturds expend to further degrade our society and push it toward collapse is just another day close to justice, because when society collapses, we won't sit around gnashing our teeth and wringing our hands, but rather we'll be splitting skulls and stretching necks.

Posted by: Improbulus Maximus at August 04, 2006 09:50 AM (v3I+x)

25 I actually think (this is jd) that you didn't answer the one question, Good Lt.  It was not, why hasn't anyone been fired in Iraq, but why is that no one has been fired in Iraq, given the historical example of Marshall's cleaning house?  I certainly am aware that all human endeavors involve error and mistakes.  Or, as our ever so incompetent SecDef put it "stuff happens." 
 
IM--I agree that most purveyors of deconstruction have been of the left perspective, but their most successful converts have been on the right.  Think about the 24 year old college drop out who was a political appointee at NASA who was inserting "theory" after Big Bang, and removing all references to climate change from NASA press releases.  This guy, who couldn't spell science, was censoring the work of some of the most eminent climatologists and astro-physicists in the world.  That's the triumph of deconstructionism, right there. 

Posted by: afamiliarvoice at August 04, 2006 02:29 PM (aqTJB)

Hide Comments | Add Comment

Comments are disabled. Post is locked.
63kb generated in CPU 0.0373, elapsed 0.0549 seconds.
34 queries taking 0.0307 seconds, 180 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.