December 14, 2006

Cato : The Libertarian Vote

I've been of the opinion that libertarian disillusionment with the GOP had a lot to do with Republican losses in 2006, but I haven't had the hard data to back up that opinion.

David Boaz and David Kirby of Cato have broken down the numbers. Their conclusion:

For those on the trail of the elusive swing voter, it may be most notable that the libertarian vote shifted sharply in 2004. Libertarians preferred George W. Bush over Al Gore by 72 to 20 percent, but Bush's margin dropped in 2004 to 59-38 over John Kerry. Congressional voting showed a similar swing from 2002 to 2004. Libertarians apparently became disillusioned with Republican overspending, social intolerance, civil liberties infringements, and the floundering war in Iraq. If that trend continues into 2006 and 2008, Republicans will lose elections they would otherwise win.
I agree with theis general conclusions above, but I doubt concern of "civil liberties infringements" carries anywhere near as much weight as rampant overspending coupled with the perception that the Republican leadership is at the beck and call of Jerry Falwell. I could be wrong.

So far, I see approximately zero evidence that the Republican leadership "gets it" as regards the disillusionment of the libertarians. If my perception is correct, we may be looking at another round of Democrat wins in 2008--which could give us four years of President Hillary. Good times ... not.

Posted by: Ragnar at 01:16 AM | Comments (12) | Add Comment
Post contains 235 words, total size 2 kb.

1 If the Republicans would go back to using "Conscience of a Conservative" as their playbook, they might be able to recover. But at this point, I know no libertarian who trusts the GOP as far as they can throw them. (Of course they don't trust the Democrats either...)

Posted by: Michael Hampton at December 14, 2006 02:12 AM (FVbj6)

2 Look at the Republicans, like Mike DeWine who lost while being incumbents.

They lost by being RINO on civil issues. Mike DeWine had an F rating from the NRA for his stance on the Right to Keep and Bear Arms.

Mike DeWine lost, even though he had incumbency working in his favor.

Where Democrats won the Democrats who did the winning were usually those who were not with their own party on the RKBA.

This is a lesson both parties need to learn. A politician can win while being anti-gun in New York or California. Everywhere else you are shooting yourself in the foot with every anti-gun vote you make. You are slitting your political wrist with every dime you accept from anti-gun groups.

Learn that lesson or learn to like the taste of defeat.

Posted by: GI Joe at December 14, 2006 07:17 AM (0euLV)

3 Ah! But we have two years to turn it around. Or more properly two years for the democrats to show how screwed up and weak they are. The problem with being in office in admitting to and correcting your own mistakes. Their have been mistakes. Hindsight is 20/20. The dems say the war in Iraq was wrong. Yet it should be noticed that they were for it as much as anyone. The leaders the dems are pushing (with the exexption of Barrack Husssein Jomama Obama) for electiion at this time all were in agreement with the war. The dems may well expand the war now if we let them. Bring on draft etc: I think they will self destruct in the next two years. They are incapable of finding real leadership. To many ties, with the unions, black caucus, minorities, ultra libs, gun control, etc:

Posted by: Greyrooster at December 14, 2006 07:54 AM (vLeHe)

4 Hey..I'm a little l libertarian but I held my nose and voted for Bush.

Posted by: Randman at December 14, 2006 08:23 AM (Sal3J)

5 What choice did you have?

Posted by: Greyrooster at December 14, 2006 08:49 AM (vLeHe)

6 And what do you think would happen to the GOP if they lost the social conservative vote?  They would go extinct.

But I'd appreciate if you could give me an example of what you mean by the Bush being at the "beck and call of Jerry Falwell."

Posted by: Jesuslad Carlos at December 14, 2006 10:41 AM (8e/V4)

7 "Libertarians preferred George W. Bush over Al Gore by 72 to 20 percent,
but Bush's margin dropped in 2004 to 59-38 over John Kerry."



It could be nothing more complex than the appeal of a "leader" with a
big chin appearing on the stage, and someone who the media assured Joe
Voter was "intelligent" and "seasoned".



Don't be too quick to overestimate the general public - and this cuts
both ways; much as I'd like to think Bush's win in 2000 was a
repudiation of democrats and their misbehavior, I suspect it had more
to do with Gore's incredible lack of camera-friendly features pitted
against Bush's "meh, could be worse" image.






Posted by: Scott at December 14, 2006 01:24 PM (z2RMg)

8 Social "intolerance"?  As opposed to what?  Social "anything
goes"?  A complete intolerance for simple criticism is the problem
- for things like abortion up to 8 months and 29 days, for throwing
pies and salad dressing at any speakers anywhere you don't like, for
traveling to Venezuela to hug and kiss dictators, for picketing
funerals with hateful sloganeering, for attending "holocaust denial"
conventions, for advocating illegal immigration.



So far as I can see, no one has been charged with crimes for any of
these and more ridiculous behaviors under a republican administration.



It would seem that certain people have an exclusive on intolerance.  And it's not just a "republican thing".

Posted by: Oyster at December 14, 2006 01:59 PM (SCVhh)

9 What choice did you have?

Exactly.

Posted by: Randman at December 14, 2006 03:01 PM (Sal3J)

10 "What choice did you have?" Yes, it is the point of the problem.

Phoney Republicans In Name Only vs. Democrats Who Talk Conservative.

Over-spending, bad government either way.

I think, though, that the real story of the last election was that voters aren't going for Old-style Democrats and they aren't going for New-style Republicans. They are going for people they hope will walk their talk.

The Dems who won have to do that now. Their honeymoon will be shorter than the two years until the next election.

Former Speaker of the House Pelosi (she may as well get used to the longer title now) will be back trying to ride herd on the Democrats who are left after the 2008 election.

Posted by: GI Joe at December 14, 2006 09:12 PM (0euLV)

11 Despite all the hype we libertarians aren't going anywheres. Yeah, we're pissed off at the GOP for passing that idiotic Internet Gaming Ban two weeks before the election. (What in God's name were they thinking???).

But all this talk by Cato and others about an emerging "Libertarian-Democrat" alliance is just bunk.

How does one explain that the Republican Liberty Caucus (www.rlc.org), just had one of its best years ever? The RLC is better organized, has more members, and had more victories in 2006 than practically ever before.

Plus, four libertrarian-leaning Republican Governors were elected: Sarah Palin in Alaska, Butch Otter in Idaho, Charlie Crist in Florida and Mark Sanford in SC.

How one can say that "libertarian Republicanism" is on the ropes, at the very moment when it is succeeding beyond the movement's wildest imaginations, is beyond me.

Eric Dondero, Founder
Republican Liberty Caucus

www.mainstreamlibertarian.com









Posted by: Eric Dondero at December 15, 2006 09:39 AM (hvcY5)

12 "Same old" corruption and overspending defeated the Republicans.

Who is this "Jerry Falwell"?

Posted by: Phillep at December 16, 2006 12:54 PM (Sq5Wg)

Hide Comments | Add Comment

Comments are disabled. Post is locked.
36kb generated in CPU 0.0118, elapsed 0.0477 seconds.
34 queries taking 0.0411 seconds, 167 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.