September 09, 2006

ACLU Thwarted in Attack on Boy Scouts

Cross-posted from The Dread Pundit Bluto

In a victory for common sense and common decency, the Oregon Supreme Court has overturned a lower court decision that would have barred Boy Scouts from public schools. From the Boy Scouts of America legal issues website:

Boy Scouts of America welcomes today’s decision from the Oregon Supreme Court declaring that the Portland Public School District did not discriminate against an atheist student by permitting Boy Scouts to make presentations and distribute informational flyers.

An atheist mother represented by the ACLU complained that allowing Boy Scouts to recruit in public schools on the same basis as other groups discriminated against her atheist son who attends Portland public schools. In today’s decision reversing a lower court decision, the Oregon Supreme Court emphatically concluded that “nothing that occurred in any public school program, service, or activity was discriminatory at all.”

“Giving Boy Scouts equal access is not discrimination,” said Scouting spokesperson Robert H. Bork, Jr., “it is the law.”

Via Jay at Stop the ACLU who has more on the story.

Posted by: Bluto at 08:52 PM | Comments (38) | Add Comment
Post contains 181 words, total size 1 kb.

1 Bluto,
Pardon this unrelated comment but I thought you Jawa's might be interested in this
http://biz.yahoo.com/prnews/060909/nysa018.html?.v=24

Posted by: Garduneh Mehr at September 09, 2006 11:45 PM (Bp6wV)

2 Which religion is worse, atheism, or Islam?

Posted by: Hucbald at September 10, 2006 12:28 AM (JkNHw)

3 I'm agnostic and this is really disgusting. That woman is jut as bad as any religion jerk trying to push her views on everyone else.

Posted by: Mr. Mxyzptlk at September 10, 2006 01:43 PM (H7GX1)

4 Another blow against these rotten selfcentered atheists trying to force themselves on us now i hope they give that stupid MICHEAL NEWDOW a swift kick right in his backside and make him hang his head in shame and lets screw the ACLU

Posted by: sandpiper at September 10, 2006 02:15 PM (n7v4a)

5 As an atheist I'm disgusted by this woman's actions. The scouts are an incredible organization. I would not be the man I am today without them.

The actions of these and similar atheists make the whole lot of us look like lunatics. Like clinic bombers and the Christians or Islamic terrorists and normal Muslims.

"Which religion is worse, atheism, or Islam?"

I can't even count how many ignorant concepts are embodied in that single statement.

Posted by: Rich at September 10, 2006 02:58 PM (89Rw1)

6 The question would have been better phrased, "Which faith tradition is worse..." - atheism is as much a matter of faith in the unknowable as any religion.

Posted by: The Dread Pundit Bluto at September 10, 2006 03:53 PM (vBK4C)

7 Yeah, clinic bombers, all 3 or 4 of them years ago, and Islamic terrorists, thousands of whom are busy killing and maiming in the name of Islam as we speak, from such varied locations as Pakistan, India, Thailand, Indonesia, Malaysia, Timor, Russia, Israel, Iraq, Iran, Sudan, Somalia, Chad, Kenya, Saudi Arabia, Afghanistan, and I could go on and on. Great comparison, Richie, and you have now taken moral equivalency to a new high, or should I say low.

Posted by: jesusland joe at September 10, 2006 03:57 PM (rUyw4)

8 Jesusland Joe,
Granted, I used too blunt an instrument to prove my point but, the fact remains. There are unfortunately fanatics in all schools of thought. That's all I was trying to convey.

Posted by: Rich at September 10, 2006 04:15 PM (89Rw1)

9 "The question would have been better phrased, "Which faith tradition is worse..." - atheism is as much a matter of faith in the unknowable as any religion."

I don't consider atheism a matter of faith at all. I came to atheism through a lack of empirical evidence supporting any of the world's modern religions. All atheists I know think roughly the same way.

It's not a belief there isn't a god. It's knowing there's no evidence there is. Maybe since I'm not completely closed minded that's more atheism with a bit of agnostic thrown in.

Posted by: Rich at September 10, 2006 04:20 PM (89Rw1)

10

 Yes, Rich, you used a cruise missile to kill a fly. And your point is about as valid as your comparison is skewed.


Posted by: jesusland joe at September 10, 2006 05:03 PM (rUyw4)

11 Jesusland Joe,
You're kidding, right? What precisely about the statement "There are unfortunately fanatics in all schools of thought." is so insane?

I'll readily admit when I'm wrong but it's not like that idea is completely out in left field....

Posted by: Rich at September 10, 2006 06:32 PM (89Rw1)

12 Sorry Rich, but unless you're an agnostic, you're taking it on faith. Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.

Posted by: The Dread Pundit Bluto at September 10, 2006 06:40 PM (vBK4C)

13 The Dread Pundit Bluto,
You are correct. I suppose I am agnostic although, I think the atheism comes in when I think about how likely it is that there ever will be evidence.

I'm not the best when it comes to labels anyway...

Posted by: Rich at September 10, 2006 06:54 PM (89Rw1)

14 Not in Left field, Rich, just saying that a fundamentalist Christian might want to display a creche on the Courthouse lawn, or perhaps want creation taugh alongside evolution, not exclusively, or perhaps want a moment of silence, or a prayer at a school function, or oppose the handing out of condoms at school. These kinds of things are harmless when you compare them to people who are cutting the heads off people, or murdering schoolchildren, or using children as suicide bombers, etc. 

Posted by: jesusland joe at September 10, 2006 08:10 PM (rUyw4)

15 It's not fundamentalism that I'm talking about. While I disagree with every last one of those things (except the condom one) they are not the actions of fanatics.

Christianity's fanaticism is largely in it's past (inquisition and crusades). With the example of the clinic bombings I was merely looking for a contemporary example. I figured if I cited the crusades (more equivalent to the trouble with Islam today) I'd be flamed for dredging up the past that's not relevant today.

Posted by: Rich at September 10, 2006 08:23 PM (89Rw1)

16 "The question would have been better phrased, "Which faith tradition is
worse..." - atheism is as much a matter of faith in the unknowable as
any religion.


Posted by:
The Dread Pundit Bluto at September 10, 2006 03:53 PM"


MEGA-DITTOS!


Posted by: QC at September 10, 2006 09:32 PM (ebe/J)

17 Check out the record of the only officially atheist states:  The communists.  HUNDREDS OF MILLIONS slaughtered in the name of no-God.


Posted by: QC at September 10, 2006 09:36 PM (ebe/J)

18 QC, as I'm sure you know, there was far more to the communists than atheism. No one in their right mind would look to them as an example.

Hell, even I don't believe in a state void of religion like the communists. I believe simply in religious freedom as is envisioned in the US constitution: Everyone is free to practice their religion (or lack there of) without interference from the government. The only limitation being that they can't intrude on the rights of those that don't believe as they do.

This may come as a shock but, "atheist" and "immoral murderous sociopath" are not the same thing.

Posted by: Rich at September 10, 2006 10:09 PM (89Rw1)

19 One other point. Your number of "hundreds of millions" sounded wildly innaccurate. I checked around online, the highest estimate I saw was about 62 million for the period of 1917 to 1987.

This is still obviously a horrendous atrocity however, just pulling numbers out of thin air to make an argument is bad form at best.

Posted by: Rich at September 10, 2006 10:14 PM (89Rw1)

20 120 million known from what I can find.  Starvation caused by communisim counts too.

Regardless.  The athiestic governments of the 20th century take the death toll crown.  Irrefutable.

Posted by: QC at September 11, 2006 01:09 AM (ebe/J)

21 Looking further I see numbers up to 140 million.  That would be 1.4 Hundred Million. More than 1 is plural, hence the "s" in hundred's of millions".

Posted by: QC at September 11, 2006 01:26 AM (ebe/J)

22 QC, I'll agree with a caveat.

All the governments you're talking about were essentially rooted in the USSR. It was basically one government and one ideology. A sample size of one is statistically meaningless and easily leads to false conclusions.

For example, the starvation you cite, was obviously not caused by atheism. Many deeply religious nations have and still do face widespread famine and starvation. Even the US was not immune from that.

So implying that you can learn about atheism from the actions of the Communists of the 20th century is just plain wrong.

Communists were atheists, yes. Communists did horrible things, yes. There's no link between the two.

If you still think there is a connection, ponder this. Hitler was a Christian. His speeches were filled with Christian ideology. He even claimed to be doing what he was doing for Christianity and found "support" for what he was doing in the Bible. Even knowing that, no rational person would try to equate the Nazis and Christianity. They really have nothing to do with each other.

See what I mean?

Posted by: Rich at September 11, 2006 01:28 AM (89Rw1)

23 Btw, I was looking for direct deaths: murders, executions, assassinations, deaths in wars, prisons, work camps. I wasn't counting things like starvation since that can happen under any form of government.

Counting starvation I have no doubt "hundreds of millions" would apply.

Posted by: Rich at September 11, 2006 01:30 AM (89Rw1)

24 You claim Hitler was a Christian.  This is folly. It is refuted by far too many sources, includiing his own words.  He hated the church and wanted it destroyed so his power would be total.

Even if he had been Christian (which he was not) I understand your attempt at the analogy, but it fails.  For I can site many instances that go against your example.  What other Godless states could you point to?

You can imagine that it was just a coincidence that they chose to crush religion, and to follow communist ideology... that the next band of merry atheists would get it right... but there are no examples to point to.


Posted by: QC at September 11, 2006 01:43 AM (ebe/J)

25 QC, sorry, it's late, I mis-spoke, I should have said
"Hitler CLAIMED to be a Christian."

You are right, he hated the church, simply because he saw it as a threat to his absolute power. He did however see it as a useful tool to control the people. He did wrap his rhetoric in Christian ideology and many people followed him on that fact alone.

Now, as for other atheist countries. You're right, there aren't any. Atheism is only recently gaining any kind of acceptance and the whole communism thing really damaged the acceptance it had at that point.

What I can tell you is that myself and every other atheist I know would never consider "crushing religion" to be a positive thing. Speaking for myself, my "utopia" would be a secular government with complete freedom of religion for the people.

I can honestly say anyone advocating soviet style government-enforced athiesm is a fringe lunatic. Unfortunately, due to our lovely media, it's always the fringe lunatics that get the attention.

I know that doesn't answer your call for another example but, drawing conclusions on a sample of two would be just as flawed, no matter how great an example I could find. =)

Posted by: Rich at September 11, 2006 01:56 AM (89Rw1)

26 Good for the Scouts. Some people (like the athiest lady) just have too big a stick up their rear about everything.

If it was the Dan Beard Council, though, she may have had a case based on rampant douchebaggery, neglect, and possibly torture.

Posted by: Ranba Ral at September 11, 2006 02:27 AM (VvXII)

27 Rich, you can't exclude starvation from the statistics. Stalin used famine as a tool to reduce the peasant population. As they began to die, he ordered his men to seize shovels, so that the corpses couldn't be properly buried to prevent pestilence.

Posted by: The Dread Pundit Bluto at September 11, 2006 09:31 AM (vBK4C)

28 The dread pundit bluto,
You are correct. I see your point.

Posted by: Rich at September 11, 2006 03:53 PM (89Rw1)

29 Rich, one other point, and I'll leave you in peace. I do not consider the Crusades to be Christian fanatism in the sense that Christianity had been under constant attack from Muslims for 400 years prior to the Crusades. Self-defense is not fanatism.

Posted by: jesusland joe at September 11, 2006 05:21 PM (rUyw4)

30 The fanaticism comes into play when you consider the whole "convert or die," "kill the non-believers," and my favorite "we need to cleanse christian lands of muslims" aspects to many of the crusades.

Also, self-defense flies out the window the instant the crusaders took new territory (which they did in most of the crusades). Most of the crusades were used for political gain by various parties as well.

Honestly, while I know all about the fighting between the sides prior to the crusades, I don't know of any historians that say the crusades were simply justifiable self-defense.


Posted by: Rich at September 11, 2006 06:27 PM (89Rw1)

31 I think atheism and Christianity are similar in that there is no evidence to support either. However Christianity does offer hope. And there are signs that it is truth whereas atheism offers nothing but a void.

Posted by: Last gasp Larry at September 11, 2006 10:41 PM (Dd86v)

32 heh... umm, how are there "signs" but no evidence supporting Christian beliefs? Also, the lack of evidence supporting Christianity itself certainly goes further supporting atheism than to the contrary.

As for Christianity offering hope, it all depends on your point of view. I don't feel hope when people replace rationality with faith. I don't feel hope when some lunatic is on TV preaching hatred and bigotry in God's name.

I do however feel hope when people are able to set aside their religious differences and treat each other decent through a respect of their shared humanity and not a threat of eternal damnation.

Posted by: Rich at September 11, 2006 10:58 PM (89Rw1)

33 Just so I'm not misunderstood, I don't think hatred and bigotry are part of christianity, it's just preached by people that don't understand their own faith.

Posted by: Rich at September 11, 2006 11:54 PM (89Rw1)

34 I don't feel hope when people replace rationality with faith.

Rich, all logic, all science, all rationality is built on faith.  Without faith all is chaos.  It starts with the faith that your thoughts and senses are real and your own, and not illusion or madness or some matrix-like machine.

Everything is built from those unprovable points. On faith.


Posted by: QC at September 12, 2006 01:28 AM (ebe/J)

35 Well, there are signs and prophesies. And events are unfolding as predicted in the Bible. And it seems to me unlikely that our Creator would leave us without a road-map. To be an atheist  requires more effort and constant denial.

Posted by: Last gasp Larry at September 12, 2006 06:38 AM (Dd86v)

36 Not if you accept the fact that there is no creator.

Posted by: greyrooster at September 12, 2006 07:42 AM (YyQDW)

37 greyrooster, interesting point. I suppose, yes, if you get down to a low enough level we all take things on faith. Yes, I do make the assumption that my senses are not failing me and giving me accurate information.

However, once you get into the human realm of thought and free will, then larger questions come up. It's these larger questions that I prefer to answer rationally while others answer them with faith.

Last gasp larry, events are also unfolding as predicted by Nostradamus and some raving homeless guy who pisses himself multiple times a day. Should we start worshiping them? Many, many authors have made predictions over the years and sometimes it looks like world events can be crowbarred in to fit. That doesn't mean they predicted it. If you make very broad predictions they will always fit sometime.


Posted by: Rich at September 12, 2006 10:12 AM (89Rw1)

38 I don't think the prophecies are that broad, they are fairly specific. Brother Rich come into the light. Salvation is awaiting you! Thirst no more!   :-)

Posted by: Last gasp Larry at September 12, 2006 11:25 PM (Dd86v)

Hide Comments | Add Comment

Comments are disabled. Post is locked.
50kb generated in CPU 0.0511, elapsed 0.1055 seconds.
34 queries taking 0.0883 seconds, 193 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.