February 08, 2007

History - 1, Revisionists - 0

UPDATE: A vet who experienced this "rumored" leftwingnut BS during Vietnam responds in the comments.

Remember the wanker who tried to pretend that nobody spat upon vets in the Vietnam War, and that no vets of today were spat upon by anti-war activists?

"Sociologist" Jerry Lembcke claims that those stories were just rumors and the stuff of warmonger fantasy. He claims that they vets were lying, as well as the journalists who saw and reported it firsthand. Gee -glad we cleared that mystery up!

Jim Lindgren notes that Lembcke apparently never opened a vicious rightwing theocon paper of the day like the NYT, WaPo, etc., during the course of his "research." Facts and history are stubborn things when it comes to forming leftwing ubernarratives, and so they must be eliminated.

Jerry Lembcke - I award you no points, and may G-d have mercy on your soul.

Posted by: Good Lt. at 08:27 AM | Comments (36) | Add Comment
Post contains 152 words, total size 1 kb.

1 Does this mean that Lembcke is still on that "list"?

Posted by: Rusty at February 08, 2007 10:07 AM (JQjhA)

2 All history that Leftards don't like is "myth".  That's why they like to rewrite it.  I get that all the time with my Liberal brother.  And of course, Leftards think the burden's on US to disprove THEM, not the other way around.  Uhh, no.  That's not how it works, Leftards.

Posted by: Jesusland Carlos at February 08, 2007 10:17 AM (8e/V4)

3 So if there were no spitting incidents in Vietnam (which is false), what does it mean that we have people spitting on Iraq veterans now? If the spit-less protests Vietnam were 'good' does that mean the spit-full protests of Iraq are 'bad'?

Posted by: BohicaTwentyTwo at February 08, 2007 10:27 AM (oC8nQ)

4 Comrades,
 
     Well, I've held off on this subject for quite awhile, but I was one of those who alledgedly were not attacked just for being in uniform. I had both real blood and red paint thrown at me, called vicious and obscene names, and all because I was a part of a group wearing the uniform of our country.
 
   The throwers were members of the Young Socialist Alliance (and a rather large group of hangers-on, mostly stoners and clueless wannabes). It occured in 1974, on the campus of Utah State University.
 
   Respects,

Posted by: Gwedd at February 08, 2007 10:28 AM (wlNg1)

5 Was a vet ever spat upon Yes.
Was that something that occutrd more than say lightning killing a vet ? No my guess was it occured about the same number of times.
Were hippies regularly going out and spitting on and beating up vets in uniform ??
I can't recall ever hearing any vets saying anything to me personally that anything like that happened to him.
And what's up with the hyphen instead of the "O" in God ?
Is that the way you would want to see it in the Pledge of Allegiance ?

Posted by: JOHN RYAN at February 08, 2007 10:37 AM (TcoRJ)

6
I can't recall ever hearing any vets saying anything to me personally


So history is based on what was told to you "personally".  LOL.  Okies.

Posted by: Jesusland Carlos at February 08, 2007 11:33 AM (8e/V4)

7 When I was a young 'un, in my teens, my Civil Air Patrol squadron met at North Hall -- the ROTC building at the University of Michigan.  One time -- '68, '69 or so -- the meeting ended just as an anti-war protest march ended -- at North Hall.  My cadet squadron walked right out into it.
 
We were wearing modified Air Force blues (buttons and insignia were different).  The protesters swarmed us -- or rather they swarmed the females in our squadron and the younger, smaller male cadets (13 and 14 year olds).  They left the big, husky guys like me alone -- at least at first. 
 
We wrenched protest signs away from the ones careless enough to get close to us (rather than beating up on the women and children), and waded in, blindsiding the ones trying to beat up the weaker members of our squadron. (It wasn't only the guy cadets.  We had a valkyre -- Sandy, I seem to remember -- who worked ski patrol, and made my efforts look pretty pathetic.)  Like the boggies in the parody "Bored of the Rings" the anti-war twerps proved perfectly harmless if the did not outnumber you at least 20 to one and attack you from behind.  They retired from the scene long enough for us to rescue ours. 
 
Anyhow, the lesson I took from that was how cowardly the anti-war left is.  They went after the most helpless of us and fled as soon as the going got rough for them.

Posted by: Mark L at February 08, 2007 01:31 PM (ZO0u/)

8 So, what else from three and half decades ago can you  dredge up, Hanoi Jane mayhaps?
Are you trying to demoralize the troops by incinuating that this will be their treatment when they return?
The only one spitting on Iraq war vets is the pResident, who ferverishly  supports them (except his friends the Saudis supply ied's to the Sunni's) as long as they can be cannon fodder on the battle field, but if they are wounded or oherwise can no longer fight, then well the tax cuts to his buds come first, he has recently cut several more millions from the VA along twith massive layoffs of caseworkers.
If  you really supported vets you would be blogging about that not what happened 35 years ago.

Posted by: MnKat at February 08, 2007 02:38 PM (6yFiL)

9 MnKat, if the protestors and their supporters are claiming it never happened then, despite evidence otherwise that is ignored, then what will stop them from doing it now and several years down the road try to clean up their image the same way?  That is the point of writing about this now, especially given a growing number of reports that it is already happening here and now.

I tend to believe the new reports.  I've seen how these protestors behave in person, and a certain portion of them love to spit when they get worked up.  Try breaking through a communist 'checkpoint' (I can't think of a better word, since it was on a footpath, so it can't be a roadblock...) set up to funnel you to one of their speeches and see if they don't set up a gauntlet of lugies aimed in your direction; and that's if you're lucky and they don't try to smack you.  Ditto if a group recognizes you as "that guy who drives the SUV with the terrorist hunting permit bumpersticker" or you're wearing a field jacket that doesn't have a huge peace or anarchy sign on it.

Posted by: RanbaRal at February 08, 2007 03:04 PM (VvXII)

10 Funding for Veterans up 27% under Bush (but Liberals call it a cut)

http://www.factcheck.org/article.aspx?docID=144

Posted by: Jesusland Carlos at February 08, 2007 03:43 PM (8e/V4)

11 MnKunt:



Maybe you can explain why the overwhelming majority of vets like President Bush, but hate left-wing liars like you? I guess it's because they're too stupid and uneducated to know any better, right?


I'm sure you just love American servicemen. You would never feign concern for them to promote your unhinged BDS agenda. You're probably the type of weasel who keys any car she sees with an American flag or "support our troops" decal.


Are you mad because you don't get to spit on any baby killers?

Posted by: Jeff Bargholz at February 08, 2007 04:15 PM (Dt3sl)

12 JB
Am I mad 'cause I didn't get to spit at any "baby kllers", nope my brother was one of them in 'nam and Cambodia.

Jesusland Carlos
 that article is dated 2/18/2004
What Bush did while trying to get re-elected and what he did after are 2 different things, he isn't running for anything soon  and frankly doesn't give a damn. The layoffs are very recent

As to recent polls showing what % of vets support Bush again all I could find were articles from 2004 pre-election, nothing more recent and things have changed overall.

Posted by: MnKat at February 08, 2007 06:03 PM (6yFiL)

13 that article is dated 2/18/2004

MnKat,

you're right.  It is a bit dated.  So just because Leftards were lying then doesn't mean they're lying now?  And I should just take your word for it.  LOL.  Methinks not.

I've noticed Leftard claims about the VA are never accompanied by a source, which means I have to go check for myself.  And neither do you provide one!  So I went and checked again.

Apparently the budget cuts to the VA go to construction projects, while spending for actual veterans programs will go up by 10%.  Interestingly, the article also states that Democrats themselves admit the bill approves record levels of spending for veterans' and active duty health programs.  And this: The bill provides $25.4 billion for veterans' health programs, up $2.6 billion from the current fiscal year.

http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2006/05/19/politics/main1637556.shtml

Hmmm.

So who's getting laid off?  Construction workers?

Posted by: Jesusland Carlos at February 08, 2007 06:47 PM (8e/V4)

14 whoo, and who proposed charging a premium along with increased copays for veterans healthcare? why, that was bush in his 2007 budget proposal.

http://www.gpoaccess.gov/usbudget/fy07/pdf/budget/veterans.pdf

theres more, but i dont feel like pointing it out.


for ease of use, when you open that pdf, on the sidebar there its under Restraining spend and managing results, and then under that its proposed new expanded fees.

Posted by: Jake at February 08, 2007 08:28 PM (AeRA2)

15 theres more, but i dont feel like pointing it out.

Of course not.  I should just take your word for it!  LOL.  Nope.

I don't recall Liberals caring so much about our veterans when Bill Clinton tried to cut the VA budget by 1.1 billion dollars in 2000.  That cut was averted only thanks to a Republican congress.

But today Liberals cry about a $7 copay increase!  LOL.  Too funny.  According to your doc, the 2007 budget provides an 11.3-percent increase in funding for medical care over last year, and a 69.1-percent increase since President Bush took office."

So much for Bush's "layoffs" and budget "cuts".



Posted by: Jesusland Carlos at February 08, 2007 08:41 PM (8e/V4)

16 All healthcare costs are increasing for everyone in 2007 - Medicare and all.

And its a Democrat congress.

At least we know who gets the blame. Lawyers, and democrats.

Posted by: Good Lt at February 08, 2007 08:43 PM (D0TMh)

17 "Facts and history are stubborn thing... "

I'm soooo stealing that line Lt. :-)
Best
-GM

Posted by: Garduneh Mehr at February 08, 2007 08:53 PM (vixLB)

18 John Ryan: You are a lying piece of shit and your mother works nights at Hunters point.

Posted by: greyrooster at February 08, 2007 09:30 PM (ZAZT9)

19 MnKunt:


You don't care about murdered American soldiers, murdered Vietnamese, or murdered Iraqis any more than Hanoi Jane does. She's in the news again, dontcha know. She's blaming America for the vile acts of the terrorists, just like she blames America because North Vietnam invaded South Vietnam.


You're spouting doubletalk that's 30 years out of date--or it would be, if you leftist automatons were capable of producing an original thought.

Posted by: Jeff Bargholz at February 09, 2007 08:23 AM (Dt3sl)

20 Fake:


If you're going to lie about the President, try not to be so stupid as to provide links that expose your lies.


As if you give a rat's ass about veterans. You'll be flying the flag on Veteran's day, is that what you expect people to believe? You hate the troops almost as much as you hate Bush.

Posted by: Jeff Bargholz at February 09, 2007 08:28 AM (Dt3sl)

21 It's finally cleared up that it was a 'good' war! Whew, thanks for letting me feel good about Vietnam again.

Posted by: tbone at February 09, 2007 01:09 PM (HGqHt)

22 Vietnam was no different than the Korea.  An invasion from the north.  Only difference is we still had the stomach for a fight back in the 50s (i.e., the American left was still insignificant).

Posted by: Jesusland Carlos at February 09, 2007 01:14 PM (8e/V4)

23 First, they let some time go by.
 
Next, they start to say that bad treatment of returning vietnam vets was limited to a few isolated incedents.
 
Then they start to say that it was exaggerated, and then they say it never happened at all.
 
Then they start to abuse the vets returning from another war, and when they are caught ...
 
They say, "Oh thats just like the lies you told about troops being abused during vietnam! See how they make this stuff up?"
 
But all they want to do is spit on our most dedicated citizens, and get away with it!
 
My advice should you see one of these punks in action ......
 
Break their faces, and take your chances with the judge!
 
Our volunteers risk their lives, so you should be able to risk a little jail time, to stick up for them.
 
And I don't normally, blatantly recommend action which may get you in trouble with the law, but there is a higher law to consider.
 
USA, all the way!

Posted by: Michael Weaver at February 09, 2007 02:24 PM (2OHpj)

24 Michael Weaver:


The fine for knocking some punk's teeth out is usually the same as the fine for spitting on him.


Hell yes, we need to kick some ass.


Weebone: Do you want to discuss the Vietnam war with some real Americans? Didn't think so.

Posted by: Jeff Bargholz at February 09, 2007 04:06 PM (Dt3sl)

25 point to 1 conservative that you personally know were IN VIETNAM and support the war. Vietnam war i mean.






Posted by: Jake at February 09, 2007 08:45 PM (AeRA2)

26 Well I knew three, one of whom I rented a room from for 5 years. He talked all the time about how crappy they were treated when they came home. This was mostly during the 'moral majority' years of politics. They were politically conservative except for a few things, including rock and roll lyrics. You may recall those times if your old enough.                              USA, all the way!

Posted by: Michael Weaver at February 10, 2007 12:19 AM (2OHpj)

27 One of them had great stories about a period where the Battleship New Jersey was used to shell inland positions. I guess the collapsed whole tunnel complaxes with a few rounds. He said it looked like someone had dug instant trenches! pretty wild.  Anyway, they were all pretty hardcore anti Communist, and they knew they could have won if properly enabled. Our own people defeated them.          USA, all the way!

Posted by: Michael Weaver at February 10, 2007 12:23 AM (2OHpj)

28 We can talk about Vietnam anytime you want Jeff. Do you think it's possible to do so in an inteligent, articulate manner or will you immediately start calling people names if they don't want to circle jerk with you? Just curious but by 'real' american do you mean you are American Indian?

Posted by: tbone at February 10, 2007 05:15 AM (iK3oF)

29 Jakeass:


Just one? His name was Tran, and he served in the South Vietnamese army. Why? Do you know him?


Fucking imbecile.

Posted by: Jeff Bargholz at February 10, 2007 01:35 PM (Dt3sl)

30 Weebone:



Indians are not native to America, and you cant handle an intelligent, articulate conversation.

Posted by: Jeff Bargholz at February 10, 2007 01:36 PM (Dt3sl)

31 Well I knew three, one of whom I rented a room from for 5 years. He
talked all the time about how crappy they were treated when they came
home. This was mostly during the 'moral majority' years of politics.
They were politically conservative except for a few things, including
rock and roll lyrics. You may recall those times if your old
enough.                              USA, all the way!
micheal = intelligent articulate conversationist.

Jakeass:


Just one? His name was Tran, and he served in the South Vietnamese army. Why? Do you know him?


Fucking imbecile.

jeff = schoolyard bully.

Posted by: Jake at February 11, 2007 05:11 PM (AeRA2)

32 Jakeass=priggish hatemonger who can dish it out but cant take it.


Maybe you can explain how my knowing at least one Vietnam War veteran is relevant to anything whatsoever.


Then again, if you could, you wouldn't have resorted to an empty ad hominem.


The people like you who disaprove of America helping South Vietnam defend itself against the communist invaders don't care about how many of them were murdered and sent to reeducation gulags. That's because you have no morals.


Bullies don't allow others to talk bback, by the way. Grow up.



Posted by: Jeff Bargholz at February 12, 2007 06:37 PM (Dt3sl)

33 Bullies don't allow others to talk bback, by the way. Grow up.

oh what the fuck are you gonna do, huh? c'mon big man. take me on.

Posted by: Jake at February 12, 2007 09:41 PM (AeRA2)

34 Jakeass:


Maybe you can explain how my knowing at least one Vietnam War veteran is relevant to anything whatsoever.



How was abandoning 3 million people to horrible deaths a good thing? Were the countless others deprived of property, thrown in gulags, or forced to flee in boats better off because scum like you convinced America to abandon them to their woeful fate?


Why would allowing the terrorists to transmogrify Iraq into a dystopian staging ground for international terrorism be a good thing? Do you enjoy human misery, or are you a blind doctrinaire?


Have I prevented you from talking back, little man? You've had free reign to make a complete ass out of yourself, something you've done quite thoroughly. You bray your ignorance and stupidity with each comment you make, totally unimpeded by me.


You're a mass of idiotic contradictions who chooses to live in his own delusional world. One were you're a masterdebater world politics should be governed by emotion. Wipe your chin and take your meds, retard, before you put your own eye out with your elbow.

Posted by: Jeff Bargholz at February 13, 2007 03:01 PM (Dt3sl)

35 One where you're a masterdebater, and world politics should be governed by emotion.

Posted by: Jeff Bargholz at February 13, 2007 03:02 PM (Dt3sl)

36 Jake the fake: I would love to take you on. Punks like you need a proper ass whupping sooner or later. Makes to look at reality. I would make you look real long.

Posted by: greyrooster at February 14, 2007 05:27 PM (MK5KV)

Hide Comments | Add Comment

Comments are disabled. Post is locked.
51kb generated in CPU 0.0139, elapsed 0.0299 seconds.
34 queries taking 0.0203 seconds, 191 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.